3News » Home
Full Story

Shortland Street murder too brutal rules BSA

4 comments | Post Comment email Email printer friendly Print    Text Size:
aA
aA
aA

Wed, 07 Jan 2009 12:00a.m.

From gay sex scenes to murder scenes - Television New Zealand's popular soap opera Shortland Street is in trouble with the Broadcasting Standards Authority (BSA) again.

In December, the BSA upheld a complaint about a homosexual encounter shown on one episode.

The BSA said the scene in question was not suitable for child viewers, even when subject to guidance from a parent or adult, because of its sexual content.

The BSA made it clear its findings had nothing to do with the fact that the scene involved two men; the scene would have been equally inappropriate if it had involved a heterosexual couple.

In a decision released today, the BSA upheld a complaint about an episode where character Craig Valentine was killed.

The episode showed a car chase before Dr Valentine was beaten with a baseball bat and eventually left in a car which was set alight.

The episode was given a PGR warning.

A majority decision by the BSA said the episode was unsuitable for children, even with adult supervision, because of the realism of the violence.

The BSA website states: "The theme was likely to frighten and disturb child viewers, particularly because the violence - which included easily accessible weapons such as baseball bats - was realistic in the sense that it could happen in New Zealand."

No order was imposed. The BSA believed the decision would remind TVNZ to take special care when including violence in PGR programmes.

NZPA

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Comments [4]

ngaire
08 Jan 2009 2:25p.m.

some people just need to over i. if parents dont want their children watching such things change the channel cause the majority of the viewers dont have a problem. only adults have the ability to police what their child watches or hears on tv. anyway what we see on the news a 6pm is much worse and a reality and kids discuss national current affirs at school.

Alien
07 Jan 2009 4:44p.m.

cartoon's are more violent than that scene was.

Since you came up with that scene Deane, I guess it would be you who would enjoy it. But hey, again showing your mentality by attacking south islanders with such a pathetic immature comment, which is typical for you

Jim
07 Jan 2009 3:51p.m.

Most children should be in bed at 7pm, I myself, am out in the boys room playing darts

Deane, HAMILTON
07 Jan 2009 3:12p.m.

I don't watch Shortland St at all. However why should some old dear would have been shocked by the gay sceen, who stil think sex should be done in the dark, dictate to the viewer what we should and should not see.

With regards to the violence, thats another matter.

What they need now is a scene involving a donky, sheep and a goat. I am sure south Island viewers would enjoy that.

Post a comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide here
Name:
Email: (Won't be published)
Comment:



3News Video 3News Audio

Post your opinion

3News - Was the force used at the Dotcom mansion excessive?
On January 20th, two helicopters and 76 police officers arrived a
Comments (191)