Surface ads misleading - lawsuit
Thu, 15 Nov 2012 12:54p.m.
By Ryan Nakashima
A California lawyer is suing Microsoft, claiming the Surface tablet he bought doesn't have all the storage space the company advertised.
Andrew Sokolowski, a lawyer in Los Angeles, claims that he bought a Surface with 32 gigabytes of storage last week. But he quickly ran out of space after loading it with music and Microsoft Word documents.
He discovered that a significant portion of the 32 GB storage space was being used by the operating system and pre-installed apps such as Word and Excel. Only 16 GB was available for him to use.
Sokolowski's lawyers filed the suit alleging false advertising and unfair business practices on Tuesday at the Superior Court in Los Angeles. They are seeking class action status.
The suit aims to change how Microsoft advertises its device and hopes to force the company to give back revenue and profits that resulted from its alleged wrongful conduct.
Microsoft said in a statement that it believes the suit is without merit.
"Customers understand the operating system and pre-installed applications reside on the device's internal storage thereby reducing the total free space," the company said. It noted that people can add storage via the microSD slot and USB port.
Microsoft confirmed on November 5 exactly how much usable storage space its Surface tablets come with out of the box. It says on its website that the 32 GB Surface has 16 GB of free space while the 64 GB version has 45 GB free. The Surface started selling October 26 and Sokolowski bought his device on November 7.
Sokolowski's lawyer, Rhett Francisco, said Wednesday that his client never saw Microsoft's responses and said the details on its website are "buried".
"They make you search and dig for it specifically, or you would never find it," he said.
It's common for mobile devices to have less usable storage space than advertised.
Flash drives and regular hard drives provide less usable memory than their labels say, mainly because there are two definitions of the word "gigabyte". That means that, right off the bat, consumers get about 7 percent less space than advertised. A 16 GB drive, for example, has about 15 GB available for use.
On flash drives, the kind used in tablets, another factor reduces the available storage further. A portion of the memory space is set aside to replace "cells" that wear out over time. For this reason, Apple's 16 GB iPad has an actual storage capacity that's 11 percent lower than the one advertised: 14.3 GB. The 64 GB model stores 57.2 GB.
On the iPad, all the storage space after the 11 percent "discount" is available for the user's photos, movies and apps. The operating system and Apple's pre-installed apps have their own, separate memory space. Microsoft's operating system and apps, in contrast, share memory space with the user.
Michael Gartenberg, research director for technology research firm Gartner, said Microsoft has consistently said there would be less memory available than is advertised. He said it is "unsurprising" that its new operating system and near full-blown version of Office take up a big chunk of the memory.
"I think they made it pretty clear to consumers what they're getting," he said.
And even if Microsoft's base-model Surface only has 16 GB of memory available, that's still slightly more than the 14.3 GB you'll get from the latest Wi-Fi only iPad for the same price of US$499.
Post a Comment
Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide
(Won't be published)
9/01/2013 12:04:55 p.m.
The comment about Apple's IOS having a separate storage space is not 100% accurate. The onboard flash in iPhones and iPads is partitioned with a system partition and a user data partition. However, the system partition still takes away space from the total flash size.
2/01/2013 9:46:33 a.m.
My opinion is this just another frivolous lawsuit. When you buy any computer the OS and Apps have to be stored somewhere. Sokolowski is nothing more than a troll.
15/11/2012 4:29:07 p.m.
Dont like the huge Microsoft OS? Dump it and run another. The OS lite version smaller too.As stated above, the GB size of storage is smaller than the Gb used by computers. Storage use 1000 units vs computers that use 1024 units.1kb = 1024 bytes with 1mb = 1024xkb and 1gb = 1024xmb. But those selling drive space use the 1000 units instead which is a measurable amount smaller.
The Whakatane Beacon has joined the Ashburton Guardian and the NBR in charging people who want to read its website.
Jill Valentine and Chris Redfield return in survival horror Resident Evil: Revelations, out now for home consoles.
Live-action trailer for Destiny directed by Jon Favreau and starring Giancarlo Esposito.
An Auckland car dealership has been sentenced for what Trade Me has called the biggest ghost bidding scam in the auction site's history.
In a medical first, doctors used plastic particles and a 3D laser printer to create an airway splint to save the life of a baby boy.
Copyright © 2013 MediaWorks TV. All Rights Reserved.