• Full Story

Paul Henry: Gov General should be more 'Kiwi'

Print

Mon, 04 Oct 2010 12:36p.m.

Breakfast host Paul Henry (NZPA file)

Breakfast host Paul Henry (NZPA file)

By Maggie Tait of NZPA

Television New Zealand host Paul Henry today urged Prime Minister John Key to select a Governor-General who "looks and sounds more like a New Zealander".

The interview has already sparked two complaints from viewers following this morning's Breakfast programme, where Henry asked Mr Key whether Governor-General Sir Anand Satyanand was a New Zealander or not.

When assured by Mr Key that he was Henry asked if he was going to pick someone who looked more like a New Zealander next time.

Sir Anand is New Zealand's first Governor-General of Indian and Pacific ancestry. He had a lengthy career as a lawyer, judge and ombudsman before taking up the job in August 2006.

He was born and raised in Auckland, attending Richmond Road School in Ponsonby, and Sacred Heart College in Glen Innes. His parents were born in Fiji and migrated to New Zealand, his grandparents were born in India and had migrated to Fiji.

On the Breakfast programme this morning Henry asked the Prime Minister about who he was looking to replace Sir Anand with when his five year term ends this year.

"Is he even a New Zealander?" Henry asked.

Mr Key said he was.

"Are you going to choose a New Zealander who looks and sounds like a New Zealander this time... Are we going to go for someone who is more like a New Zealander this time?"

Mr Key appeared slightly uncomfortable with the line of questioning and moved on to joking about whether Henry wanted the job.

He said whoever was chosen would need to be acceptable to other parties and his selection would be run by Labour.

"This is the Queen's representative and you don't want to embroil her in a domestic political spat."

A spokesman for Broadcasting Minister Jonathan Coleman said Henry's remarks were a matter for TVNZ to comment on.

A spokeswoman for TVNZ said there had been two complaints this morning.

"The audience tell us over and over again that one of the things they love about Paul Henry is that he's prepared to say the things we quietly think but are scared to say out loud," she said.

"The question of John Key is the same, we want the answer but are to scared to ask."

Sir Anand is in India for the Commonwealth Games. His public affairs manager Antony Paltridge told NZPA: "We won't be dignifying that sort of comment with a response."

Labour leader Phil Goff said Sir Anand was as much a New Zealander as he was.

"I would rate him as one of New Zealand's best Governors-General. Anand is a person that grew up in this country, understands this country as well as anybody... a fantastic Governor-General."

The comments were "silly... I think that was Paul Henry being Paul Henry".

Henry previously called Scottish singing star Susan Boyle "retarded" and on another occasion mocked the facial hair of one of his female guests; anti-nuclear campaigner and Greenpeace worker Stephanie Mills.

The Broadcasting Standards Authority upheld complaints in those cases.

NZPA

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

20 Oct 2010 06:29p.m.

Barbara Kung wrote:

I think Paul Henry had a right to ask that question about the Govenor General as I and many other kiwis asked the same question and to this day believe he is not a Kiwi. The other point to this is how can Hone Harawira be so racist as he is by calling people f.... rednecks and white face and all the rest of his comment as of that nature. I think that this government is two faced and does not really give a shit about the ordinary kiwi who is working class to those in the higher offices and this is a country that is becoming racist against the Pakeha which is a racist word to me as it means white face but we can't say that Hone Harawira is black without offending him so sad.

07 Oct 2010 12:31p.m.

Jane Reed wrote:

Paul Henry must go? Good luck with that - you don't stand a chance being successful in pathetic & small minded vendetta. Henry has 53,000 fans on Facebook....how many does your page have? Oh 27......funny. This all started because of an assumption - albeit an incorrect one - but an assumption all the same. Assumptions are not by ANY means synonymous with racism; there was no intent on Henry's part to offend anyone. He merely spoke without thinking & getting all his facts. His first question was "Is he even a New Zealander?" This is the sum of the issue & is indicative of an assumption most people no doubt had before this issue came to light - based on the GG's age who would have assumed he was born & raised in NZ? His children yes but not him. And being raised in NZ should be a necessary prerequisite for the position of GG so the questions were fair enough. He merely should have, as a broadcaster, done his homework before asking them on air & perhaps thought more about the phrasing. As for the race relations commissioner getting involved? Funny they don't care when Hone - a public servant paid entirely by the taxpayer - says the horrendous things he says. Funny that Tamihere & Jackson get to say, without reproach all the rubbish they say. Double standards if you ask me. Bottom line if you don't like Paul Henry being on Breakfast then don't watch....start your own program....TV3 tried....and failed cos guess what, the bulk of NZ like Breakfast & like Henry....how else did he win People's Choice? For the record racism (simply put) is defined as 1. "the belief that races have distinctive cultural characteristics determined by hereditary factors and that this endows some races with an intrinsic superiority over others" or 2. "abusive or aggressive behaviour towards members of another race on the basis of such a belief"

07 Oct 2010 07:27a.m.

Paul Henry MustGo wrote:

Join Us in a Boycott of Progressive Enterprises (Foodtown, Woolworths, Countdown) until they agree to pull their sponsorship of the Breakfast show as long as Paul Henry is on the air. Join "Paul Henry Must Go" on Facebook. Take a stand against racism, homophobia, sexism, and just plain old ignorance on the airways! Email Progressive enterprises at customerinfo@progressive.co.nz and let them know that you refuse to spend your hard-earned dollars on groceries affiliated with racism! Sample email. Send to: customerinfo@progressive.co.nz Dear Progressive Enterprises - I normally shop at your stores. However, because of Paul Henry's recent racist comments about Sir Anand, I have decided to boycott all Foodtown, Woolworths and Countdown stores until Progressive Enterprises pulls its sponsorship of the Breakfast Show or until Paul Henry departs that show. Regards, Your Name Here

05 Oct 2010 09:16p.m.

Rumalee wrote:

Comments like Paul Henry's are terrifying when viewed through the lens of history...genocide, holocaust, star of david emblems, darfur, somalia, ethnic cleansing...shame on you, Paul. Paul needs to be held responsible for his comments - saying Paul was just being Paul is not enough. Can we say Hitler was only being Hitler?

05 Oct 2010 08:47p.m.

gigo wrote:

Interesting. Bob Stanley I agree with what you have said. People so offended must lead such a miserable life. Paul Henry was awarded the peoples choice as best presenter. Mike B - get a life man! I too have been to many countries and have seen far worse presenters than PH. I think he is a breath of fresh air and is ALL class. Turn the channel dont watch if you dont like it. It is a sad sad world when the media sensationalise something like this. Why not focus on REAL issues.

05 Oct 2010 03:22p.m.

Dodger wrote:

Is it not OK to say Hone is more Kiwi than pakehas?

04 Oct 2010 10:55p.m.

PB wrote:

Here is the challenge, not what questions are being asked but what the answer is. The country is essentially up in arms because a journalist/commentator asked a question that made some people uncomfortable. Isn't that his job? An alternative way to look at this is that Prime Minister Key was given an opportunity to address the Governor General's background and his contributions to the community prior to being appointed to the role. A conversation that should have been had when the Governor General was appointed, is the normal man in the street able to turn around and defend the Governor General's New Zealandness? More broadly it was an opportunity to address what being a New Zealander means and how we should be working together as one nation. As the leader of the nation, the Prime Minister was given an opening to use the bully pulpit to affect the nations thought process and get people talking about this. Education, debate lead to and understanding are the key to stamping out racism. You cannot expect citizens to just start believing because it is politically correct. Maybe the citizens of New Zealand should be encouraged to share, in a public forum, controversial ideas that are being discussed around dinner tables so that they can be challenged and debated and attitudes changed. It's not going to happen behind closed doors so maybe we should be thanking Paul Henry for raising the issue.

04 Oct 2010 03:28p.m.

Mike B wrote:

Bob Stanley, if you find anything that Paul Henry says funny, you need to have an IQ of double digits only! He is obnoxious and has no class. As a presenter he must be the worst I have seen in the over 5 countries I have had the pleasure of visiting. Very unproffesional and does not desreve being in the position he is ,as he portrays an image of all New Zealanders which thankfully is very far from the truth. Get him off the air. The sooner the better.

04 Oct 2010 02:51p.m.

Craig Young wrote:

Does TVNZ not realise that the argument that Henry does not offend a given audience is illogical? Presumably, those who are offended by his repeated offensive outbursts have decamped to alternative media outlets rather than put up with his archaic nonsense.

04 Oct 2010 02:25p.m.

Bob Stanley wrote:

Paul Henry has a sense of humour, It's not illegal. Any little quip he makes it seem someone is waiting to be offended. What a miserable life these people must lead.
Try a laugh it does the spirit the world of good.