Petrol tax means Government will reach surplus

Print

Tue, 18 Dec 2012 12:30p.m.

Bill English (Photo: Jared Mason/3 News)

Bill English (Photo: Jared Mason/3 News)

The Government is on track to make its political target of a Budget surplus by 2014/15 – but by the skin of its teeth.

The Treasury’s fiscal forecasts out today show a $66 million surplus in 2014/15.

And Finance Minister Bill English has just admitted that if it wasn’t for today’s announcement of increased petrol taxes – 3 cents a year over the next 3 years, raking in hundreds of millions– then the Government would not have made surplus.

A “paper-thin” surplus

So that $66 million means the books will be back in the black – but only just.

That’s good news for Prime Minister John Key and Mr English who have staked their political reputations on balancing the books that year.

But $66 million can only be described as “paper-thin”.

Because today’s figure in the Half-Year Economic and Fiscal Update (HY-EFU) is down even on the forecast in the May Budget of $197 million – and everyone called that “wafer thin”.

You have got to remember that we are dealing in billions here – a tax revenue forecast of $68.9 billion and expenses of $75.6 billion – and the forecast surplus sits in between this.

As John Key said this morning on Firstline, the surplus is a bit like landing an Airbus A380 on a pin head.

Well, I’m sure Treasury analysts would disagree - but you get the picture.

And English’s statement today makes it clear that global events could dent the surplus – think the United States “fiscal cliff” or the Euro-crisis.

So the National Government’s on track for its goal but the best description is perhaps “there or thereabouts”.

It is no wonder that you see the Government trying to save or rake in every penny it can – take Gerry Brownlee’s announcement today that it will be raising petrol taxes to pay for roads.

Government debt – a risk to New Zealand’s credit rating?

On other fronts, the Government’s net debt as a percentage of GDP (its debt as a percentage of the economy) heads up to 29.5 percent by 2014/15.

Now the Beehive has always been worried that hitting 30 percent would cause a credit downgrade – so this is on track, but oh so close too.

Unemployment rate – to fall, but remains high

The unemployment rate is set to peak next year at 6.9 percent.

It is forecast to fall to 6.2 percent in 2014 and 5.9 percent in 2015. English has admitted – that’s not good enough.

Economic growth

The economy is expected to grow. Growth was 1.6 percent in 2011/12. The forecasts show 2.3 percent in 2012/13, 2.9 percent in 2013/14 and 2.5 percent in 2014/15.

Now it is important to note that this is down about 0.5 percent on the growth forecasts in the Budget.

So the economy is expected to grow – just not by as much as six months ago.

3 News

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

4/01/2013 7:27:16 p.m.

jannis wrote:

you just dont think do you , by then there will be another 100,000 out of work so even less revenue . they dont think at all and thats the problem . you wright what you are told to wright other wise they will get some one who will pat .little more than a dog on a rope that is .

4/01/2013 6:59:55 p.m.

bernard wrote:

i always said national is the party of high taxation . they are goomers lairs and crooks . and the mainstream media are in bed with them thats for sure .

20/12/2012 1:05:08 p.m.

bernard mahoney wrote:

pat you know they will do nothing of the sort national have never produced a surplus in my life time mate spanning many governments . if they do they have not it will be the most cooked up most corrupt surplus we have seen of and a few days ago they spunged billions in loans from some body to keep paying for tax cuts for the evil wicked and greedy people in this nation the biggest bludgers on the state of all th eelite rich .

19/12/2012 10:48:55 p.m.

marcus wrote:

@Mike,You claim that under a labour led govt debt peaked at 10% of GDP yet this article has National with an expected 29.5% as a percentage of GDP. I can safely say that this is not the last tax to be gifted the working and middle class under this government.All it would take is for the global economy to lag further and its passed onto the average kiwi while the wealthiest kiwis and foreigners can buy more of NZ's strategic assets and land. If National rescinded the tax cuts they gave to the rich NZ would be in the black again tomorrow,nevermind 2014/2015 and that Mike is a fact!

19/12/2012 10:25:06 a.m.

patterson wrote:

i know now why the nats are reducing warrants to apease motorists while they put up petrol prices to get themselves out of the crap

19/12/2012 9:42:05 a.m.

Eric wrote:

English:- 'By the skin of its teeth - is on track to make its political target of a Budget surplus by 2014/15', Easy! If they are falling behind just bump up the taxes of the working people. Oh no, not the wealthy. Then more funding for sport, Is it just coincidence that the two announcements came together? Don't the public already fund sport via sponsors via the products they buy? It would not be so bad if the taxes were directed towards those on the poverty line!

19/12/2012 8:33:41 a.m.

Greg wrote:

National said early this year they wouldnt let Len put a regional fuel tax on to pay for the loop. When the price of milk drops in 2016 the country will be bankrupted by 2020. I'l be retiring to Thailand.

19/12/2012 7:51:57 a.m.

Wiseacre wrote:

So, on Planet Key, increasing income taxes on the rich to combat poverty is bad, but increasing consumption taxes - that impact overwhelmingly upon the poor - to pay for uneconomical roads to nowhere is good. This is a tax-grab by National because they can't balance the books. Putting the screws on the little guy so the rich don't have to pay higher income taxes; or capital gains taxes; or financial transaction taxes. The rich hoard *their* wealth while the poor get forced to pay for the folly of $12 billion uneconomical roads to nowhere. That money would be much better invested in improving public transport, improving existing roads, upgrading the rail network, and better walking and cycling routes. This will just make it more expensive for people to get to work. Car usage & vehicle ownership is already trending down due to the price of fuel, and if these tax increases cause more people to start using public transport, they won't get the projected revenue needed to balance the books. Another ill-thought-out policy that will only depress the economy even further. Much like the raise in GST failed to cover the hole left by the *fiscally neutral* tax cuts, this policy has *Epic Fail* written all over it.

19/12/2012 5:44:55 a.m.

mrman wrote:

I'm so glade i have a push-bike I've already been getting really fit lately from riding every where. I'm not going to complain im just going to really ask my self, do i really need a car any more? Its just becoming to expensive.

18/12/2012 8:23:52 p.m.

Brent wrote:

@PATTY, Ya think they should Postpone the Fuel Tax again, I mean they Did say they would have 3.5 cents by 2013, Looks like that Tax take might be down by half a cent,

Patrick Gower

Political Editor

Patrick is the 3 News Political Editor based in Wellington. Here he offers his commentary on New Zealand politics from his front-row seat in the Press Gallery. He has been a journalist for 15 years, covering stories in Afghanistan and on the US presidential election campaign trail, and was previously a political and investigative reporter for the New Zealand Herald.

Patrick Gower's Entries

Previous123Next