3News » Home
Full Story

New drinking laws 'easy' to avoid

17 comments | Post Comment email Email printer friendly Print    Text Size:
aA
aA
aA
Liquor store owners say the laws won't change New Zealand’s drinking culture

Liquor store owners say the laws won't change New Zealand’s drinking culture

video
Mon, 23 Aug 2010 6:00p.m.

By Patrick Gower

Many young people say the areas targeted by new liquor laws won’t stop New Zealand’s binge drinking culture.

Under-age drinkers say it will be easy to forge permission slips, 18-year-olds say they will just buy their booze at bars, and liquor store owners say the new laws won't prevent underage drinking.

Erica Finnie and Ben Stokes are under 18 but they still drink on weekends. Now they will need a permission slip from mum or dad, but they say that's a waste of time.

“How are they going to check it? Are they going to come and kick down the garage door, look at a kid with a beer, check his papers - what are they thinking?” says Ben.

Erica says it is easy for teenagers to forge their parents’ signatures.

James Beaumont is 19 and at university. He will lose his right to buy from the liquor store, but he says he will just go to a bar to buy booze.

“As a student I obviously like to drink a little bit. It’s probably going to make things harder on us,” he says.

“It’s not going to stop us drinking, it’s just going to be more out of our wallets.”

The number of off-licenses, like bottle stores, has ballooned from 1675 in 1990 to over 4347 today.

What do you think of the new laws? - Have your say on the drinking debate.

The dramatic increase sent South Auckland residents to the streets to protest. Now they have got the power to make local authorities shut them down.

“Communities will be able to say, ‘Hey this is too many, we don't want any more and enough is enough,'” says bottle store protester Simeon Brown.

Liquor store owners say the laws won't change New Zealand’s drinking culture.

Narinder Singh says laws are only a band aid and don’t hit the heart of the problem.

It is said that drinking is okay in moderation, and Justice Minister Simon Power's been pretty moderate with this package of reform.

It makes targeted hits at New Zealand’s booze culture but not enough to annoy the silent majority of drinkers out there.

3 News

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Comments [17]

Baker
03 Nov 2010 4:40p.m.

Off the top of my head I can recall 11 bottle stores in Otara not including the 2 super markets that sell alcohol as well, 3 of them are within 500m from my house and we always have trouble with piss heads getting wasted and getting up to no good. 11 bottle stores for one small suburb, and I don't know if it's just me but it seems like there are also more bottles stores near every exit from Otara as well. I'll prove it, near Papatoetoe exit from Otara there is The Mill, near the Otahuhu exit from Otara there is a bottle store next to the G.A.S Station where they filmed Once Were Warriors, near Botany Downs exit from Otara there is The Mill again (different to the Papatoetoe one) near the Manukau exit from Otara there is a Super Liquor, and on your way out to Maraetai from Otara there's another new bottle store, there was already 10 bottle stores in Otara and they built a new one, what are they thinking. So besides the 11 bottles stores and 2 super markets that sell alcohol, there are also more bottles stores near every exit route out of Otara, not to mention that the DB Breweries is next to Otara and also the Lion Nathan Breweries is also next to Otara, and they wonder why there is so much trouble with drunks? I don't have to wonder because I know, there's too many places selling alcohol in Otara and they even make alcohol just down the road from as well, bit of a no brainer there

samuel welsh
26 Oct 2010 10:29p.m.

binge drinkers are criminals

stacey
01 Sep 2010 7:28p.m.

no matter what you do, its not going to stop. Underagers with always find a way to get their alcohol. Raising the age limit is stupid and pointless.

Emily
27 Aug 2010 10:56a.m.

This is about one of the dumbest things the Government has done this year. Whether you raise the legal drinking limit to 20 or leave it at 18.. Parties are still going to be the same. If the Government doesnt want us drinking or even snmoking .. Then why have stores that sells them? Yet, that can just start a whole different debate because we all know that the Government wants more money out of us . By raising the drinking age to 20.. dont think its going to be a good idea and a lot of people are going to be dissapointed this year when they turn 18, and those who have turned 18 earlier this year .. Definetly dissapointed . alot of people are . Is this really such a good idea ? it is, but only to a point . I agreee with Zoe, Kate, Amy, Anne and Alex too .

Kim
24 Aug 2010 4:29p.m.

@Johnmillan
Just to be a pain and because i want to show how smart i am (lol) your comment " useless as the B--Ls on a brass monkey" is not even close to correct. the expression is "freeze the b*lls off a brass monkey. This saying orignated back in the day of cannon balls. A brass monkey was the stand that they used to stack the cannon balls on. when they froze in the russian winters the stands shrunk with the cold and this caused the cannon balls to topple off..hence the saying "freeze the ball off a brass monkey". I hope this helps....maybe we could dub John Keys a brass monkey.

Ann
24 Aug 2010 9:38a.m.

First is the drinking limit, now it's underage drinkers! I find it rather baffling as to what the Government is trying to implement here. Why do they spend millions in Ads to tell people NOT to drink and drive, and at the same time, bending it to say you CAN drink and drive but just not over the limit? Why don't they implement one law that says that if drink & drive, regardless of the limit, and you'll have a criminal record. Are there not enough casualties and deaths that has been caused by drunk drivers? Why can't the Government just take a stand and not 'bend' the law to make it convenient for people to drink and drive. Similar to underaged drinkers, the Government is allowing for them to drink at a young age as long as they have permission? What's the point in implementing laws if you keep bending it? Might as well not have the law in the first place! The law should be if they start drinking at a young age, they'll have a criminal record tagged on them. It's basically to discourage youths from drinking at such a young age where their minds and body are not even mature enough to accept. The next BIG issue is when the Government would need to spend millions on medical cost on youths who will be having health related issues caused by drinking or party pills. Drinking culture especially among the youths, is not something that NZ is proud of but it seemed like it's being encouraged by the Government that as long as the underaged has 'permission', then it's okay to get pissed. It's just sad...

Alex
24 Aug 2010 7:02a.m.

The proposal to increase off-licenses purchase age to 20 is the least constructive measure of all the policies. As it has never been a problem for underage people to acquire alcohol (even when the age was 20), how does the government actually think that this will cause the young to behave more responsibly. It's a cop-out, it's going to have the contrary effect. The government should be encouraging responsible drinking ...not taking it away - and penalising only the individuals who misbehave. It also does not address the fact that a lot of misbehaviour also occurs from older drinkers who should be setting the example for our youth, and some clearly cannot. Still... as this is a conscience vote, with some lobbying there is still a good possibility it will fail.

amy
24 Aug 2010 12:47a.m.

these new laws are just plain stupid. they aren't going to stop the binge drinking but instead lead to more house parties where people aren't supervised and instead disturb their neighbours. we need to take examples from places such as Austria and Denmark where the buying ages can be as low as 16, and yet they don't have a binge drinking problem.

scott t
23 Aug 2010 11:49p.m.

Stop winging and expecting the government to babysit your kids. when I was 18 I'd go thru a couple 24 packs a weekend, I would take it upon myself to do it in a safe environment with friends and family. I'm 24 now, I'm over that stage and would be lucky to have a 6pack a fortnight.
start making the problem individuals accountable like paying for medical care as a result of drinking etc. Imagine if everytime you got taken to the cells for drunk behavior etc and charged for it, that'd soon make an impact.
If someone drinks to much and gets themself killed then thats their own dumb fault, not the governments.

Kate
23 Aug 2010 11:37p.m.

Personally I believe that if I can vote for my country at 18, die for my country at 18 and be considered an adult in my country at the age of 18 I should be allowed to have a drink and buy alcohol at 18. And to say it is purely a youth problem doesn't address the underlying issues and won't solve them either. I think the government has lost touch with how it works in the real world and what they were like at 18.

Post a comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide here
Name:
Email: (Won't be published)
Comment:



3News Video 3News Audio