Seal bashing shows 'animals don't matter'

Print

Wed, 30 Nov 2011 7:50a.m.

Jason Godsiff

Jason Godsiff

The quashing of the jail sentence for a man who bashed about two dozen seals to death sends the message that animals do not matter, SPCA says.

Jason Trevor Godsiff, 20, from Renwick near Blenheim, had his two-year jail sentence reduced to eight months' home detention on appeal, the Marlborough Express reported.

The bodies of 25 bashed seals, some of them pups, were discovered in November last year at the Ohau Point seal colony near Kaikoura.

Godsiff admitted bashing them with a galvanised metal pole.

High Court judge Jillian Mallon quashed the two-year prison sentence because the original sentencing judge had not given enough credit for his youth, good character and remorse and guilty plea.

SPCA chief executive Robyn Kippenberger said the reduced sentence was "hugely disappointing".

"Anybody that can brutally kill animals like that with such disregard for their suffering, there are a lot of question marks around that person," she told NZ Newswire.

There were well-known links between cruelty to animals and violence against humans, she said.

Last year's incident was a wanton attack in which the seals had been bashed and left to die, she said.

The court's decision sent the message that "animals do not matter".

However, it could turn out that his community would judge him, she said.

"That community can say that's not OK, that's what's being done with child abuse, people are no longer turning a blind eye to it."

NZN

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

12 Dec 2011 11:21a.m.

bita wrote:

He will be back on the news, wait and see! Next time for bashing someone’s son, daughter, husband, father….these type of criminals will only start with animals! And then, those who let him get away with such small term, will be sorry they did not teach him a more serious and memorable lesson! Shame.

05 Dec 2011 09:25p.m.

Pippa's Mum wrote:

Inflict the same injury on him as what he did and see how he likes it. It doesn't get my seal of approval. Absolutely disgusting decision and may he be haunted by his actions for the rest of his life!

02 Dec 2011 11:37p.m.

anonymous wrote:

this is outrageous what he did was terrible to those poor seals. i do not think he should be let off lightly @ all

02 Dec 2011 05:30p.m.

Andrena wrote:


This judge is a disgrace to New Zealand. This low life is a disgrace to civilisation. There is a very old saying, "Do unto others as you would have them do unto you". A seal is unable to take a club to a human but I would be willing to start for them. If 23 blows were given to him with a steel rod for every seal he killed we would be close to fair punishment. Renwick is a small town in one of the most beautiful parts of New Zealand. Shame it is now tarnished with this scum. As others have said, Remember this name Judge Mallon. I am sure you will see this scum before the courts again. It wasn't one seal he clubbed to death, it was 23. Do you not hear their cries of pain as he slowly beat every one to death and the agony of those that didn't die there and then but were left to die a slow agonising death. You are a disgrace to the NZ judicial system. Medals are considered worthy of a three year sentence for their theft, killing 23 seals is 8 months home on holiday. You shouldn't be in front of the courts and this scum should be in prison.

01 Dec 2011 10:07p.m.

Simon wrote:

I really do not understand NZ'ers. People get similar punishments when they kill another person: you know, when they go out in groups and beat the shit out of someone random for "fun" and "don't realise" jumping on their head, face and chest is dangerous. Where is all the support for these people's families? Do not get me wrong, the seal bashing is awful, but seriously, take the seals and give me back my brother in law.

30 Nov 2011 09:22p.m.

Laurie wrote:

Where was his so called good character when he was carrying out the attack?

30 Nov 2011 08:09p.m.

Alex wrote:

Anyone capable of killing 23 protected animals in New Zealand has to be pretty sick and evil. It's inevitable he'll do it to something (or someone) else in the future without the right correctional punishment. I don't see how prison will help him, but it's a big step up from home detention - reduced to less than half of the original sentence.

30 Nov 2011 06:59p.m.

Ashamed to be Human wrote:

SHAME SHAME SHAME..
This kind of thing makes me soo ashamed to be human

30 Nov 2011 06:14p.m.

jim wrote:

Hey Danny if we all destroyed what we perceive to be pests guys like you would not survive for long !!!!!!!!!!!!

30 Nov 2011 05:49p.m.

Danny wrote:

people tend to kill off seals because they feed on the fish, so typically the people who are running small business' with private fishing boats are losing on their own livelihood. i am obviously not as sensitive about animal cruelty as others but to these people the animals are a pest, just like blowing up rabbits on your farm, or more simply stepping on a spider when it runs towards you! haha, i wouldnt like to see a young lad doing prison time for this, chances are is wasnt his idea