3News » Home

Pike River: A reflection

Sat, 27 Nov 2010 2:27p.m.

By Jeremy Elwood

There is really only one story this week, and it does not lend itself to satire, so if I may, I’d like to simply share a few thoughts on the tragic news from the West Coast.

I happened to be live on air as a guest on Radio New Zealand’s The Panel when we interrupted the discussion to break the news of the second explosion. It was a visceral moment, and listening back to the broadcast, you can hear the intake of breath from all involved as Andrew MacRae, who was impeccable, outlined the worst possible news. We then had five minutes to fill before the hourly news came on, and quite simply they were the hardest five minutes of my career to date. In that moment, I gained an entirely new respect for the journalists who do this kind of thing on an all-too-regular basis – maintaining dignity, accuracy and professionalism whilst battling your own churning emotions is a remarkable skill.

Over the last week the media have come under scrutiny, criticism and even outright attack – and often, particularly in the case of The Australian’s Ean Higgins, they have deserved it.

However, as with any career, journalists are individuals, and many of them, both from this network and all the others, have individually been exceptional.

I’d also like to extend the utmost respect to the two most visible faces of this tragedy as it unfolded – Peter Whittall and Superintendent Gary Knowles. Both have shown great integrity and strength in the midst of what has probably been the worst week of their lives; at least partially by never losing sight of the fact that it was much, much harder for the families of the trapped men.

They have both also shown the power of the three most underutilized words at press conferences – “I don’t know”. Rather than attempt to blind us with science, distract us with analogy or hide behind obfuscation, they shared when they could, admitted when they could not, and consistently reminded us all of what was at stake once the cameras stopped rolling.

The most palpable thing that was shared this week was grief. The West Coast is a tough part of the world, and the people are as staunch as anyone you’ll ever come across. However, in these dreadful hours, their emotions were plain to see.

In a country like ours which, even a few short years ago, seemed a bastion of the idea of the “good keen man” the willingness of families, key figures in the event and ordinary members of the community to weep has in some way allowed us all to be even more able to weep with them.

There is something about the idea of a mining disaster that is almost archaic in this age of workplace safety, air conditioning and ubiquitous hand sanitizer, but this has from the very beginning, and particularly once the names were released, been an all too human tragedy.

Questions will be asked for a long time to come. There will be more tears, there will be more anger, and this is anything but over for everyone involved in any way. But I for one would like to see the families given space, time and support so that they can come to terms with something most of us will, all willing, never have to bear.

One week ago, 29 men went to work. They never came home.

It is that simple.

It is that awful. 

Comments [6]

chris
01 Dec 2010 02:02p.m.

Andrew no one has ever suggested an open cast mine for the coal reserve that Pike River is mining. Way too far underground. Never been done anywhere.

Andrew
29 Nov 2010 12:03p.m.

Re#2 Pyke - I tend to agree with yuor thoughts. But I put the blame fairly and squarely on the "Green Party" and its equally guilty alley "Labour". The mining company wanted to have an "open cast" mine but the "Green Party" refused to allow this method of mining!
Next the "Green Party" would only allow the miminum number of ventilation shafts to be drilled. Then "Labour" did away with mining inspectors some years ago. Thus I am not too surprised at the outcome at the mine.

cyril
27 Nov 2010 10:50p.m.

I think the press acted in there usual lame way looking for a story when there wasnt one to tell instead of just saying "we have nothing to tell you at this time". Especially Campbell with his hand wringing and tear filled storys

Neil
27 Nov 2010 10:43p.m.

I cant agree with your views re the media.
The NZ journalism to my mind was often lacking substance, detail and an objective and enquiring angle.
While such an unfortunate event needs to be handled with a good deal of sensitivity that isnt any reason to disconnect your brain in deference to presenting a palatable story for primetime viewing or authorities.
If you only have journos recycling notes from briefing and an audience who accept accounts without question and little depth then the reporting can be judged a success.
Ean may have misjudged the sensitivity part of his mission but at least he was willing to pursue a greater understanding of the circumstance.
Probably a more factual and useful account will come out of the official inquiry reports.
It may be more socially acceptable to ask more about what actually occurred after someone else with official sanction has already asked it.
This isnt very reassuring for those who would consider freedom of information, speech and pursuit of truth and justice to be the cornerstones of democracy and our way of life.

Pyke
27 Nov 2010 07:24p.m.

umm....."we" collectively did away with, I think, 11 lives the weekend before, including cyclists on the national roads/cycleway. What happened at Labour weekend on the roads? Concentrating on one "accident scene"... the damage seems that much greater...or something? Pike rever is a gamble and $300 million plus to date gamble, optimistic capitalism in the age of global warming. Mr Whittal playing the erudite, well spoken face, for the company spin, think about it....why was he promoted to CEO? ...well no one else wants a hospital pass, or this on their CV...promote someone from within... and the blind will continue to lead...if ya get my drift....so much for surgical mining and trying to catch Aussie...perhaps Don Brash will be able to advise the Mine on how to catch-up with modern day practices. ...wake up NZ...how much is Bell English borrowing to keep the show afloat... on a weekly basis? ..we need to be selling the coal to pay the interest...don't give me Juan campbell and saint marksbury...faux reality while ya drown in the carry trade.. ...I'm sorry for your loss....but can we get real now!?

Bryce
27 Nov 2010 03:06p.m.

Thank you Jeremy for voicing the thoughts of so many of us ..... At the end of the day those boys won't be home !....... R.I.P

Post a comment

Name:
Email: (Won't be published)
Comment:


3News Video 3News Audio