3News » Home
Full Story

Man takes benefit for 25 years, uses to fence pool

20 comments | Post Comment Email Print Text Size:
aA
aA
aA
Tue, 22 Dec 2009 5:07p.m.

By Jeff Hampton

Social Development Minister Paula Bennett says she is “a little incredulous” to hear a Christchurch beneficiary got a special needs benefit to fence a swimming pool on one of his properties.

That beneficiary is Darryl Harris – he is from a notorious Christchurch family, addicted to cannabis and has been receiving a benefit for 25 years.

Those on the trail of Mr Harris still end up at a house in South Christchurch, but the man himself is not there. It is under new ownership, although one of those on the property certainly did not have the Christmas spirit.

The new owner says she has got no links with the Harris family, has had the house three months, and is sick of dealing with debt collectors coming to her door.

They are not the only ones having trouble finding the elusive Mr Harris, who has gone to ground after being high-profile in the 1990s along with his brothers and hangers-on.

He and his wife Marcia draw $1000 a week in benefits and they literally exploded back on the scene two years ago when their headquarters caught fire.

Work and Income paid for the family to spend 10 nights at a smart Christchurch hotel.

On top of that, it has been revealed the pair have received $30,000 in special needs grants since 2000 – one was to buy tyres for their car; a 2007 silver Chrysler saloon.

Another was to fence a swimming pool at a family property.

“Look, it's bit hard to talk about specifics and there always are a lot of complexities around it, but it does seem a little incredulous to me,” said Social Development Minister Paul Bennett.

Mr Harris's Chrysler, which burns 17 litres of fuel every 100km, is registered to another South Christchurch address, but no-one was there when 3 News dropped by.

Work and Income now uses what they call a ‘remote monitoring unit’ to deal with the Harrises – that is because they are deemed too dangerous for face-to-face meetings with staff.

“We prefer face-to-face. We get further with people, it's easier to case manage but there are exceptional circumstances where we will deal with them differently,” says Ms Bennett.

The Harris duo are one of 300 couples nationally who get about $1000 a week in benefits. Mr Harris has been on one for 25 years and has a medical opinion to say he is addicted to cannabis.

Mrs Bennett says an audit of these cases has been under way since June, but no-one believes the case of Darryl Harris will be resolved in a hurry.

3 News

Comments [20]

outraged
05 Jan 2010 9:43a.m.

this is the most rediculous story i have ever heard.stop the payments and let the bugger come to service.its easy to stop other criminals as would be easy to stop him ........

GOVERNMENT FAULT I SAY

Ian
27 Dec 2009 4:01p.m.

He looks like an albino! no insults to albino's

Wgtn
26 Dec 2009 11:58a.m.

This guy is a joke, National supposedly purged his kind in the 1990's it was one of the reasons that they cut benefits by 20 percent.

But this story just highlights how bad government workers are at doing their jobs properly.

25 years without being caught? National and Labour would have both known about this guy.

Now National is going to use this guy to push things like Welfare being put into the hands of the Waipareira Trust.

Bad move, this institution is run by John Tamihere who employed Donna Awatere-Huata.

Are we reall going to shift welfare into the hands of Donna Awatere? when she has already been jailed for stealing tax payer money?.

PAM SIMMONS
23 Dec 2009 2:46p.m.

STOP PAYING HIM ALL THE MONEY AND HE WILL COME TO THE SURFACE. HE IS RIPPING THE SYSTEM OFF AND SO IT ENCOURAGES OTHERS TO DO THE SAME. WHY SHOULD THE TAX PAYER HAND OUT GOOD MONEY TO A NO-GOODER? I THINK IT SHOWS THE WELFARE SYSTEM AS BEING INCREDIBLY FLAWED AND OBVIOUSLY THEY ARE HAPPY TO PART WITH THE TAX PAYERS MONEY. PERHAPS IF IT WAS THEIR OWN AND THEY HAD A SET SALARY TO MANAGE A SET NUMBER OF BENEFICIARIES, WE WOULD SEE THE HAND OUTS REDUCE. SO EASY TO GIVE AWAY MONEY WHEN IT IS NOT YOUR OWN. AND APPARANTLY SO EASY TO GET IT AND NO NEED TO BUDGET ON AN ORDINARY BENEFIT. THE DEPARTMENT IS AN OPEN CHEQUE BOOK. BETTER THAN A BANK THAT CHARGES OVERDRAFT FEES.

cynical
23 Dec 2009 11:11a.m.

Silly me, and I thought that (benefit) fraud was a criminal offence.

PJ
23 Dec 2009 10:02a.m.

And those 300 ppl were likely the only ones living it high. I,m also on a dpb and looking after my 13 yr old son who has issues that need caring for 24/7. After my rent $89@week in state housing i get a whole $220 left in the bank to pay for power food smokes petrol to run him to school 5 days of the week and your lovely government say the average wage in nz is $750@week then if thats the average WTF are we still struggling on miniscule pay outs having to take out bank loans just to buy clothes and sometimes even just to put food in the house, get real and look into why this happens , criminals on a $1K week why? put them in jail and split thier money up and put it to use where it is needed.

Buzzard
23 Dec 2009 9:49a.m.

NZ a society of tolerance???? Go figure if we had a society of intolerance this would never have happened. The Harrises are the scum of the earth and that goes for anyone else abusing the social welfare system. The thing is that if you cut the payments from WINZ the crimes they commit will increase. When the crimals go off to jail, all their outstanding fines are wiped and they have a family reunion again at the cost of the Tax payer. This cycle needs to be broken by one a lead tablet for the offenders and sterilisation of all their children. It is obvious all the other PC reform BS is not working and only creating jobs for jokes of society. I am not proud to Say I voted for the current govt, I was lead to believe there was going to be change. Unfortunately JK just wants another feather in his cap rather than growing some balls. We do not need prisons at all, the monies saved there could be spent on extra policing, and fitting the crime to the punishment. Rip the Treaty of Wiatangi up and tell this pooooooor hard done by race to get over it or get out.

Koos
23 Dec 2009 9:07a.m.

I would like to see the government do an audit on how many gang members are receiving some form of benefit - be it dole, sickness, child support, whatever. I suspect ordinary tax payers have been indirectly funding criminal activities for decades, we should all be arrested for funding P labs and cannabis operations. I would fire all of WINZ bosses. Obviously they are incompetent to let scumbags get away with this sort of thing for so long. How difficult could it be to clean up this act?

Mike
23 Dec 2009 8:45a.m.

300 couples @ $1000 a week is 15 million a year. Makes some of the politicians perks look like schoolboy pocket money! Agree with ANRATH, not ALL beneficiaries get anything like that! Most are struggling on what they do get. So exactly what gives in these particular cases? In competent workers? Bad legislation? Can WINZ do as John suggests....stop their benefit....make them reapply? If so, why haven't they done just that? 24 years ago? There are so many ways today to "rip off the system". Shonky lawyers ripping off legal aid.(SOME) Shonky financiers ripping off investors. (SOME) People ripping off ACC (SOME) People ripping off the Tax system (SOME) Etc. Etc How does Government deal with it? By the "broad brush" approach which means in the end everyone pays! Either by reputation, financially or both!

andy
23 Dec 2009 7:48a.m.

the problem is staff are scared to deal with harris and his brothers knowing thier violent past ,blowing up the sydnham police station,burning down witnesses houses and taxi,s gang shootings, violent assaults and even intimidation of police by finding where they live etc,its easy to see why some poor girl sitting behind a counter at winz would be scared

Post a comment

Name:
Email: (Won't be published)
Comment:


3News Video 3News Audio

Post your opinion

3News - Adrian Leason, Peter Murnane, Samuel Land each faced charges relating to the damage of Waihopai spy base (NZPA)
Comments (39)

Waihopai acquittal: dangerous precedent or sensibility prevailing?

Three peace activists walked free Wednesday even though they admitted breaking into a Government spybase near Blenheim....