3News » Home
Full Story

PM labels bank inquiry "fizzer"

13 comments | Post Comment email Email printer friendly Print    Text Size:
aA
aA
aA
Prime Minister John Key labelled the inquiry a "fizzer"

Prime Minister John Key labelled the inquiry a "fizzer"

Thu, 12 Nov 2009 5:41a.m.
Prime Minister John Key has dismissed the opposition-driven parliamentary inquiry into banks' behaviour, which found they failed to fully pass official cash rate (OCR) cuts to consumers.

"Fundamentally the banking inquiry by Labour was a political stunt and it's proved to be a complete and utter fizzer, there are no strong recommendations," Mr Key said.

Mr Key said Labour had nine years in government to deal with the issue, but had not felt strongly enough about it then to do anything.

"The relationship between the OCR and what consumers pay to borrow money is a very complex relationship. If Labour were really serious they would have come up with recommendations to do something about it."

The parliamentary inquiry was led by Labour, the Progressives and the Greens, and the findings were released yesterday.

Statistical evidence produced for the inquiry showed that while most interest rates had fallen since the global financial crisis began late last year, major banks had not passed on the full impact of OCR cuts into short-term interest rates charged to customers, said Labour's finance spokesman David Cunliffe.

The report showed "considerable agreement" among submitters on a number of key banking and monetary policy issues.

Mr Cunliffe accused the Government of "failing in its responsibilities to hard-working Kiwi families and taxpayers" by refusing to take part in a bipartisan inquiry.

Bank workers' union Finsec said the cuts were not passed on despite the major banks surviving the global financial crisis comparatively well.

Finsec campaigns director Tali Williams said in one of the inquiry's peer reviews, Professor John Quiggin said "a better conclusion might be that the taxpayer is entitled to require that the banks will act as good corporate citizens".

Ms Williams said New Zealand taxpayers and consumers were underwriting the banks' business through government guarantee schemes.

"Meanwhile, the banks continue to be very profitable and are not doing everything they can to help customers through the global financial crisis. In this case, to the tune of billions of dollars."

Finance Minister Bill English said at the outset of the inquiry that nothing would come out of it and said that had been proven true.

"Reserve Bank analysis shows that banks' interest rate margins had dropped and stabilised at a relatively low level," Mr English said.

NZPA
Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Comments [13]

Ricardo
17 Nov 2009 2:54p.m.

Keys is right...Labour had plenty of opportunity. We should be very thakful in NZ that largely the global recession passed us by. In some countries (for anyone capable of reading a newspaper) large numbers of people have left their homes and mortgages, and many lost their entire savings in banks that folded. Labour needs to think of something useful and helpful to make NZ even better. Just think, if interest rates dropped to European or US levels, what would the elderly in NZ live on when their money only gets 1%. That would be a far worse crime.

Jim
13 Nov 2009 8:19a.m.

Really Barry
Surely it should come down to the price one pays to be with the best. Kiwi Bank has now been around for 4 years+. If it was the best, people had all this time to switch!!!

Barry Holland
12 Nov 2009 9:56p.m.

jim 12th Nov; People cannot afford to change banks whilst they are charged exorbitant fees to move from a foreigen bank to a genuine NZ bank

Robert
12 Nov 2009 5:49p.m.

The OCR does not drive interest rates. Kiwibank is a NZ bank that is set up to compete and their rates are not cheaper. TSB as well. I don't fully understand myself what is driving the rates, but it is more complex than people think.

Jim
12 Nov 2009 3:45p.m.

So, if the Aussie banks are so terrible, why is not all Kiwi's going to Kiwi Bank? Maybe, it is because Kiwi Bank is not that great!!!

wolfman x2
12 Nov 2009 3:39p.m.

i totally agree with wolfman !!!!! who can you trust!! action speck louder than words.

M
12 Nov 2009 2:02p.m.

Neville, I think you'll find that the Section 59 bill was first introduce and given headyway in Jun/Jul 05, with 1st, 2nd & 3rd readings under Labour I would be very hesitant in taring National with that brush.
I also agree that there could be more given in respect to margin on mortgage rates however for those that know and understand the markets it's not simply the OCR that dictates, in fact that has only a very small bearing on the consumer rates, with a balance being required between OCR, wholesale market rates, offshore funding lines, local deposit rates etc etc. Let's makle sure that if someone is going to cast an opinion that they do so armed with all the information to ensure a balanced well rounded outcome - unfortunately this isn't the case here and is nothing more than grandstanding.

wolfman
12 Nov 2009 1:54p.m.

What a bunch of hypocrites this Labour, Green and Progressive bunch are. They had 9 years to sort out the banks and did nothing, and now they are blaming the National Party. Goff and his Cronies should start shutting their mouths, as everytime they open them they put all their feet in them. But saying this, of course Key will do nothing, after all he was a banker and that's how he made his millions. Go Figure.

Deane
12 Nov 2009 1:21p.m.

This is a mistake Key has made. It shows he is out of touch with those paying mortages and are struggling.

It also shows that he is out of touch for kiwi business who are paying higher rates here then similar businesses in Australia.

Lets face it, Australian banks are milking us, and the government are prepared to accept it.

I also dont like Keys comments on saying Labour had 9 years to do something about it, so why should he do something.

John, stop blaming the previous government, you are the PM now, so act like one.

Key has now got cocky over the polls. He is living in falls paradise.

cherie
12 Nov 2009 11:16a.m.

This was the biggest waste of money ever.
They come up with what everyone knows.
The intrest rates where what when Labour was in? They should of done something when we were all paying 9+%.

Post a comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide here
Name:
Email: (Won't be published)
Comment:



3News Video 3News Audio