Not just National ministers denting their cars

Print

Tue, 10 May 2011 6:32p.m.

Shane Jones says Steve Maharey dinged up his car

Shane Jones says Steve Maharey dinged up his car

By Patrick Gower

Last night 3 News bought you a story of how Cabinet ministers have a million-dollar fleet of taxpayer-funded self-drive private cars which have been regular customers at the panel beaters.

But it isn't just National - documents obtained by 3 News show Labour ministers in the last Government were also hard on their cars.

Labour MP Shane Jones was a little surprised with the bill for repairs to his ministerial car when we presented it to him.

There was damage in 15 places when he returned his self-drive Honda Accord when Labour was kicked out of Government.

It cost $2,385 dollars to fix, and taxpayers picked up the bill.

He had damage to the right rear door fittings, rear bumper, left rear door fittings, bonnet, right rear door, lower boot lid, left rear door, left front mud flap, and scratches to the exterior.

There was even mould.

"I can't account for that," says Mr Jones, "unless it was going through one of these Northland floods. I don't know."

But then he remembered - the car used to belong to former minister Steve Maharey, and apparently it was his fault.

"This car belonged to Maharey," says Mr Jones. "Auntie Helen [Clark, former Prime Minister] wouldn't give me a flash four-wheel-drive for the Nga Puhi roads."

Other Labour Ministers handed back damaged cars too. Maryan Street's needed $1615 worth of repairs, and that was also a colleague's fault.

"I certainly didn't have any accidents in it myself," says Ms Street. "Dover Samuels did have it before me however."

Former associate Transport Minister Harry Duynhoven dropped back his Skoda with $1470 worth of damage. Mita Ririnui's dents cost the taxpayer $500. Mahara Okeroa, $1000. Former Minister of Conservation Steve Chadwick, $720.

"I had to hand it back," says Ms Chadwick, "I couldn't afford to buy it."

And don't forget coalition partner Winston Peters. He returned his Ford Territory - the taxpayer paid $795 dollars for repairs - then he bought it.

3 News

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

10 May 2011 11:18p.m.

Dave wrote:

Are there really no other stories in the country? If this is the best you can come up with from using the freedom of information act, you should really stick to your other favourite of surfing the news on the internet and then reporting it poor extremley poor

10 May 2011 10:43p.m.

cyril wrote:

Sounds like they drive there cars like they drive the country EXTREMLY BADLY.

10 May 2011 09:32p.m.

Doug wrote:

What is the point of this reporting National yesterday Labour today are you just trying to fill column centimetres seems like nit picking.

10 May 2011 08:31p.m.

paul wrote:

wot a crook of shit.Dont you have anything more constructive to do. The standard of journalism and reporting in this country is pathetic.There wouldnt be many cars on the road without the odd dent or scratch and $1000 dosnt go far at panelbeaters...

10 May 2011 07:40p.m.

Nick wrote:

My bumper cost $600 to get some plastic welding done, we must have no political woes, if all you can report on is minor vehicle damage. Be honest and stop making news report on real issues.