Decision to fly Maori flag dividing caucuses - Story - Politics - 3 News
3News » Home
Full Story

Decision to fly Maori flag dividing caucuses

13 comments | Post Comment Email Print Text Size:
aA
aA
aA
Tue, 15 Dec 2009 5:29p.m.

By Scott Campbell

Waitangi Day is still almost two months away but the Government’s decision to fly a Maori flag high above official buildings and the Auckland Harbour Bridge has caused some splits; mate against mate, caucus colleague against colleague.

It is the representation of Maori self-determination and separatism and it is again causing division, not just between political opponents, but party colleagues.
 
Labour leader Phil Goff says he quite likes the design, while one of his MPs says he does not want it foisted on him.

“I don’t like the notion that that flag is going to be the Maori flag on the Harbour Bridge or, for that matter, on Government House,” says Labour MP Shane Jones.

“I'm not opposing it, I've made that clear. But I've said it’s a minor issue,” says Phil Goff.

Mr Jones claims the decision to fly the Maori flag alongside the New Zealand one is tokenism and a have, payback for the Maori Party supporting the Government.

This despite 80 percent of Maori canvassed saying they wanted it and even his own boss saying he likes the design.

“This flag has been forced upon us; it’s really Hone’s flag. Hone Harawira ran that farcical process and it’s a small gesture, I suppose, to keep him in the tent.”

Kaumatua Kingi Taurua says he won't be hoisting it at Te Tii Marae in Waitangi; he says it is not liked in the Far North.

The Prime Minister, though, is resolute.

“There’s always going to be some people who don't think it’s the right flag and that’s why 80 percent of the submissions supported it and 20 percent did not. But that’s equally true of the New Zealand flag. There was a movement not so long ago from a reasonably large bunch of New Zealanders who didn't think we should fly the current New Zealand flag,” John Key says.

But, like Labour, even Mr Key's own Caucus do not seem to universally support their leader.

While publicly they are toeing the party line, politically some feel it could be more trouble than it's worth.

3 News

Comments [13]

Jimmy
22 Dec 2009 3:32p.m.

In Oz they have a flag for the country as a whole, the state that I live in has a flag, and the city I live in within that state has a flag. The high school I went to had a flag, the sports club had a flag. Is this being divisive??? The Macedonian community in my city had a cultural day a few weeks back. I saw lots of flags from their cultural background. Yet it is not seen as being divisive, but being proud of your culture. It seems to me that some ignorant people don't understand the point of a Maori flag. I guess us whinging dole bludgers (or Maori as I prefer to call myself) should forget about our culture and just assimilate into the "one size fits all" culture. Which is just a euphemism for saying "don't express any culture that isn't white european". It is laughable that when people look at Maori symbols all they can think of is protest and hatred. Yes the flag that has been chosen, has been used by radical Maoris who express unjustified hate to others. But in the same way the Union Jack has been hijacked by racist groups over in the UK. This does not make the flag inherently a symbol of hate. Worst of all is that there are people who have a problem with a Maori flag being displayed on Waitangi day??? What the hell do you think this day represents? It is meant to be a celebration of a treaty that defined a partnership agreement between two peoples. Both flags flying over Auckland harbour would be a great gesture of the equality and unity of Pakeha and Maori. Yet it seems now that one partner is resenting the other trying to express their culture or equality. Would it be more fitting to have the Maori flag sitting at the bottom of the harbour? Is this a more appropriate symbol of the attitude that some Pakeha have of the relationship between Maori and Pakeha? Read your own countries history and stop being ignorant about the bicultural foundations of New Zealand!!!

mary
19 Dec 2009 10:10p.m.

Why are we flying this so called "Tino Rangatiratanga" flag or "MONEY" flag. This isnt the real Maori flag, or correct me please. I believed the (ORIGINAL) Maori flag dated back to before 1835 (WHAKAPUTANGA) The Independence Flag. Oh how stupid "kee" Fly every nationality flag. LMAO.

Ramlin77
19 Dec 2009 3:22p.m.

Same outrage, same comments from ignorant people was made when Cathy Freeman went ahead and proudly carried her flag in the games. The saddest thing was all the whites made a song and dance about it, when all she wanted to do was show the world how proud she is to be aboriginal and this is their country in which they share with numerous cultures. Whats the big deal about Maori having their own flag, was it not their country first?? In which they now share with many cultures! Comment to Drifter & Richard below; I see your english ancestors ways of thinking have been passed down from generation to generation. Let maori people have their flag, for the time being it will take away the focus of how they were robbed of their land, just like the aboriginals, indians and the like. And to think the white people have all the answers as they continue to live by greed, & rule the world by destroying it.

Bex
17 Dec 2009 6:19p.m.

The govenment should not encourage separatism of cultures. Having a maori flag is encouraging separatism. It will cause resentment. For every other culture. If they are going to allow a maori flag, why not allow every other culture that has come to NZ to fly their own flag too? One country one flag.

Drifter
16 Dec 2009 4:20p.m.

Lets go one better lets put all the Maori on the south and let the whites have the north and they can have there own country money flag ect ect ect.that will solve it once and for all let them look after there own like they want.

Richard
16 Dec 2009 8:17a.m.

Let the baby have its bottle, at least it will keep it quite for a while, let it think its tantrum was for something

chappy
16 Dec 2009 8:15a.m.

WELL DONE; SHARPLE'S N' KEY'S in handling the past month's
fiasco's and this last decision to fly the flag is as it should be (no harm in that) although people(mostly white would like to look @ it as seperatism People try this recognition for maori living here in Aotearoa jeeesss!!!

Reuben
16 Dec 2009 3:24a.m.

i dont understand whats the big deal about a flag representing one of the important cultures in New Zealand. We do not need 2 different flags because we're one whole country even if they are 2 islands. NZ has to stay united and if we should have 2 flags representing the people that this land belongs to then there's no issue in that. Whats a country without its people right...This is my point of view on the situation I'm just saying

Terry
16 Dec 2009 12:37a.m.

Maori sovereignty flag a representation of activisim and hatred toward white folk,,Hone`s flag has no place flying beside our steeped in history NZ flag, my father would be turning in his grave.

This will cause more radicalism and further division in this already racist (towards whites) country.

What are you thinking Key?!

Glenn
15 Dec 2009 8:43p.m.

Maybe then we could have a north island and south island Flag too, if we are going to separate some why not separate them all. I am so over seeing the divisions caused in NZ by the cultures, havnt we paid our dues already with the handouts, how long do the rest of us Kiwis have to suffer, as a result of long time ago. Come on NZ unite as one.

Post a comment

Name:
Email: (Won't be published)
Comment:


3News Video 3News Audio

Post your opinion

3News - Steven Joyce
Comments (19)

Changes to student loans - what's your opinion?

So Steven Joyce has announced that students who are failing more than half their courses will not have access to a student loan. What is your view?...