• Full Story

Progress on race relations but inequalities high

Print

Fri, 11 Mar 2011 6:13a.m.

Last year's `three strikes' legislation and the removal of prisoners' right to vote are in breach of human rights and will impact disproportionately on Maori, the Human Rights Commission says.

In its annual Review of Race Relations in New Zealand, the commission also said social and economic inequalities remained unacceptably high in New Zealand despite progress in relationships between the country's diverse ethnic groups.

"An unrelenting focus on the elimination of racial inequalities is needed, to ensure future generations of New Zealanders are free from this blight," Race Relations Commissioner Joris de Bres said at the launch of the report in Auckland.

"It is also time to examine whether there are still systemic or institutional barriers to racial equality that need to be addressed to make other interventions more effective," Mr de Bres said.

Positives in New Zealand's race relations included the growth of te reo Maori and the Maori economy, Parliament reflecting the cultural diversity of the country, and the settling of historical claims for breaches of the Treaty of Waitangi.

However, the Government would have to acknowledge that entrenched racial inequalities in health, education, employment, justice and housing continued to be a blot on New Zealand's otherwise positive record, Mr de Bres said.

"They impact most of all on New Zealand's children and young people."

The report noted that last year's introduction of the `three strikes' legislation in sentencing and the removal of prisoners' right to vote went against basic human rights principles and would impact disproportionately on Maori.

"This is of great concern, particularly since Parliament passed the legislation in both cases despite advice to the contrary from the Attorney-General."

Attorney-General Chris Finlayson told Parliament that the three-strikes legislation was "inconsistent with the right against disproportionately severe treatment", would result in "disparities between offenders that are not rationally based", and might result in "gross disproportionality in sentencing".

Also, with the removal of prisoners' right to vote, both provisions were likely to have a disproportionate effect on Maori because of their rate of conviction and imprisonment.

The report also highlighted 10 priority areas for the year.

Among them were:

  • Protecting children who are vulnerable to abuse from harm and ensuring that all children equally enjoy the right to education, good health, housing and freedom from poverty;
  • Identifying and working to remove any structural or institutional barriers to racial equality in the enjoyment of civil, political, social and economic rights:
  • Reducing the high rate of unemployment of Maori and Pacific people, and particularly of young people;
  • Reducing the number of people in our prisons and the disproportionate number of them who are Maori; and
  • Making better provision for Maori representation in local government in this year's representation reviews.

NZPA

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

18 Mar 2011 06:42a.m.

Mike B wrote:

Hi Brent
How exactly am I a criminal I did not steal any land, I was born into a poor family in NZ and have worked for everything I have. I do not commit crimes because I was born poor I don’t expect extra help because I was born poor why should it be any different for Maori.
Maori Tribes invaded other tribes all the time and stole their land even after the treaty, is it a different story when the person taking your land is brown? The Crown permitted and in some cases supported the confiscation of land not the current citizens of NZ why should we pay the penalties.
What have the Royal family or the British government paid towards settlement considering they were the main parties in the agreement.

16 Mar 2011 12:30p.m.

Brent wrote:

A debate on race relations wouldn't be complete without it being pointed out that "Maori commit more crime". However no one ever wants to talk about colonization which was effectively the largest armed robbery ever to take place in this country. We as the criminals owe Tainui every dollar made from agriculture carried out on land stolen from them. And that's billions and billions. And that's just for Tainui. I imagine if fair reparations were made Maori would have a lot less need/desire to commit crime.

12 Mar 2011 08:02a.m.

Mike B wrote:

Hi Judy
I won’t follow your lead and insult you because you have a different opinion to me but it would be nice to know exactly what you think was racist about my comments.

11 Mar 2011 07:35p.m.

Judy Sainsbury wrote:

Joris de Bres is right, of course, and the comments above prove it. What a pathetic, racist, snivelling society we are!!!!!

11 Mar 2011 04:14p.m.

Mike B wrote:

Hey Hemi how about all the Maori targeted health programs, education grants, whanau Ora, cheaper doctor fees for areas with a high density of Maori, lower standards to get into Uni, community and Marai based programs funded by the taxpayer.
And instead of waiting to be given something how about you get off you’re a#ss and do something for yourself!

11 Mar 2011 03:54p.m.

Ruz wrote:

@Alex. The implication is that Maori commit crime because they are disadvantaged and have no other choice. I reject that.

11 Mar 2011 01:20p.m.

Hemi wrote:

This government and the previous have given the Maori nothing to help us in our struggle we have nothing.

11 Mar 2011 12:18p.m.

Bobby wrote:

Being maori isn't a culture anymore it's a lifestyle. There are some pretty fair skinned maori's around crying that the have some how been repressed.

People have to be held responsible for their actions. If someone has committed a crime and are in jail they should be treated harshly, including loosing the right to vote. After all their victim is often left worse of than the criminal.

11 Mar 2011 12:07p.m.

Bart wrote:

don't do the crime then you won't do the time and loose your civil liberties. prison is suppose to be a punishment, not a holiday camp. if maori are over represented in these statistics maybe it's time they learn to live within the rules that the rest of us seem to be able to abide by. become productive members of society instead of a drain on it. maori are already afforded many more opportunities then any other racial group so it's time they stop crying about been mistreated

11 Mar 2011 10:33a.m.

Mike B wrote:

Inequalities suggest that Maori have not been given opportunities that the state has given to others when the opposite is true.
More money is spent on Maori health and education than any other race and yet they still lag behind, perhaps it is time to admit that the problem lies with Maori culture and not NZ culture.
You cannot help people who refuse to help themselves.