• Full Story

NZ Election 2011: Labour strongholds slip away

Print

Sun, 27 Nov 2011 7:12a.m.

Phil Goff told party faithful "It wasn't our time".

Phil Goff told party faithful "It wasn't our time".

Labour had its nose bloodied in key seats in Saturday's election that just a few years ago it would have considered safe as houses.

Despite running a strong campaign in the closing weeks its share of the party vote slipped from 34 per cent to 27 per cent.

Diminished Labour Party 'bloodied but not defeated'

VIDEO: John Key’s post-victory speech
Key toasts three more years
Banks takes Epsom, Brash steps down
Winston Peters’ triumphant return
Greens celebrate record result

But while the party vote took a hammering, there were some victories in the electorates; Damien O'Connor won back West Coast-Tasman from National and Rino Tirikatene the southern Maori seat of Te Tai Tonga from the Maori Party.

Chris Hipkins in Rimutaka increased his majority from 753 to 3126 but that was about all the good news there was for Labour.

In a remarkable result, Brendon Burns and Nicky Wagner were tied on 10,493 votes each but that only shows how far Labour has slipped in a seat that had held since 1946 and won in 2005 with a margin of nearly 8000.

Labour-National tie in Christchurch Central

Special votes will decide if Mr Burns can hold onto the seat by the skin of his teeth.

Immediately to the north, in Waimakariri, Kate Wilkinson defeated the incumbent Clayton Cosgrove, whose majority had been slowly slipping since 2002, when he held a majority of 10,000.

Labour could not retake Auckland Central, with Jacinda Ardern coming within 535 votes of National's Nikki Kaye and Carmel Sepuloni ran Paula Bennett close in Waitakere, but was 349 shy at the end of the count.

Former Labour Party president Andrew Little did not make much of an impression on National's Jonathan Young, who increased his majority from 105 to 4130 in the former Labour stronghold of New Plymouth.

Charles Chauvel was meant to run United Future leader Peter Dunne close in the Wellington seat of Ohariu, but Dunne actually increased his winning margin, eventually winning by 1646 votes.

Despite the losses, party leader Phil Goff is not stepping down immediately but will advise his caucus on Tuesday of his intentions.

Labour was "a bit bloodied but not defeated" and vowed the party would be back in 2014 to beat National, he said.

NZN

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

27 Nov 2011 06:10p.m.

matty wrote:

Ahh Ben.. It hasn't worked buddy. Winston has almost no power in government. If you were a smart lefty, you would have given your vote to Labour or the greens. Anyway you can feel safe in the knowledge that the best party won on the night! ;-)

27 Nov 2011 09:09a.m.

ben wrote:

IT STILL WAS NOT 19% THAT NATIONAL GOT IN 2002 IN OTHER LAB STRONG HOLDS LAB DID WELL LIKE RIMUTAKA 10 SWING BACK TO THE LAB MP , . THE MEDIA WILL JUST PITA OUT OF STEAM NOW THEIR LOVE FEST WITH KEY IS 5 YEAS OLD NOW I BELEAVE THEY DONT HAVE THE HEART NOR THE STAMINA TO KEEP IT UP ANOTHER 3 YEARS . AND THE TIDE WILL BE DUE BACK LAB WAY IN 3 YEARS . AND AWESOME WINSTON PETERS LOL .I VOTED PETERS TO SPITE THE MEDIA AND JOHN KEY LOL . AND ITS WORKED .

27 Nov 2011 08:18a.m.

erik wrote:

seems whale oil has got hold of photo's showing some parties with illegal campaign boards up on election day, hope tv3 will follow this up

27 Nov 2011 07:58a.m.

erik wrote:

labour lost this by looking like a fractured party. If you note the seats that were lost, they are seats where the politician refused to carry the labour brand. i do believe they are defeated, i believe we will see in the next election greens continue to take from labour.

27 Nov 2011 07:50a.m.

eddie wrote:

Hmmm I hear it's Labours worst result since the party formed almost 100yrs ago, I believe they only got 25% in their first election as a party...is that right?
I see all you leftie posters being bemused as to the polls showing National so far ahead, and saying 'all my friends/family/workmates are voting labour'...seems you either have to:
1. Widen your circle of friends
2. Realise people never really truely divulge who they are voting for, say labour to keep you sweet, but vote National as they have intelligence!
:) :) :)
WE WON YOU LOST, EAT THAT! (Michael Cullen, 2005)