Power's shock exit leaves power struggle

Print

Wed, 02 Mar 2011 1:01p.m.

Simon Power (NZPA file)

Simon Power (NZPA file)

By Patrick Gower

So who will take Simon Power's role as "next National leader"?

The received wisdom was that Simon Power was on a "marathon run" to be Prime Minister.

Well today he pulled out - and quite a few kilometres along in the race.

And that leaves a bit of a power struggle among the big egos in the National Party.

There's always been the theory that Key was going to get the hell out of here too - as early as next term or soon after 2014.

Like Power, Key probably doesn't want to be an old, broken-down and bitter man when there's quite a lot else there he's capable of.

But Power always loomed as a possible successor. He had the goods to be PM - or a deputy-come-Finance Minister.

Now the pecking order is shaken up. There's future leader and deputy leader roles up for grabs and the hopefuls will be jockeying even harder for position.

So who's left pounding the street?

Bill English: If you thought Power was on a marathon run, this guy is on the ultra-marathon. He'll jog past Power now, and probably won't look back. He could do New Zealand's version of John Howard and become PM in 2020 such is his determination. But maybe the public are tired of watching him do loops.

Gerry Brownlee: Gezza's a stayer too. He had an absolute 'mare with the mining but is back on track and comes across well with the punters. Has Deputy PM stamped on, but it all depends how this shakes down.

Steven Joyce: New to the race. That helps. Key's mate. That helps even more. Background: his background’s a bit like Key - that helps too. Everyone says this guy is a future Finance Minister. Why not Prime Minister? He's got everything else he's wanted so far in politics.

Judith Collins: Crusher is the highest-ranking woman. She takes no prisoners. That will extend to her fellow front-bench colleagues in a leadership race where she would rate herself as at least a deputy leader.

Tony Ryall: Smooth operator. Stayer. No matter how much he harps on about loving Health and it's the best portfolio ever - he would love the Finance role in some future shake-up. Best bet is with his brat-pack mate Bill English but he could slip into it some other way.

So good on you Power - you've created some intrigue.

Then there's Power's prized justice portfolio - and the struggle for direction there.

Of course Crusher may be keen on grabbing the Justice role. We all know Power hated "three strikes" and brought it in under duress because it rated highly in National's polling.

Power was a National Party "liberal" in the tradition of Ralph Hanan, the 1960s Justice Minister who crossed the floor to vote against the death penalty for murder.

Crusher is on the other side of that debate - she ended up fronting "three strikes".

So that'll be a change. Unless of course justice goes to Chris Finlayson - a legalistic liberal more akin to Power.

That liberal/conservative divide continues into the caucus and wider National Party.

Power was a consensus MMP man - not everyone liked that.

It’s a shock, and a lot of people are wondering why.

But let’s get it straight here: Simon Power didn't want to "do a Goff".

Goff's still battling away despite having had some great years as a minister.

Like Goff, Power came in young. Sure he may have been leader one day - but the timing may have been wrong.

Why wait all your life for something that may never happen.

Power achieved a fair bit. But I wonder if he could ever really fix up the justice system the way he would like to. Head and brick wall stuff. Costs money, which National won't do, and is liberal, which the National backbench doesn't like.

It’s no secret I respect Power. He was the first politician I ever got to know when he was opposition Corrections spokesman and I was a police reporter looking for stories to get me though the summer season. I wrote this column after National took power, exposing his liberal instincts.

He's an honest fulla - and I rate that.

So Power's gone out on top: he's done what I call a "political Susan Devoy".

The corporate world awaits this machine. Any bets on Simon Power, Fonterra CEO?

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

18 Mar 2011 05:16p.m.

Christina wrote:

In my opinion ,Simon Power could envisage a long period of recession,so much money going towards helping people,with him unable to have any elbow room to briskly achieve reforms and selling off state assets, but mostly his dislike of having to consult the Maori Party each step of the way.So he opted out!

14 Mar 2011 04:52p.m.

Watch and wait wrote:

Has it not occurred to you media types that Power is jumping before the full facts surrounding the demise of Allan Hubbard's finance investments become public knowledge? He is the fall guy for poor decisions made by the government, in advance!

08 Mar 2011 09:04p.m.

Jeff wrote:

Oh dear, what a depressing bunch of leaders-in-waiting. Power at least (despite his removal of many of our legal rights - like trial by jury, the ability of prisoners to vote, and so on) was competent and hardworking, with respect from across political boundaries. The alternatives don't measure up - lots of sound and fury, but signifying nothing.

02 Mar 2011 06:32p.m.

Craig wrote:

Brownlee and Collins are too socially conservative for liberal Nats and voters, and wouldn't perform well against a revitalised Labour Party if or when Andrew Little takes over if Labour loses the forthcoming election. Interesting to compare it to Labour, which has a wealth of newcomer talent mixed with old hands. Key seems to carry the rest of his party, with the exception of Paula Bennett

02 Mar 2011 06:07p.m.

dave wrote:

Maybe power is just going to head out for the next term and come back in for Labour. They need a leader after all and power might just be sick of having to deal with hard nosed conservatives seems it says he is somewhat liberal.

02 Mar 2011 03:50p.m.

James J Read wrote:

So some think National could have a Leader in Waiting, in Crusher Collins. I don't think I am alone in being disappointed in Crusher, words aren't matched by actions. So far as I'm aware, despite her bluff and bluster, no boy racer's car has been crushed yet and her explaination wouldn't fool a 10 year old.

02 Mar 2011 02:06p.m.

Long-Time Observer wrote:

The other contenders make Power look pretty good. Brownlee has demonstrated an obvious contempt for democracy and accountability. Arrogant to a fault. Joyce is in the pocket of several large corporates with vested interests that may not coincide with the national interest. The "Minister for Infratil" is on a mission and isn't to be PM. Collins is one to watch. Doesn't appear to listen unless she absolutely has to. Not endearing. Mr. Ryall is the ultimate party hack. If you don't like party hacks, then you won't like Mr. Ryall.

Patrick Gower's Entries

Finance Minister Bill English delivers the 2012 Budget (Photo: Jared Mason)

OPINION: English taxes the smokers but leaves the boozers

The path to that wafer-thin surplus in 2014/15 will be paved by taxing the life out of smokers.

Comments (5)

Key is looking quite up-for-it and motivated at the moment - I've heard him say on a number of occasions recently that he wants to "get stuff done" (pic: file/Victoria Evans)

Key still holds all the cards

The typewriters have been telling their interviewers that all the sideshows are wearing the PM down - in my experience, the typewriter is often wrong.

Comments (13)

John Key has been telling everyone how much he likes the local nasi goreng

Key's love of nasi goreng shows why he likes Crafar sale

John Key wolfs down a big feed of nasi goreng – and washes it down with some Southland sheep milk.

Comments (17)

McCully hacker now says he's Kiwi

The McCully hacker, self-described Russian 'Yuri Petrov', is now claiming he's just a normal old Kiwi bloke.

Comments (1)

Who is the Russian who hacked McCully's emails?

So who is the McCully hacker?

What I can say is about how I came into contact with the hacker - it was through Twitter.

Comments (2)

"Key and Joyce are sick of people who say 'you can't' when it comes to projects that generate economic growth."

SkyCity pokies deal should be a conscience vote

The odds against a conscience vote are the same as those against someone beating a pokie machine - the machine always wins.

Comments (16)

Gower: David Shearer had a shocker with his response on the ‘Nick Smith political favours scandal’.

Shearer's shocker on Nick Smith scandal

It has to be said: David Shearer had a shocker with his response on the ‘Nick Smith political favours scandal’.

Comments (13)

Lesley Longstone

Sex offender teacher: Bureaucratic heads must roll

Public sector heads must roll, argues 3 News political reporter Patrick Gower.

Comments (9)

Politics 2011 was "bloody exciting"

Patrick Gower's bloody exciting end of year blog

Politics bores the hell out of most punters, says Patrick Gower, so he'll sum it up for you in a few short words.

Comments (3)

Phil Goff and Winston Peters

Goff should rule out Winston – right now

Peters has left Goff stranded up the aisle. Shame! Goff should have ditched Peters first – and long ago.

Comments (12)

Don Brash says marijuana should be decriminalised

Banks will roll Brash as ACT leader, it's inevitable - blog

It seems inevitable John Banks will take out Don Brash as the leader of the ACT party.

Comments (13)

Key says without the urgent law change, "criminals will walk free" - this is essentially blackmail

Labour must harden up and reject police spy-video law change

Goff needs to look in the mirror and say to himself: I am not going to cave into the petty politics of John Key on this one.

Comments (15)

Peter Dunne called his spin-doctors into action after reading one of Patrick's blogs

‘I’m not dirty!’ – Dunne. ‘Yes you are!’ - Gower

Peter Dunne's spin brigade has tried on a full-frontal filthy denial of his dirty deal in Ohariu with John Key/National.

Comments (19)

Electorate deals are dirtier than AC/DC after a particularly long and sweaty tour

Dirty electorate political deals, done dirt cheap - blog

It's election year - there are dirty deals all over the shop and they are taking genuine choice away from voters.

Comments (21)

ACT voters might be wondering if getting rid of Hide was such a good idea

The ACT Party looks pretty much stuffed

The rebranded ACT Party looks like a couple of old blokes on life support.

Comments (30)

Key badly wants a piece of what's going on in India

Key turns pirate-hunter to nab Indian deal

John Key the deal-maker has thrown the possibility of a NZ warship chasing Somali pirates into the mix of the India Free Trade deal.

Comments (11)

Bishop Brian Tamaki

Destiny Church and politics: All about money and votes - blog

All I could think when I saw the Maori politicians getting blessed by Brian Tamaki was "who is using who here"?

Comments (26)

IRB Chief Executive Mike Miller is just too chummy with Frank Bainimarama's regime

Old Farts at IRB have lost the plot over Fiji

Here's a question for International Rugby Board - what part of "Military Dictatorship" don't you understand?

Comments (39)

Patrick Gower is a 3 News Political Reporter based in Wellington.

Here he offers his commentary on New Zealand politics from his front-row seat in the Press Gallery.

He has been a journalist for ten years, going as far as Afghanistan to get his stories, and was previously a political and investigative reporter for the New Zealand Herald

Subscribe to this blog by email