‘I’m not dirty!’ – Dunne. ‘Yes you are!’ - Gower

Print

Thu, 28 Jul 2011 5:38p.m.

Peter Dunne called his spin-doctors into action after reading one of Patrick's blogs

Peter Dunne called his spin-doctors into action after reading one of Patrick's blogs

By Patrick Gower

Peter Dunne's spin brigade has tried on a full-frontal filthy denial of his dirty deal in Ohariu with John Key/National. 

Dunne's found time to cast his eye over my last blog and dispatched one of his henchmen to say: 

"What's all this ‘dirty’ stuff???”  

It’s always good to know someone is reading. And no, they didn't complain about me saying “if there was no Dunne-deal" he'd "go more feral than one of the possums he doesn't want to use 1080 on”.

So that was a pleasant surprise. 

Dunne's crew did say "what's all this dirty stuff???" like they are some kind of pack of angels.  

Dunne’s spin-doctor says:

"It's all up front and out there for people to vote for whichever MP they want, at least on our side… ( Labour and the Greens are the ones doing denials…Now that's dirty!!).”

But what the spin-meister really wanted to debate was my assertion there is no "strategic advantage" to National doing the Dunne-deal and knee-capping the National candidate just to avoid the threat of Labour’s Charles Chauvel getting the seat in a three-way race.


 

Here’s some more from Dunne's henchman:

"Even if United Future doesn't bring in a second or third MP in [off the party vote] and Peter holds his seat, it will actually be 'plus one' for a centre-right Government.. so there is a numbers gain… Therefore counter to your line, there is a strategic advantage., Katrina holding the seat would mean they are effectively one vote down… they won't get an extra MP as she is already in on the list… and Peter would be gone."

I agree. A back-of-the envelope analysis shows if United Future polls below .4%, and Dunne wins the seat, there will be an overhang - and a "plus one" bonus.

But if United Future polled between .4 and 1.2%, that would be proportional - there is no bonus.

So there is a chance of a strategic advantage in this dirty deal, especially if, as the polls show, United Future get 0% or close to it.

But there may also be no advantage at all, particularly if Dunne boosts his profile in the campaign debates.

So I stand by my argument that there could be no strategic advantage to this deal and it’s just to keep Charles Chauvel out and there may also be a back-room deal with John Key.

So all up, another filthy deal by Dunne. As my Aunty Anne used to say: "you can't put icing sugar on a cow pat and call it a meringue". 

But full credit to Dunne, at least they have replied to my blog and tried to deny the cruddy deal.

Neither National, Labour nor the Greens have bothered to deny their vile, yecchy deals.

Don Brash did for ACT but a news article today shows that he's already kneecapped their man in New Plymouth.

It’s called being "in denial" and no doubt makes it easier to sleep when you've done a dirty deed.

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

11 Aug 2011 04:51p.m.

DEBBIE wrote:

BEFORE THE LAST ELECTION PAT THE MEDIA GAVE LABOUR ONE HELL OF A HARD TIME ABOUT THESE KINDS OF DEALS , FIX THE ELECTION THEY SAID . NOW ITS NATIONAL DOING IT YOU THE MEDIA SAY NOTHING AGAINST THEM . WHY DOUBLE STANDARD PAT ? WHY DO YOU GUYS HAVE ONE SET OF RULES FOR LABOUR AND ANOTHER WHEN IT COMES TO KEY . THEY WINGED WHEN CLARK TRAVELED THIS MR KEY IS NEVER IN THE COUNTRY AND YET PATRICK GOWER YOU GUYS DONT SAY A WORD ABOUT IT . WHY DO YOU PEOPLE IN THE MEDIA DO THAT ? WHY ARE YOU DOING IT ? LOVE A RESPONCE MATE CHEERS.

07 Aug 2011 11:14a.m.

Clarke wrote:

@Fred All parties hire public relations companies, and yes that even includes online bloggers so Patrick has every right to suspect you of being a paid National party hillbilly. Thats the way the new media empire works, politicians have even resorted to using facbook and twitter. I believe that most people have paid mouthpieces, National uses Cameron Slater (a known nut job) to leak information to on a consistent basis. Even though whaleoil has severe mental health issues and no impulse control, National still utilises this idiot. The problem with a mad dog like slater is that you have to really careful that he doesnt also bite the hand that feeds him too. So Patrick asking if you are a paid mouthpiece given the times we live in and the fact that social networking is utilised by all political groups now is a valid question.

02 Aug 2011 08:51a.m.

Clarke wrote:

When you have a party that is blatantly manipulating the popular vote you dont really need voters to hop out and into the voting booths come November do you, they just arrange everything for themselves and bypass the whole democracy aspect. It should be a legal requirement that all parties stand candidates in each electorate, that way they then have no choice and cant manipulate the vote to suit themselves. That these deals are happening is a damned good sign that Key knows the polls are very wrong, if they were right National would have no need to manipulate the vote like this. However they could just be doing it to bring ACT into parliamanet so that they have a coalition partner to blame for some of their more radical policies. No more interest free student loans? no more working for families? Upping the retirement age. All of these are options under and National / ACT coalition agreement.

02 Aug 2011 02:01a.m.

"Fred" wrote:

Wow Patrick, what a fiery response. It is just me or are you quite the paranoid little man? First it's Dunne's spin doctors after you (can't even write that with a straight face), and now the beehive has people commenting on your blog! Then again, I shouldn't underestimate your power and influence, you did afterall attend a John Key press conference (which I'm lead to believe is the true mark of a serious and respect-worthy journo - they don't let just anybody see the Prime Minister).

You are of course entitled to your opinions; my concern is when you present these opinions as fact. This is exactly what I was getting at with my first post - you (and by this I mean the media in NZ in general) are misleading us. Come on Patrick, you used to be a serious investigative reporter but now you run a political gossip column. Shape up!

01 Aug 2011 10:39p.m.

UFS wrote:

... and United Future is undoubtedly the most honest of our political parties too.

31 Jul 2011 11:18a.m.

Ruz wrote:

Peter Dunne and the dubious deal making that goes on between parties is one of the resons why I will be voting for a return of FPP. Get rid of the party vote and the gloves are off. Dunne will be history then as National try and take the electorate seat.

30 Jul 2011 03:01p.m.

AndrewF wrote:

@erm : to understand how FPP is corrupted/manipulated you need to look up 'gerrymandering'.

29 Jul 2011 02:39p.m.

Doug wrote:

Why has everyone got so precious about this issue with Peter Dunne? After all others are doing the same and while you may not agree with it the fact is that having smaller parties in parliament does provide a wider and more representative range of views. If Peter Dunne gets into parliament he will bring in policies that no other party wishes to touch. Whether you agree with him or not, Dunne is putting 1080 on notice and saying he wishes to see it banned. No other party has said this and yet there are tens if not hundreds of thousands of New Zealanders who want 1080 banned - should their voices not be represented?

And as a resident in the Oahriu electorate I am amazed that not one of the other party candidates standing against Dunne actually lives in the area or has even said they will move here if they win. At least Dunne is a true electorate MP who looks after his constituency.

And I am not a United Future spin doctor. I just happen to like the fact that under MMP we are getting a much fairer and truer representation in parliament of more sectors in society. One of the great successes of MMP in my mind has been the Maori party. They are able to speak for thier nationwide constituency in a way that FPP did not allow.

Get with it people - we need to have parliament represent as wide a sector of our population as is possible. It is something called democracy.

29 Jul 2011 01:20p.m.

Taylor Dane wrote:

Peter Dunne has 'henchmen'? He's starting to sound like quite a player. This has been quite an interesting couple of blog-posts. Just typical to see all the usual Trotskyist inebriates having a pathetic bash at his hairdo to shut down any debate. As for a deal, can't see the dirty aspect myself. That's politics ladies.

29 Jul 2011 11:15a.m.

Patrick Gower wrote:

C'Mon "Fred", if you are going to come on here and bag and belittle me you must get your facts straight you are a liar.
I was there when John Key was asked about the possibility of a deals on April 18 and he said "maybe Ohariu". So it was never out in the open as you attest. It only came right out in the open when Shanks kneecapped by National chiefs. If not for her we still wouldn't really know for sure. So tell the truth Fred, and come out of the shadows you sound distinctly as if you work in the Beehive, or at the very least some sort of party hack apologist who has watched too many West Wing DVDs and dreams of being some Machivellian type. Its a deal, yes they do happen I'm not naive, but that doesn't mean I can't have an opinion about them. Please keep reading and if you are ever bored up there in your Beehive office just come down and see me. PG







Patrick Gower's Entries

Finance Minister Bill English delivers the 2012 Budget (Photo: Jared Mason)

OPINION: English taxes the smokers but leaves the boozers

The path to that wafer-thin surplus in 2014/15 will be paved by taxing the life out of smokers.

Comments (5)

Key is looking quite up-for-it and motivated at the moment - I've heard him say on a number of occasions recently that he wants to "get stuff done" (pic: file/Victoria Evans)

Key still holds all the cards

The typewriters have been telling their interviewers that all the sideshows are wearing the PM down - in my experience, the typewriter is often wrong.

Comments (13)

John Key has been telling everyone how much he likes the local nasi goreng

Key's love of nasi goreng shows why he likes Crafar sale

John Key wolfs down a big feed of nasi goreng – and washes it down with some Southland sheep milk.

Comments (17)

McCully hacker now says he's Kiwi

The McCully hacker, self-described Russian 'Yuri Petrov', is now claiming he's just a normal old Kiwi bloke.

Comments (1)

Who is the Russian who hacked McCully's emails?

So who is the McCully hacker?

What I can say is about how I came into contact with the hacker - it was through Twitter.

Comments (2)

"Key and Joyce are sick of people who say 'you can't' when it comes to projects that generate economic growth."

SkyCity pokies deal should be a conscience vote

The odds against a conscience vote are the same as those against someone beating a pokie machine - the machine always wins.

Comments (16)

Gower: David Shearer had a shocker with his response on the ‘Nick Smith political favours scandal’.

Shearer's shocker on Nick Smith scandal

It has to be said: David Shearer had a shocker with his response on the ‘Nick Smith political favours scandal’.

Comments (13)

Lesley Longstone

Sex offender teacher: Bureaucratic heads must roll

Public sector heads must roll, argues 3 News political reporter Patrick Gower.

Comments (9)

Politics 2011 was "bloody exciting"

Patrick Gower's bloody exciting end of year blog

Politics bores the hell out of most punters, says Patrick Gower, so he'll sum it up for you in a few short words.

Comments (3)

Phil Goff and Winston Peters

Goff should rule out Winston – right now

Peters has left Goff stranded up the aisle. Shame! Goff should have ditched Peters first – and long ago.

Comments (12)

Don Brash says marijuana should be decriminalised

Banks will roll Brash as ACT leader, it's inevitable - blog

It seems inevitable John Banks will take out Don Brash as the leader of the ACT party.

Comments (13)

Key says without the urgent law change, "criminals will walk free" - this is essentially blackmail

Labour must harden up and reject police spy-video law change

Goff needs to look in the mirror and say to himself: I am not going to cave into the petty politics of John Key on this one.

Comments (15)

Peter Dunne called his spin-doctors into action after reading one of Patrick's blogs

‘I’m not dirty!’ – Dunne. ‘Yes you are!’ - Gower

Peter Dunne's spin brigade has tried on a full-frontal filthy denial of his dirty deal in Ohariu with John Key/National.

Comments (19)

Electorate deals are dirtier than AC/DC after a particularly long and sweaty tour

Dirty electorate political deals, done dirt cheap - blog

It's election year - there are dirty deals all over the shop and they are taking genuine choice away from voters.

Comments (21)

ACT voters might be wondering if getting rid of Hide was such a good idea

The ACT Party looks pretty much stuffed

The rebranded ACT Party looks like a couple of old blokes on life support.

Comments (30)

Key badly wants a piece of what's going on in India

Key turns pirate-hunter to nab Indian deal

John Key the deal-maker has thrown the possibility of a NZ warship chasing Somali pirates into the mix of the India Free Trade deal.

Comments (11)

Bishop Brian Tamaki

Destiny Church and politics: All about money and votes - blog

All I could think when I saw the Maori politicians getting blessed by Brian Tamaki was "who is using who here"?

Comments (26)

IRB Chief Executive Mike Miller is just too chummy with Frank Bainimarama's regime

Old Farts at IRB have lost the plot over Fiji

Here's a question for International Rugby Board - what part of "Military Dictatorship" don't you understand?

Comments (39)

Patrick Gower is a 3 News Political Reporter based in Wellington.

Here he offers his commentary on New Zealand politics from his front-row seat in the Press Gallery.

He has been a journalist for ten years, going as far as Afghanistan to get his stories, and was previously a political and investigative reporter for the New Zealand Herald

Subscribe to this blog by email