• Full Story

NIWA faces court action over data accuracy

Print

Sun, 15 Aug 2010 4:00p.m.

John Morgan, CEO of NIWA (NZPA)

John Morgan, CEO of NIWA (NZPA)

The country's state-owned weather and atmospheric research body is being taken to court in a challenge over the accuracy of its data used to calculate global warming.

The New Zealand Climate Science Coalition said it had lodged papers with the High Court asking the court to invalidate the official temperatures record of the National Institute of Water and Atmospheric Research (Niwa).

The lobby of climate sceptics and ACT Party have long criticised Niwa over its temperature data, which Niwa says is mainstream science and not controversial, and the raw data publicly available.

The coalition said the New Zealand Temperature Records (NZTR) were the historical base of NIWA's advice to the Government on issues relating to climate change.

Coalition spokesman Bryan Leyland said many scientists believed although the earth had been warming for 150 years, it had not heated as much as Government archives claimed.

He said the New Zealand Meteorological Service had shown no warming during the past century but Niwa had adjusted its records to show a warming trend of 1degC. The warming figure was high and almost 50 percent above the global average, said Mr Leyland.

The coalition said the 1degC warming during the 20th century was based on adjustments taken by Niwa from a 1981 student thesis by then student Jim Salinger, a Niwa employee who was later sacked after talking to the media without permission.

The Salinger thesis was subjective and untested and meteorologists more senior to Dr Salinger did not consider the temperature data should be adjusted, it said.

The coalition would ask the court to find Niwa's New Zealand Temperature Record invalid.

It would also seek a court declaration preventing Niwa from using the NZTR when it advised the Government or any other body on global climate issues. It would also ask the court to order Niwa to produce a full and accurate NZTR.

Mr Leyland said Niwa was refusing to repudiate the NZTR to avoid political embarrassment and loss of public confidence.

A substantive hearing was expected later this year.

(Seeking comment from Niwa)

NZPA

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

10 Sep 2010 12:18a.m.

G wrote:

The skeptics data is always falling to bits under scrutiny.
The last time Monckton toured Aussie he was making approx 150 factual errors per seminar.

15 Aug 2010 08:32p.m.

V wrote:

Its mistakes are buried not headlined, Its dissenters are silenced not praised, No expenditure is questioned no secret is revealed....

15 Aug 2010 06:30p.m.

cyril wrote:

It is about time this was done. Its about time the climate change advocates data was pair reviewed by unbiased scientists and they had to be accountable for what they say. You will notice that it isnt the sceptics data that is falling to bits under scruteny.

15 Aug 2010 05:37p.m.

TWE wrote:

Excellent, I hope they expose NIWA's data fudging. NIWA must be wetting themselves right now, they booted Salinger out when they realised he was not behaving as a proper scientist should but their refusal to come clean and admit their incompetence could be their undoing.

15 Aug 2010 05:32p.m.

V wrote:

Wriggle wriggle.