3News » Home

Religion won't help kids with diversity, fluidity might

Teaching primary school children about world religions was on the agenda this week Teaching primary school children about world religions was on the agenda this week
Tue, 16 Mar 2010 3:18p.m.

A Victoria University academic believes teaching primary school children about the world's main religions will promote understanding and tolerance, and prepare kids for an increasingly diverse 21st century.

Has anyone else spotted the irony?

Religion is responsible for most of the world's most impacting misunderstandings and intolerant behaviour. It promotes conformity, not diversity.

They say religion is the opiate of the masses and, like drugs, people often spend money on religion they cannot afford. It causes delusional beliefs and, at times, makes people talk utter nonsense. 

Groups lock themselves in dark places for many hours, then go out and try to convince others it's what they need to be happy. Religion causes violence and sometimes even provokes suicide and murder.

So, why do we want children to know more about it?

If we want children to know more about understanding, tolerance and diversity, teach them that, for God's sake. Actually, do it for their sake, for our sake.

Teach them that diversity is about uniqueness and commonality, similarity and difference. Diversity is not about what we believe, it's about how to believe, especially when we don't agree with others, or they disagree with us.

Diversity is not about age, gender, sexuality, religion, culture, disability, marital status, etc. That's categorisation and representation.

Diversity is about self-awareness, communication, inquiry, exploration. It's about certainty and confusion, knowing and not knowing. It's about recognising fear and meeting it, head on, with love and peace. 

Where religion promotes fear and doctrine, diversity promotes realisation, wisdom and fluidity. 

I experienced a powerful example of how fluidity is becoming more of a social imperative at a recent forum run by Rainbow Youth. Several of the young people speaking were transsexual, having either transitioned from living as a young man to a young woman, or vice versa.

When I was 19 I came out as gay and that was difficult enough. I'm still recovering. These 20-somethings had already come out as bi, then lesbian, then male and are now often mistaken as being gay when they are actually straight.

Confused? That's fluidity for you.

What saddened me was that, in a world of Boy Georges and Ellens, Melissa Etheridges, Elton Johns and Ru Pauls, it's still not safe to come out as transsexual. You may not know that the guy you work with used to be a girl, because in our "modern" society, people are still threatened with isolation, hatred and violence if they do not conform to a binary notion of gender.

And that's not just in the straight world, either. Gender intolerance exists in the gay world as well and the panel believed the change needs to be led by the gay community. I agree.

If you think we live in enlightened times, you're right. But you're wrong.

We are close and yet so far. And believe me, a better understanding of religion is not going to help.

 

Until 2008 Philip Patston identified as gay, disabled and vegetarian. These days he prefers to think of himself as having a unique experience. A social entrepreneur and change consultant, with fifteen years’ experience as an award-winning professional comedian, he aims to promote a new, more useful understanding of diversity. He runs Diversity New Zealand in his spare time (www.diversitynz.com).

 

You can keep in touch with Philip Patston via his social media sites:

 

facebook.com/philippatston

 

twitter.com/philippatston

 

Please vote for this blog in the NetGuide Web Awards.

Philip Patston's Entries

Comments [22]

Sam
2/02/2011 7:33:27 p.m.

I agree that religion is humanity's hangover from our pre-scientific past when we knew nothing and were afraid of everything. But, I think we absolutely SHOULD teach about the world's religions in primary school. How better can we make kids realize that it's just an accident of history and birth that they happen to worship a jewish zombie instead of a sacred cow? Or that it's a good idea to consume bread and wine, pretending they're consuming said zombie's flesh and blood, but a nonsensical idea to perform a funny dance to make it rain?

Preacher
26/07/2010 10:22:24 p.m.

Totally agree, religion should have no place in schools. For one think, secular education cannot and does not understand the truth on one world belief. A good example is Islam; its ok kiddies, says the teacher, its really a peaceful belief in a God called Allah who taught his people through the Prophet Mohammad... I wonder how many schools teach the little kiddies that Mohammad married one of his wives when she was 6 years old and took her virginity when she was 9? We have a special word for that in society today. As for Christianity, it is not a religion. Christianism that the majority of the worlds 'denominations' teach is. "God loves you, but he's going to knock you in the head if you don't follow the rules and straighten up you no good little sinner" And people wonder where intolerance and condemnation come from??? Whats worse is the true Christians get the blame for something we don't even preach! God don't care if your Gay, Straight, or into Pink Elephants. He sent Jesus to the cross and laid on him all the punishment Hell could offer for 3 days so everyone could be saved because we all stuffed up. The only thing keeping a man from going to hell now is his stubborn refusal to accept what Jesus did for him because God ain't going to force it on you. Leave religion out of schools, but at least acknowledge that some of us have a different interpretation of your 'evidence'.

Luke
26/03/2010 12:16:26 p.m.

Believing in Ghosts is a religion... Is it?

Niamh
22/03/2010 11:28:14 p.m.

Atheism is as much a religon as not collecting stamps can be called a hobby.

Bizo
22/03/2010 5:22:05 p.m.

Religion promotes fear, Philip? I think that statement is totally misguided. That is a biased, unfounded, statement coming from someone who seems to have a score to settle with religion. Religion is not based on fear: take Christianity, for example, it is based on love, mercy and grace, knowing we are imperfect but can be made perfect through God's love - how is that based on fear?

P.J.
18/03/2010 2:50:01 a.m.

Corban, would this 'Nazi secularism' of which you speak be the same one that introduced compulsory prayer for children, was supported in it's enabling law by the Catholic 'Center Party' (headed by Ludwig Kaas, a Catholic priest)? Which signed a Concordat with Rome and marched it's troops into battle wearing 'Gott Mit Uns' belt buckles, instituted an official prayer that began 'Führer, mein Führer, von Gott mir gegeben' (Leader, my Leader, given to me by God)? Whose leader frequently referenced religious ideas and who persued infamously vicious persecution against certain other religious groups?

I would suggest you need to brush up on your C20 European history (or your definition of 'Secular').

Philip
17/03/2010 7:48:04 a.m.

Thanks for the comments folks. Obviously I'm taking an extreme viewpoint for dramatic and comic effect. I wouldn't condemn teaching about religion outright. But my main point is the connection made by the academic with diversity – that I do have a problem with. If you want to see a very poignant analysis of religion, I recommend the movie Zeitgeist at www.zeitgeistmovie.com You can see an interview with the film's director Peter Joseph on my blog http://wp.me/poylQ-Py

Frankie D.
17/03/2010 5:17:22 a.m.

Teach all religions and teach that they're all wrong!

Teach that they came about as a way of trying to understand that which we couldn't at the time and as a way of controlling people.

@Richard - By definition, Atheism is not a religion and morality is not owned by religion, in fact it is only through religion that good people can do evil acts...

TheGlovner
17/03/2010 2:53:35 a.m.

"Atheism is another religion."

Arrrggghh!!!! How many times?!

No atheism is not another religion.

A religion is a belief structure or an ideology. It has a god figure at its head, but overall it is a dogmatic rule over its followers supported by the application of fear as a device to control.

Atheism is not a belief structure, it is nothing more than a lack of belief in any deities. End of story.

Most of the argument about the definition of atheism comes from the religious not the atheist. You will find that most atheists will agree that all the term encompasses is a lack of belief in a god of any kind.

It does not tell you how to act, it does not imply what you should think, it does not indoctrinate the people that fall into this group into acting in a specific way.

It is not, I repeat, NOT another religion.

The only reason there is a need for the word "atheism" and its varients is because of the unfair status given to religions that they can be treated as factual without bothering to provide any facts to support themselves. If it wasn't for this unfair treatment there would be no need for the term atheist as it is just the natural state of a human (or any animal) before any indoctrination into a belief structure can be applied.

If the special status of religion was taken away there would be as much requirment for the term atheism as there would be for a word to describe people that didn't believe in fairies, dragons, magic, goblins or any other supernatural thing you care to mention.

Once more to clarify, atheism is not a religion no matter what you might like to believe.

GSW
17/03/2010 2:03:02 a.m.

@richard: Do you really think he (&we) haven't heard all this before? If you don't worship a god you must be religious because not worshipping a god is a religion etc... ... and your "fears of the faith" comment sounds a little too like the claims of islamaphobia to me. However, I as an atheist, will admit that I do not wish to see any religion gain sufficient power that I need be afraid of it. Fortunately, here in the west, your faith is no longer legally permitted to burn witches, torture heretics or hang blasphemers and homosexuals (although this is still done in theocracies). Please, do not try to persuade us that your religion is all love and light because it isn't. You STILL have women forced who have been raped forced to give birth at risk of their own lives. You STILL have persecution of homosexuals. You STILL talk of sex between consenting adults as though it was something disgusting, while your own priests are raping small children - which IS disgusting. Hypocrisy is rife in the worlds religions and misogony predominant. NO THANK YOU.

Post a comment

Name:
Email: (Won't be published)
Comment:


3News Video 3News Audio