Opinion: Ben Affleck must apologise to NZ for Argo's deception

Print

Wed, 27 Feb 2013 9:22a.m.

Affleck won an Oscar for his film which wrongly depicted New Zealand

Affleck won an Oscar for his film which wrongly depicted New Zealand

Congratulations Ben Affleck for Argo’s Oscar - well-deserved.

But what is also deserved now is an apology from Affleck to New Zealand - particularly our courageous and professional diplomats.

It goes like this; Argo suggests that during the hostage crisis, the New Zealand embassy in Tehran refused to shelter the American fugitives.

In the Argo script a CIA agent describes the getaway like this:

"The six of them went out a back exit. Brits turned them away, Kiwis turned them away. The Canadians took them in. They've been there since.”

Watching the film, my first thought was: ‘That doesn't sound right - is this true - surely it can't be?’.

So I sent a tweet asking this question of what our role really was - and was quickly told the real facts.

The New Zealand diplomats didn't turn the hostages away at all - in fact we played a key role assisting the Canadians to shelter them.

Kiwi Ambassador Chris Beeby and his second secretary Richard Sewell actually went beyond the call of duty to help shelter them - even though Iran was at that stage New Zealand's biggest customer for lamb.

Beeby even went as far as visiting the fugitives at their hideaway with the Canadians, and had rented another property ready if they needed to change places.

This obviously put Beeby - and New Zealand - at huge risk. Even Prime Minister Rob Muldoon was kept in the loop.

My Press Gallery colleague Adam Bennett has already done the heavy-lifting on this yarn when Argo was released.

In Wellington circles, Beeby was a legendary figure - the ultimate diplomat, a hard-living, fun-loving character. Both he and Sewell have since passed away.

Many people who knew Beeby say what Affleck has done just isn’t right - and having looked into this I have to agree.

I am not being naive here. I know that a Hollywood blockbuster - even one based on a true story - takes ‘dramatic licence’.

But this is different because not only does Affleck portray our diplomats - and by extension New Zealand - as cowardly, the opposite is true.

They weren't cowardly - they were brave.

And worse still, Affleck was apparently aware of this. He's made some public comments that it wasn't ‘totally fair’.

I'm no movie expert obviously, but I can't really see what slamming New Zealand adds to the film - if anyone else can, let me know.

Some people will say I'm being over-sensitive here. But in my opinion, what Affleck has done just isn’t right.

He has deliberately slammed New Zealand in the biggest movie of 2013 - and for no good reason.

Affleck has besmirched the personal reputation of legendary diplomat Chris Beeby and Richard Sewell. They, and their families deserve better - anyone can see that.

Affleck has not told the truth. Affleck knows it is wrong.

Kiwis didn't turn the hostages away - Kiwis helped them out.

Affleck has danced around this so far - but in my opinion his ambiguous Hollywood talk does not suffice.

It's time for Affleck to put this right. It's time for Affleck to apologise for Argo’s deception.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

22/05/2013 9:22:01 a.m.

Bertrand wrote:

It is a fiction, not a documentary. The former explains (maybe) the later.

19/05/2013 9:11:41 a.m.

SarahNZ wrote:

I only got round to watching the movie last night and I LOVED IT. I'm not a big fan of Ben Afflict but he did a good job. I can see why people would be upset but realistically the characters were saying what they would have known at the time, ie "The kiwis turned them away". The kiwis were working covertly so it was in their interest to be seen as non-compliant (no matter how cowardly it may appear). Don't forget that it wasn't until much later that their involvement was recognized. So I think the script holds more true to the situation than we'd like it to. Perhaps the end notes could have mentioned it, but really who else gives a damn but us? Frankly, I'd be more peeved if I was Iranian at the portrayal because obviously they came off looking worse even though the basis of their plight was justified.

15/05/2013 1:52:26 p.m.

KeHoSuRo wrote:

Ben was just the Script Reader... Shouldn't the Apology if any be coming from the Writer or whom ever did the Background Research on this Movie??? Just Saying :)

20/04/2013 10:31:45 p.m.

Charlie T wrote:

What ignorant, cynical tripe people have written here! Chris Beeby risked life and limb for these people. Importantly, the NZ Embassy would not have been safe, and at least two of the Americans refused to stay there for this reason.

5/04/2013 12:27:49 a.m.

Arthur Wilson wrote:

This is how movie fiction becomes fact. Most of those commenting here are saying NZ "turned them away", but they're simply parroting Affleck because as far as I can make out his movie is the only source for that statement. Don't parrot Affleck -- he lied and maligned a couple of brave Kiwis who put their lives on the line for those US hostages!

4/04/2013 10:49:40 p.m.

Liz wrote:

Ahhh hello - it's a Hollywood movie! Don't get your knickers in a twist! Ps. I'm a proud kiwi

1/04/2013 9:37:18 a.m.

Tony wrote:

Really? That's the least of our worries. We get derided internationally due to things we actually do - false tourism marketing, pulling out of Kyoto, terrible conditions for cyclists, culture of violence... no point getting upset about a movie.

19/03/2013 1:18:57 p.m.

Charles wrote:

Could you be any more petty? It's a movie, it is Hollywood, we didn't take them in... Get over it! I dont think a four second line in a movie is really worthy of an opinion piece.

13/03/2013 9:49:20 a.m.

Darren wrote:

The line between propaganda and Hollywood movie is very blurry. Hollywood is an important tool in convincing Americans that they are the good guys and everyone else is bad or suspicious. New Zealand's reputation will be tainted by this movie as we all know how credulous the American public can be. War will Iran on its way.

10/03/2013 1:54:28 p.m.

julian h wrote:

Bottom line - the Kiwis did not take them in, they didn't take the big risk. The Canadians did. And yes, it's being precious to say otherwise.

Patrick Gower

Political Editor

Patrick is the 3 News Political Editor based in Wellington. Here he offers his commentary on New Zealand politics from his front-row seat in the Press Gallery. He has been a journalist for 15 years, covering stories in Afghanistan and on the US presidential election campaign trail, and was previously a political and investigative reporter for the New Zealand Herald.

Patrick Gower's Entries

Previous123Next