3News » Home
Full Story

Govt considering separate welfare programme for Maori

66 comments | Post Comment email Email printer friendly Print    Text Size:
aA
aA
aA
Minister of Social Development Paula Bennett

Minister of Social Development Paula Bennett

video
Thu, 17 Dec 2009 5:14p.m.

By Duncan Garner

Official documents obtained exclusively by 3 News show the Government is close to a decision that would see millions of dollars set aside to fund a separate Maori welfare system.

The taxpayer millions would be handed over to private Maori agencies that will be tasked with delivering social services to Maori families.

It is a bold and controversial extension of a current aid programme called Whanau Ora and a cause the Maori Party has been championing.

The Waipareira Trust delivers social services to West Aucklanders and this is the one-stop-shop the Government wants to model its new Whanau Ora programme on - services for Maori, delivered by Maori.

Maori Party co-leader Pita Sharples says the programme helps empower families to help themselves.

“It is about re-energising and re-empowering whanau to do it for themselves to determine their own destiny," he says.

Senior ministers met in the Beehive on Monday night to discuss the programme.

3 News has obtained advice sent to ministers, which entails special social services directed at Maori whanau only. The Government may broaden the approach one day to include pakeha families.

Whanau Ora is about assessing whether current services are being delivered in a "holistic and empowering way from the perspective of whanau".

Minister of Social Development Paula Bennett says the programme is about combining the main social services.

“It's about pulling together housing, health, justice, all of it, social services as well,” she says.

The documents also recommend Prime Minister John Key appoint a new Whanau Ora Minister. The minister would oversee and be responsible for special Whanau Ora funding to be spread over six Whanau Ora sites around the country by next year - and more locations every year until 2013.

Former Labour Party Minister John Tamihere heads the Waipareira Trust - he says the new programme simplifies assistance to families in need.

“Whanau Ora is in a nutshell one case manager handling all things in regard to a family and ensuring that they are navigated through their difficulties," he says.

Mr Tamihere says Whanau Ora works - but Labour didn't want to do it.

“We've achieved more in nine months - policy shifts out on the street that all Maori are supportive of - under this Government than we did in nine years with the last - that's just a fact,” he says.

The documents show ministers are to make decisions at a crucial cabinet meeting on February 1.

Labour says it is waiting to hear more about Whanau Ora before taking a position. 

Labour is currently sensitive about Maori issues, with one senior MP telling 3 News that criticism of the Whanau Ora programme could make the party look racist. But generally Labour views programmes like Whanau Ora with suspicion, and as the first steps towards the privatisation of welfare.

3 News

 

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Comments [66]

vyxn
04 Feb 2010 2:18p.m.

Jan... another Maori radical with a big mouth. I don't live on Maori land. Try stepping onto my land... I'm sure my dog will tell you otherwise, and he aint a racist Maori. If you want to split hairs, I believe you stole this land from the Mori Ori's. You are a racist and it's people like you who are creating more separatism in this country. I bet you are one of the Maori's screaming poverty and "poor me". Yeah, I would go to another country but unfortunately I rely on welfare as my MAORI husband took off when our son was 6 and hasn't bothered seeing him since (with no financial contribution except his $12 p/wk to IRD). Oh I know, let's make it that the Maori don't have to pay child support either - afterall, they are all living in poverty. I went to WINZ just yesterday about work but apparently they don't have careers advisors, yet I bet you will get what you want (as someone suggested, laptops etc).
Might I even venture to say that you are prob one of those Maori with a stiff arm - and no doubt passing the same attitudes onto your kids. And don't forget your separate justice system Maori is pushing for, that one will be priceless. Only one racist I can see in these comments Jan - must be a Maori aye!!!! You poor helpless, poverty stricken elitist.

Jan..
03 Feb 2010 2:40p.m.

Bex your comment is out of control this is Maori land is all they have and who are you to question the matter..
The Maori culture is nothing like the corruption you brought into our country today..Get real Bex..

dale
15 Jan 2010 8:01p.m.

Racist Racist Racist. This is excluding people, then everyone else misses out

robbie
14 Jan 2010 12:13p.m.

well..i think Waipareira trust from personal experience with them are full of sh*t..i went there for help as a maori and got nothing but promises they would help me with this and that and they did absolutely nothing! no programs, no assistance with work, no assistance with medical issues ..no assistance with nothing..
I'm a maori and i can tell you i am very supportive of maori issues of all sorts as anyone who reads any of my other comments in the Opinion section will tell you.
But i dont support this stinkin trust at all. If the government wants to use this trust to initiate whanau ora then god help all of us maoris, good rort though John Tamihere and all you others working there.Your all a joke!!
The government can use there money to help maori in other ways but not with Waipareira Trust.

Diana
03 Jan 2010 1:54p.m.

No-one seems to have noticed that we already have separate government funded health care (tikanga maori needs assessment, disease prevention, health promotion & medical care)and schooling (pre-school, primary, secondary & tertiary)for Maori (as well as a separate political party based on race); so why, now, waste so much energy criticising the proposed introduction of tikanga Maori in our welfare system??? The issue is much larger than discussed here; and so increadibly well-immersed into our political, economic and social persona that the only way to realistically respond is to break away from the priveledge-based constitution under the British monarch and establish an independent, republic constitution.

Julie
30 Dec 2009 1:05p.m.

Whanau Ora is for evey family in NZ. It is about the holistic aproach for families in need not just the single issue at hand.If all the services eg medical social workers, victim support agencies: did their job effeciently then there would be no need for Whanau Ora and extra funding. For some reason people of NZ will not offer advice/help for families in need. Why? There are agencies that deliver every service for all issues one could ever want in NZ, so why is it whanau/families are not connected with them? In my opinion the social workers need to be trained to adopt the holistic aproach, the whole country will benefit then. High time NDers got off their backsides and put more effort into their work. Then there would be no need for Whanau Ora.

Bex
22 Dec 2009 6:59p.m.

The majority of Maori need to learn to hear one word : NO!
Why should a whole society suffer for the selfish greedy wants of one culture?
The government needs to lead by example and say NO! No more hand outs, no more treaty money, no more short cuts to easy money.
The truth is that if any other culture were disadvantaged years and years back, they would get up and celebrate their freedom and work for a better life and therefore have a better life. Have some MANA!

Kim
22 Dec 2009 3:04p.m.

Absolutely ridiculous. Wait for it to all go on administration and the fat cats on top and a tiny % to those in need. Why do we keep going on about making all NZers separate instead of working together as one country all aiming to help NZ

anne
21 Dec 2009 10:34p.m.

A dangerous move in a lot of respects and a system that would need close auditing for years to come.
The maori and part maori population would belong to tribes that were paid out huge settlements for a past grievences, therefore with diligent investment these would be able to support and nuture their reciptents ie members of those tribes, wouldn't it not?.
Questions need to be asked why hasn't the money recieved from those settlements reached EVERY tribal member not just those at the top of the food chain,enough is enough bring on accountability for those who are reaping the benefits of those settlements and not dispersing money to those members who are in dire need,after all that is what the settlements were ment to do, wasnt it?

PWPCSS
20 Dec 2009 3:10p.m.

Yeeeeah riiight..basically, the National party gives a chunk of $ to some joke Maori outfit (e.g. a 'Trust'), they will spend a large % of $ on the incompetent administration of the service and a tiny % on actual welfare - sprinkling a few scraps for a few poor Maori people, with no real change for them, and take the rest and invest it for themselves - this is how tribal Capitalist's operate - worse than the State administration of welfare.

Post a comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide here
Name:
Email: (Won't be published)
Comment:



3News Video 3News Audio