3News » Home
Full Story

Shot cop saw no need for firearm in Linwood incident

6 comments | Post Comment email Email printer friendly Print    Text Size:
aA
aA
aA
Christopher Graeme Smith was charged with attempted murder of the officers and murdering police dog Gage (NZPA)

Christopher Graeme Smith was charged with attempted murder of the officers and murdering police dog Gage (NZPA)

video
Wed, 14 Jul 2010 6:00p.m.
By Juanita Copeland and NZPA

The police dog handler shot in the jaw in Christchurch yesterday is deeply upset about the loss of his dog Gage, but does not think it would have made a difference if he had been armed at the time of the incident.

Police today also revealed that a Taser stun gun was used by police in the incident, but without success.

The dog handler, Senior Constable Bruce Lamb, and Constable Mitchel Alatalo were both wounded in the shooting in suburban Phillipstown yesterday morning.

Canterbury police district commander Superintendent Dave Cliff told a press conference Mr Lamb, who was shot in the face, was grateful for the outpouring of support for him and his family, and wished to thank the public for the cards and flowers.

Mr Lamb was in a lot of pain, but was now out of intensive care after surgery last night, Mr Cliff said.

A bullet had shattered his jaw before exiting out the side of his face.

Mr Alatalo, who was shot in a leg, was recovering well, Mr Cliff said.

Gage died quickly and was a sad loss to Mr Lamb and his family, Mr Cliff said.

Should New Zealand police be armed? Campbell Live talks to Police Minister Judith Collins

Attempted murder charges were laid today against a 34-year-old Christchurch man, Christopher Graeme Smith. He was remanded in custody.

Police said they had found four weapons: a .22 rifle, a .308 rifle, a shotgun, and a pig knife. No one at the Buccleugh Street house had a firearms licence.

They have their own theories about how Smith came to have a shotgun.

“We do know that firearms are routinely stolen during burglaries and that is something we can prevent if they are secured properly,” Mr Cliff said.

It was only revealed today that a third officer had retrieved a Taser from a police car outside the property. It was discharged immediately after Mr Lamb and Mr Atalato were shot, but without success.

Mr Lamb had access to a firearm in his police truck, but chose not to pick it up when he went into the house.

Mr Cliff said the officer had seen no need to use the firearm.

“Having spoken to Bruce this morning, he said he had the dog with him and just didn’t think he needed the firearm,” Mr Cliff said.

The gunman was unsuccessfully tasered by a third constable, who was uninjured.

“It is possible one probe entered the offender, but we’re still unable to confirm that,” Mr Cliff said.

The gunshot heard as Smith was apprehended, which was captured on a neighbour’s cellphone, occurred when an Armed Offenders Squad member attempted to kick the 308 out of Smith’s reach.

“The weapon was fully cocked, ready to charge and as it was kicked away, it was discharged,” Mr Cliff said.

Inspector Brendon Gibson, the national co-ordinator of police dog training, said the other dog handlers were very upset.

There was an incredible bond between the dog and the handler. Gage had lived for six years as part of Mr Lamb's family.

"Mr Lamb and Gage were a team in their prime, and this was the worst nightmare for a dog handler," he said.

Dog handlers were called out more than 25,000 times a year and dogs were retired at 7-1/2 years. He said Mr Lamb's street experience may have helped him get out alive.

He said it was up to Mr Lamb to decide what happened to Gage now.

Mr Cliff said staff at the scene should finish their investigation about midday on Thursday.

Smith, a process worker, of Phillipstown, faced six charges in Christchurch District Court in an appearance that lasted only seconds.

Defence counsel David Ruth asked Judge John Strettell for Smith to be remanded to July 28, and no bail application was made.

Smith was charged with attempting to murder Mr Lamb and Mr Alatalo.

He was also charged with intentionally killing police dog Gage without lawful authority or reasonable excuse, using a firearm against a third police officer, possession of a pig knife with intent to commit an offence, and cultivating cannabis.

No pleas were entered.

A man from the same Phillipstown address, 31-year-old unemployed Steven Paul Smith, was charged with possession of cannabis and was granted a registrar's remand to July 28, without having to appear before a judge.

3 News / NZPA

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Comments [6]

andrew
11 Nov 2011 1:49a.m.

Far out, I was at school with this guy, Chris Smith for years. To tell you the truth I just feel sorry for him, that he thought he needed guns to protect his crop, kinda makes me think it was the cops fault for not being a bit more cautious and considering the possibility that someone who grows a lot of pot might be a little bit paranoid about their said crop of dope no? most people who had lots of pot would be paranoid (and for good reason) that someone might (actually quite likely) try and rip them off... makes you think if he was allowed to grow a couple of plants for personal use (and everyone else too) then would it be wise or necessary to have weapons such as guns in your house? I think not and I'm sure he feels the same, shame on the justice system for not letting people have a small amount of personal freedom to grow a medicinal herb in their closet. I'm sure this didn't need to happen, just sad really

sam o
28 Apr 2011 11:23p.m.

Many un-educated people living with their heads in the clouds may think that the full time arming of police is unnecessary or to quote one of the above comments "ludicrous", your an idiot. If you were to call and need police assitance in a armed offender situation the first cop to arrive at the scene will have to park, get out of the car, open the boot, write down the scenario his name and then sign for it. He will then have to procced to open a safe, take out the fire arm and load it. While the officer is doing this you may have just been shot, takin hostage or he may have caused serious harm to himself. the reality is we need more armed officers! The angs and crooks are already armed and will continue to arm them selves with more and more fire arms while puttting more and more officers at risk. Protect the officers, protect the public and intimidate the gangs into submission. It's the only way, in the end yes we may have to take some casulties but overall we will be safer in our homes nd communtities.

Avery
15 Jul 2010 12:17a.m.

Exited out? Maybe the bullet just exited.

WB
14 Jul 2010 10:26p.m.

Start targeting the illegal guns & black market gun trade, don't try to match them.
They'll just get more, then the police need more and so on..
It won’t end well.

Mark Shekell
14 Jul 2010 6:52p.m.

As much as Police do a fantastic job in New Zealand fully arming Police is totally ludicrous as this country is too small for that.Just make the politicians concentrate on stopping the drugs -: P and other psychotic drugs in this beautiful country.

andrew
14 Jul 2010 6:39p.m.

Fortunately there was not a human fatality. How much do the public or government value their police officers? Apparently not enough to enable and arm them to perform their duties.

Post a comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide here
Name:
Email: (Won't be published)
Comment:



3News Video 3News Audio

Post your opinion

3News - Was the force used at the Dotcom mansion excessive?
On January 20th, two helicopters and 76 police officers arrived a
Comments (193)