3News » Home
Full Story

Somerville gets 23 years

12 comments | Post Comment email Email printer friendly Print    Text Size:
aA
aA
aA
Jason Paul Somerville

Jason Paul Somerville

video
UPDATED AT 01:23PM
Published: Fri, 29 Jan 2010 10:58a.m.

No apology and no remorse has been offered by Jason Paul Somerville for the two murders that have brought him a life sentence with a non-parole term of 23 years today.

He had admitted strangling his near neighbour Tisha Lowry and his wife Rebecca Somerville and burying their bodies beneath the floor of his house in Christchurch's Wainoni Road - an address that became known as the House of Horrors.

His acts in having sex with both the dead women were described as callous and depraved at his sentencing today in the High Court at Christchurch by Justice Lester Chisholm, the Christchurch Court News website reported.

Because he was charged only with murder, his offending did not allow an open-ended preventive detention sentence to be imposed as well as a life sentence.

But because of the life sentence and the facts of the case, he may never be released from custody by the Parole Board.

Miss Lowry's mother Tanya Lowry said outside the courthouse that it had been a very hard day for the family, and it was the end of the justice system as far as Somerville was concerned. "We just want to get our lives back as soon as possible."

The uncle of Rebecca Somerville, Peter Clifford Marsh, said the family was pleased with the sentence. "We ask that he gets the assistance he requires to carry on through life."

Somerville, who has just turned 34, killed the women about 11 months apart. He apparently strangled Miss Lowry when she came to his house and refused to leave, and he killed his wife when she refused sex.

In both cases the strangulation was followed by underwear being forced into their throats, sexual intercourse, and burial beneath the house.

Nine members of both families read out victim impact statements in court, recounting their grief and the effects of the loss of loved family members.

They spoke of love for Miss Lowry, disrupted sleep, lack of concentration, and hate of Somerville.

Jacob Lowry, the younger brother of Tisha, referred to Somerville as scum. "You don't deserve to be on this earth," he said.

Miss Lowry's sister, Leanne Hodder, said: "I hate you with so much of myself that the hate I feel has interfered with the rest of my life."

Mrs Somerville's father, Clayton Chamberlain, who lives in Australia, had a statement read out saying: "I really miss Rebecca and feel lost without her in my life."

Mrs Somerville was described as "a troubled lady", but the family said they would miss her company, her singing, and her "beautiful, giggling laugh".

One family member read out a poem Mrs Somerville had written in 2001, entitled "I am not a mistake."

Crown prosecutor Brent Stanaway described the sex as a "depraved and sickening act". Somerville clearly posed a danger to the community, and it was clear there was no remorse or empathy with the victims.

He had changed his story since talking to the police in September, when he was recently interviewed by probation and health assessors.

"He has tried to minimise his involvement, and minimise the unsavoury aspects that are likely to make him very unpopular in prison. He has very little insight into what he has done."

Defence counsel David Ruth said Somerville had a difficult start in life, with brain trauma, a head injury, and suffering sexual abuse during his teenage years. However, none of this had resulted in an identifiable mental disorder.

"Right from his early days there has been a worrying trend of strangulation being part of his response to situations that were not of his liking or stressful to him," Mr Ruth said.

Justice Chisholm said the deaths of 28-year-old Miss Lowry, and 35-year-old Mrs Somerville had been devastating for the families and had caused irreplaceable loss.

He said he found it absolutely incomprehensible that Somerville showed no remorse or empathy for the victims. The sexual aspect of the offending could offer a significant indication of future risk.

The judge allowed a three-year reduction in the sentence for Somerville's guilty pleas.

Somerville remained impassive all through the sentencing, though he sometimes frowned and looked puzzled when technical legal aspects were discussed.

NZPA

 

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Comments [12]

jarhead6353
03 Mar 2010 9:51a.m.

23 years? you people have surrendered to yourselves. any society that doesn't execute rapist/ murderers, much less serial-spree rapist murderers, deserves to be overrun by them. here in the states, we fry em, shoot em, hang em, and poison them. we call it justice. for the victims.

Rail
01 Mar 2010 9:40p.m.

This is why I like Texas, the death penalty is a wonderous thing.

Mary
30 Jan 2010 11:04a.m.

I was shock to hear what he had done but what his sentence was it was a disbelief. I cant belive 23yrs and that it.
if i was the judge i would say 3 yrs in soloduie confiment and the rest of hes remaing life in prison.
Maybe then the justice might feel like it done it job.
But i do know one thing if i was ever one of the victim family or close friend i wouldnt wont death for him as it will be a easy way out.........

Alberto
30 Jan 2010 12:04a.m.

Mate Alien you are a troll, dude this guy murdered 2 innocent women and sexually violated them, he had sexual intercourse with their dead corpses and shoved a sock in their mouth. Now 23 years is not justifiable. It doesn't matter if the murder sentencing has increased from what? 1840? This is the modern age we are not dwelling in the past, if you sexually violate someone and kill them that's a life sentence, even death in most countries, and YES as Rob stated New Zealand has a very weak justice system. Alien face the facts YOU sir are a TROLL.

Alien
29 Jan 2010 8:36p.m.

actually rob, what they call someone like me is someone who knows the facts, now can you please supply the facts to show your claim that murder rates have increased. No you cannot because the facts are that over the past 20 years the murder rate has halved. Perhaps before you try to call me a troll you answer your own claims, because to not do that and simply attack me makes you the troll. So again troll, prove it, but you can't so go learn the facts of the figures before you lie about them. And sweetie, I haven't even made a comment on how long his sentence is, simply that the it is far greater than what it used to be and that the justice system has been improving with tougher sentences. So perhaps you can focus on the issues rather than try to get personal when you cannot even produce any facts. 1985-1992: 21 murders per million people 2004-2008: 12 murders per million So again show me the raise, oh wait you can't because you ignore the facts and can never present any to back up your claims. And if you want to know how i feel about the length of the sentence, it should of been longer, but compared to past years it is pretty long. now put your big boy pants on and try to deal with facts.

rob
29 Jan 2010 5:52p.m.

You've been lied to, if you end a person's life the adequete punishment would be life, you had just ended someone's life, you know what they call people like you Alien a troll. I've seen several comments of yours on articles, you're just a troll giving negative feedback. 23 Years is NOT ENOUGH for ending someone's life LET ALONE 2 PEOPLE. The punishment for killing one person should be at least 1 with parole maybe even death, don't even get me started on 2 deaths. You live in your perfect little world Alien. Murder Rates have been going up, crime going up, hell a copper got shot, a girl stabbed over 200 times. You know nothing Alien. You're just a troll.

Alien
29 Jan 2010 4:24p.m.

weak justice system for giving 23 years? That is a lot, it used to be that life meant ten years. The justice system has been improving with tougher sentences. Rob, got any evidence of murder rates going up? Last I read murder rates in NZ were decreasing. Actually figures released last year showed that in the past 20 years the murder rate in NZ had halved.

Rob
29 Jan 2010 3:02p.m.

WDF!!! 23 years for killing 2 people!! If you kill one person in America you get life or death! OMG but 2 deaths only 23 years??? Wow New Zealand sucks no wonder murder rates are going up, people want to come to New Zealand do these crimes because they know they won't get much time. This is seriously bogus, only 23 years and you kill someone. And the government wonders why crime is increasing? Hmm I wonder eh?

Rayleen Beals
29 Jan 2010 2:26p.m.

this guy deserves to rot in prison after what he did asfor the justice system maybe the goverment need to look over it for people that do these things for what he did he deserves longer my question is what is our city comming to Im from Christchurch

Kim
29 Jan 2010 12:22p.m.

What only 23yrs for a double murder, it sickens me how weak our justice system is, it's high time to get rid off our weak judges & bring in some young no nonsence tough ones & this 3 strikes & your out is a joke esp for rape & murder, way to soft, the stupid doo gooders would'nt agree though & these people play a big part in our sick justice system,they have been heard for far too long.

Post a comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide here
Name:
Email: (Won't be published)
Comment:



3News Video 3News Audio

Post your opinion

3News - Was the force used at the Dotcom mansion excessive?
On January 20th, two helicopters and 76 police officers arrived a
Comments (148)