NZ on tsunami alert all day, but some don't care

Print

Sun, 28 Feb 2010 5:21p.m.

People gathered on some beaches to watch the tsunami, while vessels ventured out to deeper water as a precaution

People gathered on some beaches to watch the tsunami, while vessels ventured out to deeper water as a precaution

By Emma Joliff and Juliet Speedy

All of New Zealand's coast was on tsunami alert for much of the day with particular fears for low lying areas on the East Coast.

While many people complied with authorities' orders to flee to higher ground, some were more brazen in their defiance.

At Long Bay, on the North Shore, visitors to the beach were turned back by rangers and police were warning people of the potential danger at Mission Bay.

But fishermen were undeterred.

“There seem to be a lot of these tsunami warnings but nothing really eventuates so we're just going to head out,” said fisherman Matthew Connolly.

A half marathon on Auckland's waterfront was cancelled, prompting a terse response from the organiser.

“We're pretty disappointed,” says Malcolm Wade. “On behalf of 2000 people, and it's a personal comment, not the club's comment, but I believe Civil Defence have panicked and over-reacted.”

At the nearby Port, all commercial vessels were evacuated – including the Dawn Princess cruise ship – they were taken to deeper water as a precaution.

In Wellington, police and a helicopter were warning visitors to the South Coast to move to higher ground.

Emergency staff were on high alert overnight at the National Crisis Management Centre in the Beehive bunker

The first wave hit just after 7am.

“We've had advice that the Chathams had a huge surge, and this is a huge volume of water – not just a wave,” John Carter said.

“The first one was 20 centimetres, the second we're told was a metre. This is serious.”

He urged people to take the warnings seriously and stay away from the coast.

“We saw the loss of life in Samoa, it could happen here if people nosey-park at the beaches.”

Emergency services patrolled the northern end of the harbour at Petone and blocked access to the beach.

While some were more light hearted about the alert and took the opportunity for an early morning dip after a mass nude photo shoot was cancelled.

“We've still got about half an hour, we've got plenty of run-off area up there, and we'll be running,” says Paul Taylor.

But by mid-afternoon, the Ministry of Civil Defence downgraded its warning to an advisory and it was back to business for Wellington's beach goers. 

But Civil Defence says surges and sea level changes are likely to continue for up to 24 hours.

There has been some concern expressed to 3 News about alert fatigue and whether people will take notice of warnings if we keep being alerted of tsunami danger but nothing eventuates.

But the Minister says there was a real threat and if they hadn't reacted in the way they did lives could have been lost.

He urges people to always heed the warnings.

In the South Island there was initial panic on Banks Peninsula where many families fled low lying houses first thing this morning.

Other areas near the sea moved out of their homes while the warnings were in place.

Okain’s Bay campsite had to evacuate over 100 people at 6.15 am.

A family from Chile were relocated from their site while trying desperately to get hold of family.

“Because we are stuck here we don't have access to call them or maybe get more information from internet,” Alexis Chavez said.

Further round on the peninsula in Purau, other families were evacuating.

“In the 60's our house was flooded by a tsunami that had the same reason – from the earthquake in Chile – so we were quite worried,” Bina Kilse said.

But it didn't stop local fisherman going out.

“They reckon the first one won't be too high, so plans are straight up the hill if there's any issues,” said one fisherman.

Local authorities had other ideas.

Down in Dunedin, police tried to warn people and clear the beach – even taping it off.

But there was no stopping some surfers.

Back at Sumner Beach, while plenty came for a look, others evacuated to higher ground.

In Lyttelton there was no action for most of the morning, but many boaties secured their ships or moved them out into the harbour.

Then a few hours later, the water started receding.

At midday at Lyttelton Harbour the water dramatically dropped by nearly a metre, causing boats to rest on their keels.

But like most other places, there was no major damage.

Late this afternoon, even if the surges of water hadn't completely died out, any panic had.

3 News

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

02 Mar 2010 10:25a.m.

Clinton wrote:

It's call survival of the fittest, people. The kid that swallows too many marbles does not grow up to breed. One day the warning will amount to something. I'll be the one on the top of the hill laughing. If people want to ignore warnings, (and clean up the gene pool in the process) so be it.
Just my two cents.

01 Mar 2010 10:24p.m.

expat wrote:

typically alarmist kiwi response - desperate to be involved in some wider global event, media hype its up as a 2cm wave makes its way across the pacific - no doubt with some side story about a squinty eyed jandal wearing backpacker from Otago, who 'narrowly' escaped the tumult, largely by being in an adjacent country

01 Mar 2010 06:40a.m.

Emma wrote:

Anyone who thinks the Civil defence over-reacted should check out: http://wcatwc.arh.noaa.gov/chile/chileem.jpg - it shows the wave stregnth, anything bigger then 30/40cms can kill.

28 Feb 2010 11:35p.m.

Lassie wrote:

Better to be safe than not. People take life for granted and shouldnt. Be grateful what you got and send love and light to mother earth. Condolences goes to those in Chile and any other place who going thru a tragedy.

28 Feb 2010 11:30p.m.

Erin wrote:

Of course head to the beach, if you're on the west coast, or in an equally sheltered area. Like Long Bay. It's highly improbable that a tsunami would be travelling at just the right angle to make it past not only the Cormandel, but also the islands protecting the bay. Psh.

28 Feb 2010 10:14p.m.

POPAP wrote:

HARDEN UP NO ONE GOT A WATER GUN OUT TO SPRAY PEOPLE...
WE HAD A MINI WAZE WHEN OUR WASHINE MACHINE BROKE TTODAY

28 Feb 2010 10:04p.m.

V wrote:

All the twats who rely on the stupid media and Civil Defense and don't go online to look at the real situation are just dribbling out the side of their collective mouths! . I checked with US Hawaiian sources online saw no threat and spend great day surfing!.

28 Feb 2010 09:49p.m.

Muchadoaboutnothing wrote:

Civil Defence being over-dramatic again as usual. I agree with the people who have said too many warnings and all coming to nothing. The quake was on the other side of the world for God's sakes! I wasn't at the beach but wouldn't have cared if I had been - wasn't like the quake happened nearby! About time us Kiwis stopped being such over-dramatic panic-mongers.

28 Feb 2010 09:20p.m.

Sue wrote:

I was evacuated with Sumner school because of the Chile earthquake in 1960(best school day ever!)and we learned pretty smartly that warnings are given for good reason.This morning I'm up in the Waikato and trying to make sure my deaf mother in Redcliffs(near Sumner) knows there is a warning and is prepared.I say always take such warnings seriously.We cannot beat nature.

28 Feb 2010 08:58p.m.

shaken wrote:

A marine warning would have been enough. An over reaction is just as bad as no reaction at all.