Popular Hamilton doctor barred from practicing

Print

Wed, 18 Aug 2010 6:30p.m.

Dr Suresh Vatsyayann

Dr Suresh Vatsyayann

By Michael Morrah

The Medical Council has suspended a Hamilton doctor's practicing certificate after patients complained about his conduct.

But that's angered other patients, who rely on Dr Suresh Vatsyayann for free consultations.

Now they're worried about where to turn for medical help.

Paul Herbison weighs 231kg, is on the benefit and a has a variety of health problems.

"Without Suresh, I'm finished," he says. "I cannot afford what it would cost me to go and see another doctor on a regular basis."

He visits Dr Vatsyayann twice a month.

"I've had injections, I've had referrals to other specialists, but I've never been charged by him for anything."

But not all patients are happy. Complaints resulted in him being found guilty of providing false or misleading medical notes last year.

Now there are fresh accusations, and, in a letter this week, his patients were advised that the Medical Council was suspending his practising certificate.

"The seriousness of these complaints has been at a threshold that the professional conduct committee has considered it serious enough to lay a charge," says chairman John Adams.

"I think it's horrible what they're doing to him because he is only trying to help the community," says patient Sally Sehnert, "and I think being free he does help as there's thousands of unemployed people that go to him."

But the Medical Council says the interim suspension is in the best interests of the patients.

"The council's responsibility is to protect the health and safety of the public," says Mr Adams.

It is relatively uncommon for doctors to face misconduct charges. Eleven doctors have been charged so far this year out of more than 12,000 who practice and perform more than 11 million consultations every year.

Dr Vatsyayann, who wouldn't be interviewed today, has been given till Friday to stop working at his practice.

Dr Vatsyayann will be back before the Health Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal in October and again in February on a number of charges relating to issues with his record keeping. A public meeting will be held with his supporters in Hamilton tomorrow.

3 News

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

21 Apr 2011 03:30p.m.

Dr Rajesh Guleri wrote:

Dr Suresh is a wonderful human being and an exceptionally competent medical professional. I have witnessed him acting as a messaiha for the ailing humanity. The decision of Medical Council is unjust and deplorable. I fully support Dr Suresh and appeal others to do the same. May God bless him.

15 Apr 2011 11:05p.m.

Anna Roberts wrote:

Suresh Vatsyayann is an outstanding medical professional.

He is being unjustly prosecuted.

Other doctors are frustrated because he offers the same professional medical treatment, but doesnt charge and arm and a leg. He is happy to live within his means, so that he can offer free GP assistance to those that would normally go without instead of paying $20-$60 for a basic consultation.

I support Suresh 100%. This world would be a better place if there were more people as dedicated and caring as Dr Suresh Vatsyayann.

07 Apr 2011 06:55p.m.

michael baylis wrote:

DOCTOR You have my utmost sympathy and support. Keep up the good work! Michael Baylis- retired orthopaedic surgeon

21 Dec 2010 08:27a.m.

Dr. Abhi Bhardwaj wrote:

I know Dr. Suresh personally for more than 40 years. He is one of the most humanitarian, dedicated, and honest doctor I have ever met or seen. He pays from his own pocket for helping poor and needy and would go to any extent to serve them wherever he is. What a shame for Nation like New Zealand to treat a true humanitarian doctor in such a shabby way and take away his practicing licence without any solid reason. It seems like this whole saga is creation of few racist people in media who did not like him personally and were after him ever since he came out and started supporting the cause of poor people in New Zealand. Rather than awarding him for his great services to poor communities he is been tried falsely and deprived of his practicing licence. This really sets an extremely bad precedence for many foreign doctors who aspire to come to New Zealand and be part of this great country. As for as I know Dr. Suresh he is one of the most talented doctor with a true humanitarian heart who does not know dirty politics at all and genuinely want to help poor in any way he can. His case clearly demonstrate that how even in today’s world people like Jesus and Gandhi can be falsely accused and tried. Its high time real people of Hamilton and New Zealand at large should get up and support this great doctor in whatever way they can.

17 Sep 2010 01:12a.m.

GIRISH JASWAL wrote:

A man who selflessly devotes himself to the cause of sick people has to face flak in such a manner!!!it is shameful and uncalled for.Just an email can spur the board to suspend a man whose professional integrity has been unquestionable and whose credentials have far surpassed many who call themselves 'medical professionals'!! Instead of trying to promote such messiahs who never look at the medical profession as a means to earn currency but as a means to assuage the sufferings of people, the board is hell bent on satisfying its phoney ego!!!!dr vatsyayann , we are with you...forever, so just continue doing the good work for which THE ALMIGHTY had created you.

14 Sep 2010 04:37a.m.

RITU NAG wrote:

it is indeed surprising that a man is judged on his behaviour more than his deeds. i have known dr vatsyayann for ages and looked upto him, tried to emulate his selfless love for the profession. it is not surprising that he is giving free consutations to people as he has been doing this in india for ages. till date people remember him with reverence, love and trust as a man who could not bear the suffering of people. dr vatsyayann...we are with you in full strength.

19 Aug 2010 10:17p.m.

Dr. Suresh Vatsyayann wrote:

Those who know me know me. Those who don't know me speak against me or in my favour, it doesn't affect either me or those who know me. I do not have anything against those who don't know me and speak against me, be they people from the medical council, from the ministry of health, Health and disability commission, Waikato DHB managmenet or the governance ...I don't even pity them, I feel sorry for them and pray to God to give them wisdom and sense to serve the people they are meant to serve. No action of their's will ever destabilise my work for which I am meant. What I do is not for them but for the people and the Nature that protects us all, supports us all, loves us all. I forgive you all, today even Ex Bryce Johns of Waikato Times who published Tamara Browning misleading people that I forged her signatures 3 years ago during these months (Mayoral Elections)and did not even have the courtesy to apologise when police forensic report clarified the truth ...I forgeive him for his meanness and conspiracy with the help of the many who then became a part of the institutional organised Mafia ...and forgive those who are still hanging on to crucify me ...in reality, I am thankful to all of them for giving me a chance to forgive them before they end in shame. I am very indebted to thousands of people who have given me tremendous love and spiritual strength including the patients, staff and family. Love is rare, sharing of one's soul is rarer, and being ready to die for someone is divine ...and I am one of the luckiest people I have ever known in my life, be that Socrates, Jesus, Galeleo, Mahatma Gandhi, Martin Luther King, Nelson Mandela and many more unsung heroes who were trashed like lucky me is being trialed ...truth shall prevail, and if it fails, I wouldn't be surprised ...its nothing new ...I love you all and forgive you those who are harming people for your own greed!!!

18 Aug 2010 08:47p.m.

Eugene wrote:

Its truth new zealand got lots of the dodgy doctors, some of them in the Bennet Center in Hamilton.Just wonder how they got the job like that.Too many of them just wondering and eating public money for nothing.

18 Aug 2010 07:13p.m.

Medrate Admin wrote:

Well now, the medical council has offered up a sacrificial lamb in Dr Vatsyayann, he is facing charges on record keeping, once again the medical council is trying to show that is doing its job, which is far from the truth. Yes only 11 faced charges, but a hell of a lot more were referred and only ended up with retraining or counseling for bad behavior. The best they can do is ping someone for record keeping. I highly doubt that any one of his patients complained about him, I think you will find it was ACC or WINZ, or person who thought he handed out medical certificates to whomever asked for them. Doctors who don't charge above what the government gives them are a rare breed indeed. We believe hundreds more cases, that are true examples of misconduct are never brought before the relevant authorities, because of two factors: 1. Fear of the doctor 2. Knowing deep down the medical council look after their own. New Zealand is losing doctors at a rapid rate, and whilst our best head overseas we are left with the scraps, the medical council needs to protect their members like never before, the sad truth it is our health that suffers in the end. Dodgy doctors? Maybe! Come see for yourself: http://www.medrate.co.nz