3News » Home
Full Story

Review: Hands free phone kits for driving within the law

10 comments | Post Comment email Email printer friendly Print    Text Size:
aA
aA
aA
From November it will be illegal to use a mobile phone in your car

From November it will be illegal to use a mobile phone in your car

video
Tue, 20 Oct 2009 9:26a.m.
By Emma Brannam
 
From November 1st it will be against the law to handle or manipulate a mobile phone while driving and doing so will earn you an $80 dollar fine and 20 demerit points.
 
Basically, that means no fiddling with the phone on your lap or sending or reading text messages. The phone either needs to be mounted in a secure cradle on a dashboard or similar or you have to get a hands-free kit. (The old ones which plugged into the phone but still meant you had to dial the number manually will no longer cut the mustard).
 
But don't fear - there's plenty of Bluetooth handsfree kits to choose from (no more dangling wires) and I've tested some of the latest and most popular. For some reason during the gadget review, the devices got studio-fright and refused to work (some say it's the phone reception in the studio, I say it's Oliver) but in road tests they all performed!
 
PARROT MINIKIT SLIM - $229
 
This Bluetooth device is slim, attractive and easy to use and attaches to the car's sun visor with a little clip. Uploading your phone book onto the device is a doddle - mine did it automatically - and then it's ready for action. The device announces who in your contact list is calling you and a quick jab of the green button connects you. To make a call, jab the green button and say the name. There's also a dial to manually browse through the contact list (although the latter is illegal if you're driving as it requires too much fiddling).
 
Advantages: Simple to set up, simple to use. The call quality is great as the whole device acts as a speaker. I didn't notice any interference or call drop-out during testing. You can also log onto the Parrot website and update the car-kit regularly and for free using the software update tool. Talk time is up to 20 hours and it comes with a charger that plugs into the car cigarette lighter socket.
 
Disadvantages: You might have to learn a bit of "Parrot" to make it work and sometimes if thinks it's made a match it goes ahead and dials without asking which then requires frantic stabbing at the sun visor to switch it off and a bit of cursing (at least on my part). That said, you can solve the problem by recording new voice tags if there are names it doesn't recognise.
 
BLUEANT V1 HEADSET - $189
 
The BlueAnt V1 Headset is the world's first fully voice controlled Bluetooth headset . The little device fits snugly over the ear and unlike other headsets that only support voice dial capabilities through a mobile phone's voice features, the V1's voice control is embedded in the headset itself. That means the user can control all headset features such as pairing, volume and connection status using only their voice.
 
Advantages: It's like having a little man in your ear and if you're not sure what you're doing you can ask for help and it tells you the options. You can also jump in and out of any car and it still works.
 
Disadvantages: It didn't understand my British accent properly and I had to say "answer" with an American twang! Plus wearing a headset can make you feel a little silly if you forget to take it off!
 
BLUEANT SUPERTOOTH 3 - $229
 
The unit's text-to-speech capability works well. For incoming calls, the Supertooth uses caller ID and your phone's address book to read out the name of the person calling. You can also give instructions by saying things like "answer" or "okay" or "call Emma". There are several different languages to choose from - you can even practice your Spanish while you drive!
 
Advantages: It's reasonably straightforward to use and its voice answering system is great because you don't have to touch the device. BlueAnt also have a helpline which is good if you're having trouble uploading contacts or figuring out how it all works. Talk time is about 20 hours which is good and charges through cigarette lighter. It can connect to eight mobiles but it's first come first served if everyone jumps into the car at once.
 
Disadvantages: Sound quality was ok - not great and the voice is slightly robotic - making it sound like Stephen Hawking is trapped inside the device. I also noticed occasional interference when testing it out on the road. Also for phones that don't have the capability to transfer the whole address book over automatically, it was a little fiddly having to select them all.
 
LG SOLAR POWERED HFB-510 - $229 approx
 
The windshield of your car is one such place that gets basically endless sunlight and LG have taken advantage of this with their solar-charging HFB-501 Bluetooth hands-free kit which comes with a transparent suction-cup holder to stick it onto the windscreen. The speaker is nice and loud and clear and it also has name alert and voice recognition features. It's just out in New Zealand so price is approximate.
 
Advantages: It's solar powered. No need to worry about charging it! It can also be turned into a charger a LG or Nokia phone so fantastic when the mobile runs out of juice. Good hit rate with the voice dialling feature and nice and clear.
 
Disadvantages: It's not so great in areas which don't get much sun and when taking it off the visor you can accidently knock the side of it triggering commands unintentionally.

And for the truly flash...how about a hardwired hands free kit
 
PARROT MKI9200 CAR KIT - $599.00 plus approx $200 to install
 
The MKi system combines the latest communication technologies with a full set of services dedicated to music. Once paired with your Bluetooth mobile phone, the MKi enables you to establish in a few seconds any phone conversations in your vehicle without needing to handle the telephone.
 
And all the connectors for any type of music are provided with each MKi hands-free kit: iPod, iPhone, iTouch, USB keys, USB MP3 players, Bluetooth Stereo devices, CD players, MiniDisc.
 
Advantages: It looks flash, lets you play your music at the same and the sound quality is great.
 
Disadvantages: It's a tad expensive once you take into account installation costs which have to be done by an approved car dealer or installer and if you swap cars you can't take it with you.
Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Comments [10]

John Bannerman Gollop
24 Oct 2009 7:05a.m.

As a campaigning green environmentalist wanting safety on our living streets, steps like these in empowered legislation are welcome, and will embed good behaviour over time. Emma has a rapport and empathy with inventions and it is good to see a glamour girl having a great brain and doing science for a change. This is new territory for TV women. Gromit 2 X

Andy
21 Oct 2009 2:24p.m.

The BlueAnt V1 has UK and AU English available as a download. It picks up my kiwi accent fine.

Don
20 Oct 2009 9:14p.m.

Turn the phone off when driving - that works only if you don't drive all day or take very few calls.
When you spend a 5 or 6 hours a day on the road, much of it on motorways were you can't just pull over to take a call the phone and hands free become a necessity not a toy. When your work place is your car, juggling, cancelling and adding appointments or answering urgent questions from the office etc are often not things that can wait an hour or two for a call stop.
Regardless of the law, if you ever take calls without a good hands free system you deserve a swift kick before you kill yourself and/or someone else. I have a built in factory blue tooth hands free in my car and also use the Parrot slim when I need to use other cars. It is easy to operate, works very well and can even be put on a table and used for conference calling if necessary.

Jan..
20 Oct 2009 8:39p.m.

No Mark I say, stop somewhere safe, even if you are on the motorway, we do have rest area where you can turn off safely and cancelled your appointment..Common sense Mark..


col
20 Oct 2009 5:20p.m.

in my line of work i have tried many types of hands free car kits.My research lead me to a brand called IO-PLAY made in the UK with a link to INVICTA COMMUNICATIONS NZ who are the factory authorized Aust & nz agents The installation are so easy ,all plug and play,no cutting of cables,on any vehicles,and YES!! voiding your cars warranty!!!! and the radio is muted and the cellphone audio it comes out of your car speakers,no small speaker mounted so you cant hear the voice from your call By the way ,if you pick up your cell phone,even in stopped traffic, it is no excuse,you will get caught!! My advice,have a good look at IO-PLAY. Installs $120.00 per car,my boss is pleased ,and so is the CEO

Debbie
20 Oct 2009 1:52p.m.

I have a blue ant hands free device in my car, only problem is at night time there is a blue flashing light, barely visible during the day, but like a strobe light at night time. Simple solutions a piece of black electrical tape. However now I have to guess when the darn thing is in need of charging!!

Dan
20 Oct 2009 11:53a.m.

Yes the sensible thing would be to pull over and complete the comversation or turn off the mobile phone. There can be no excuse from 01NOV09.

Mark
20 Oct 2009 11:36a.m.

@Den - are you for real? So...just pull over on the motorway? A lot of people rely on their phones these days.....unless you happen to be unemployed....

Jan..
20 Oct 2009 11:03a.m.

Excellent work, save lives, save money, you are a genies..no excuses just get there in plenty of times for your appointments and if delayed in anyway stop somewhere safe and cancelled your apointments..common sense folks!..

Den
20 Oct 2009 10:23a.m.

Why waste money, just pull over and make the call any way. or turn your phone off while driving, or are you one of these people that can't do without your cell phone being on......

Post a comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide here
Name:
Email: (Won't be published)
Comment:



3News Video 3News Audio

Post your opinion

3News - Was the force used at the Dotcom mansion excessive?
On January 20th, two helicopters and 76 police officers arrived a
Comments (175)