Govt to implement boot camps for NZ’s worst young offenders

Print

Mon, 16 Feb 2009 12:00a.m.

Military style discipline has been tried before and dumped. The experts say they do not work.

However, next year National will make sure 40 of the country's worst and repeat young offenders do time with the army for an old fashioned sorting out.
 
“At the end of the day, these are not good kids,” says Social Development Minister Paula Bennett. “We want to turn them around so they do not become the adult offenders of tomorrow.”
 
Rita Croskery's son, Michael Choy, was killed after being set upon while delivering pizza. One of his attackers was Bailey Kurariki who was just 12-years-old at the time.

Mrs Croskery supports the tougher approach.
 
“They’ll be taken away from their dysfunctional families, for a start,” says Croskery. “They’ll have a purpose.”

The boot camps will start next year and a judge will decide who goes. The young people will spend three months in camp and face an intensive nine months of supervision afterwards.

Bennett says she accepts 40 is not many to start with, but the supervision afterwards is crucial.
 
“We’re not actually going to have these young people in a military style camp for three months and then throw them back out on the streets,” continues Bennett.

While Labour says boot camps do not work, Croskery says it is worth a try.
 
“The main problem with boot camps is you tend to turn out faster fitter young criminals with the same bad attitudes,” says Labour leader Phil Goff. “Every piece of research that’s every been done on boot camps shows that they have not worked.”
 
“The softly-softly approach has not worked,” says Croskery.

National will also force 12- and 13-year-olds into the youth court to face longer sentences.
 
Overall the moves will cost $35 million to implement.
 
3 News

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

15 Jun 2011 03:39a.m.

Jay wrote:

My son is currently waiting for his court case, he went to a party with a few friends, started of alright but ended up in Jail, He had gotten into a fight but apparently was hit first but he has no witnesses for this, his friends had given their statements to the police on the night and so therefore they do not count as witnesses for my son. My son apparently stabbed the guy in the head and arm but the guy is fine thank god, My son got so drunk that all he remembers is going to the party and having a great time then waking up in the cells, till this day my son can not remember what happened that night. He is currently going to a drug & rehabilitation for help and is also doing some odd chores on a farm.. He is not a violent kid at all he is a loving kid not only to his family but to all his friends too. This is his first offence ever but if there is anyone out there that can help us by finding a boot camp that would help our son it would truely mean so much to us and our son, we do not want to see him go to prison as he is so scared and feels that a boot camp would make him a better person.. Please help us anyone please!!!

06 Jan 2010 03:03p.m.

Devvyn Scofield wrote:

This is a brilliant and much needed implementation. I desperately want my 20yr son to attend one of these. I sent him to Birnham Military camp in 2008 he thrived and enjoyed it so much he tried twice to join the army, but because of his driving record was refused and told not to re apply. My son need structured discipline and routine this could have turned him around and given him a sense of achievement and a positive outlook, instead he is on a downward spiral and no matter what I do it is always one step forward two steps back. If anyone out there can help it would be much appreciated. I live in a state of desperation and sadness. This has been going on since the age of 14yrs continually battling and seeking a solution.Hamish is, despite everything a very sensitive but mixed up young man, I'm afraid one day he could end up in prison and that is defiantly not the right place. I see the potential he has and his caring nature. Boot camp would I know give him the wright focus for a positive future. There are so many stories, I wont go on.

18 Sep 2009 04:14p.m.

ms wrote:

having a troubled teenage son, and having him going of the rails no matter what the consequences are for his actions, and no matter whom trys to enforce it us the parents, or weather its youth services, the police the list goes on, it does not seem to sink in,
my son is a great kid at heart but unfortunatley he is on the wrong path, and i believe that if i managed to track a boot camp down that he could go on, it would be the best thing for him, with the skills and discipline that would be taught, and learning to respect people and himself, if this failed at least it was tryed, as so many teenagers are going down the wrong path, for most that get into trouble they get a tap on their hand and say you shouldnt have done that and dont do it again, even for stealing the grandparents car and causing over $2000.00 worht of damage as my son and his friends did,they didnt even have to pay a cent as they were only 15.
if all teenagers are seeing this happening, what sort of society is it going to be in the future, all that are starting or are of the rails need to go to a boot camp, it cant do any furthor harm to them or their familys that are struggling with their carry on,
if by chance anyone knows of any bootcamps please post a coment with details and i would be ever so gratefull.
as i have tried every and spoken to so many people, places for any sort of help, and i feel as though i am running out of options.......

12 Sep 2009 08:48p.m.

Teens Camps wrote:

Boot camps are fine structured and disciplined training centers. There are lots of boot training centers for boys and girls that monitor all the activities of youths. In the caring and supportive environment of the camps teenagers get highest potential as well as improved behavior in life. Vigorous physical training, exercises and outdoor programs are the vital parts of the training. Teenagers boot camps are designed for developing overall personality, skills and attitude of the distressed and unmotivated children.

http://www.teenscamp.net/Teen/Boot-Camps-For-Teens/index.htm

16 Feb 2009 06:57p.m.

KGB, Christchurch wrote:

I am 53yrs, I was sent to Rolleston Detention Cemtre when I was 2 days shy of 20 , the average age being 16-18. Most people got the first feel of being in a family, and they were mainly Maori, I am not being racist. This was supposed to be a short sharp sentence of 3 months with 1 month off which you could lose if you got say 3 points for dust losing a day. I learn't to be a better burglar thru' the confidenece course( look it up ). It did not do much for me or others, a 60% recidivisim rate and it was harder than the Army course which had blown down in 1976, The big Blow. eventually it was decided it was of no benefit. It got me fit. With some fine tuning I could see this working but the discipline was tougher than the Army. The food was worse than the dumpsters, I lived on Leeks. It was tough, up at 5.00A.M., in middle of winter at Rolleston, with justshorts, singlet, and sandshoes. Some of the exercises are now banned due to the nature of damage, such as my back was injured but I cannot prove it. Bed at 9.00, and you earn .2c per day, of course that may change but I don't think it will work but cause resentment, perhaps a 6 month sentence would work. This would stop smoking, and other bad habits that young people pick up. Also human rights must be respected.