3News » Home
Full Story

School with no pupils forced to remain open

5 comments | Post Comment email Email printer friendly Print    Text Size:
aA
aA
aA
Tomahawk Primary

Tomahawk Primary

video
Wed, 03 Feb 2010 4:52p.m.

By Dave Goosselink

Dunedin's Tomahawk Primary School, like others all over the country, reopened the gates to pupils this week. The trouble is, it's got no pupils - but the Ministry of Education is insisting it remains open.

There are no pupils enrolled at the school this year, but the school's four staff members are still being employed.

"The secretary's just tidying up some things left over from the end of the holidays, I've answered some emails and some telephone calls and done a couple of interviews, and the other teacher's just having a teacher-only day," says principal Richard Aitkin.

Tomahawk's roll fell to just 11 students last year. With two of those moving on to intermediate school, staff and the school board decided the best option was to apply for closure.

"It's difficult to continue running a school with nine students," says Mr Aitken. "The funding just isn't generated to maintain that."

But he says despite having no students, he still hasn't been given permission to close the doors on the 141-year old school.

Unlike many other school closures in recent years, the decision to close down Tomahawk was made by parents and the community, rather than dictated by the Ministry of Education.

Education Minister Anne Tolley refused to front for cameras today, but told 3 News she has signed off the documents to begin what is now a meaningless consultation process.

The former Tomahawk students have all transferred to nearby Musselburgh School, where they are adjusting well to the larger surroundings.

"Well like all new children in a new situation, some of them were feeling a little bit anxious, but on the whole they were all very excited about starting a new school," says Debbie Smith, Musselburgh School principal.

Dunedin's Waldronville School also has no students, but has been told it will officially close in April.

Mr Aitken believes Tomahawk could be empty and open until early July. He plans to keep busy by going back to school himself and completing his master's degree.

3 News

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Comments [5]

Ants
22 Feb 2010 7:16p.m.

The full story was not reported in this instance. Only a few people want this school closed and the rest of us had no say in the matter. There was no consultation with the community on the issue of voluntary closure and groups close to the school heard about it through the media. There was also no attempt to recruit new students, to find out what the community wanted in their local school or to show good reason why locals would want to send their kids there. Sure this doesn't need to happen in a bigger school, the kids just come. In a small, semi-rural school if you don't engage with the community and make it a school parents want to send their kids to, the kids won't just come. It's such a shame that investigative journalism does such a poor job of covering a story properly!

Steve
08 Feb 2010 9:33p.m.

Yet she closes Aorangi Primary in Christchurch. What the hell is going on?

Warren Matthews
05 Feb 2010 12:55p.m.

Something doesn't add up.


Closing schools which had support to stay open. Keeping schools open where people seem to think they should be closed?

Baker
05 Feb 2010 11:02a.m.

Yet another bloody mistake from the Government

John
05 Feb 2010 12:59a.m.

I thought National was the party that abhors public sector waste? This is hilarious. Far be it for the minister of education to front up to explain this massive waste of taxpayers money, she has gone into hiding!

Post a comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide here
Name:
Email: (Won't be published)
Comment:



3News Video 3News Audio

Post your opinion

3News - What changes would you make to MMP?
The Govt and lobby groups are urging people to have their say on
Comments (3)