Murderer sues for the right to read Cosmopolitan

Print

Sat, 26 Jun 2010 6:00p.m.

The issue had a feature on fake breasts

The issue had a feature on fake breasts

By Janika Ter Ellen

A convicted murderer is taking the Department of Corrections to court for confiscating his Cosmopolitan magazine.

Stephen Hudson is serving a life sentence with a minimum non-parole of 16 years for the cold-blooded murder of 22-year-old Nicholas Pike in 2002.

Mr Pike was last seen in Mt Maunganui in March 2002, but his body's never been found.

Now, his killer has filed High Court papers against Corrections for stripping him of the Cosmopolitan he was reading, something his victim's family just can't believe.

"What human rights did Nicholas have?" asks Evelyn Pike, Mr Pike's mother.

"Stephen Hudson killed him execution style in cold blood. He didn't consider his human rights - how can he be worrying about his own?"

The particular edition of the women's magazine is thought to contain pictures of fake breasts, comparing them with natural ones.

It is understood Hudson will use the 'Boobs on Bikes' event to bolster his legal argument, asking if kids could look at breasts on the street, why couldn't he look at them in the privacy of his Rimutaka prison cell?

Hudson's mother Catherine billing told the Dominion Post: "It's a simple magazine, it's not pornographic or R18 or anything. There are lots of good articles in them."

The Corrections Act prohibits inmates' access to pornographic material, and gives prison managers the power to ban anything he or she deems "objectionable".

But that doesn't mean prison officers can just do what they want.

"If he deems the Cosmopolitan magazine to be objectionable, there has to be some kind of rational connection or reason for that, otherwise it could very well be a breach of Mr Hudson's right to freedom of expression," says Michael Bott, human rights lawyer.

Corrections is refusing to comment.

3 News

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

09 Aug 2010 01:02a.m.

Nicole wrote:

he murdered someone, he shouldnt be allowed any luxories at all let alone pack a tantrum like a two year old because it was taken off him. He deserves to rot in that cell for life and not see the light off day again. Where's the justice

28 Jun 2010 02:27p.m.

Jim wrote:

scum, most requests by the scum in prison should be laughed at. I can't agree more with some of the seniments here, they gave up their rights as humans when they committed the crimes. Should they be housed in filthy conditions, should they be given bread and water.. maybe not. Should they be given playstations, tvs, demand specific magazines, bugger off crim! get a real job.

27 Jun 2010 04:31p.m.

Chris wrote:

Good on corrections staff, as long as they are consistent I don't mind one bit.

27 Jun 2010 03:01p.m.

george wrote:

The problem here guys is that some greasy suited legal aid lawyer..is likely to have encouraged him to make the claim.

27 Jun 2010 08:28a.m.

BT wrote:

This society is obsessed with the civil rights of convicted murderers, while averting its gaze from the life sentences imposed by them on the families of their victims. So a cold-blooded murderer has a hissy fit over his magazine being confiscated? Cry me a river, Hudson. You're in the right place and not nearly for long enough.

26 Jun 2010 11:57p.m.

Woger wrote:

Tax payers should not have to pay for this scum bag to waste court time. He shouldn't be able to waste court time at his own or our expense over this trifling issue.

26 Jun 2010 11:19p.m.

JD wrote:

Let me guess, this court action this killer is taking against the Corrections Department, will be paid for under legal aid. So our taxpayer money is going to line the pocket of some lawyer, just because some criminal wants to get his jollies off over a womans magazine. Great system we have in NZ...

26 Jun 2010 08:05p.m.

roobs wrote:

what about the victims rights who he killed?

26 Jun 2010 06:46p.m.

katrina wrote:

When you are imprison that long I can imagine thet the slightest thinkg would make them horny. Last thing prisoners need is an increase in sodomy due to a set of boobs.
They shouldn't even be allowed magazines. Magazines are luxury that a lot of people can't afford on the outside.