Teacher upset over 'F' word in school dictionary

Print

Fri, 24 Feb 2012 6:27p.m.

A Nelson teacher has found entries such as 'STFU' and RTFM in a school dictionary (file pic)

A Nelson teacher has found entries such as 'STFU' and RTFM in a school dictionary (file pic)

By Amanda Gillies

A Nelson teacher had to choose her words carefully when a student asked her to explain an entry in the school dictionary.

Lisa Shymkus was teaching her special needs class about spelling but was shocked to discover the Harper Collins dictionary contained two ‘f’ word references.

“I was absolutely appalled and shocked,” says Ms Shymkus

A special needs student brought in a Harper Collins dictionary and asked about some of the text abbreviations at the back - such as STFU, which immodestly ignores the F bit and then pretends RTFM stands for read the "flippin" manual.

Dictionary or not, Ms Shymkus was lost for words.

“They need to get this off, this is not appropriate. Shut up is very aggressive anyway, add the extra bit with F on it and, yeah, that's not what our standards are here,” she says.

Ms Shymkus wrote to HarperCollins in the UK and last night the commissioning and development editor replied, apologising for any offence.

“I must say I completely agree that these abbreviations do not belong in a school dictionary. I do not know how the former editors allowed this to go through. I will make a note of it and ensure they are removed at the next reprint,'' said the editor.

Harper Collins New Zealand told 3 News the dictionaries were imported from the UK and there was no editorial input here. Later in the day a spokeswoman rang back, saying she had looked at all the different editions of similar dictionaries in their warehouse and could not find the offensive page in question, but 3 News found editions at two Nelson book shops.

Dictionary editors cannot normally sneak in made-up or offensive words but from 1934 to 1947 a fake word ‘dord’ - appeared in a Merriam Webster dictionary.

And like these abbreviations, the word was eventually removed.

3 News

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

25 Feb 2012 09:43a.m.

Joey wrote:

You turn to a dictionary when you want to know the meaning of a word or acronym, and the four letter word that people are so freaked out about is a real actual word which is used quite a lot as we all know, and the various acronyms containing the word are in widespread use as well. It is obvious that these words should be in a dictionary. And remember, we should world-proof our children, rather than child-proof the world.

25 Feb 2012 05:40a.m.

Bluey wrote:

Go to many primary schools and definately secondary schools and you won't be hearing "flippin" you'll hear the actual word. Live with it, it is part of life..children & indeed adults will make their own choices about usage or not of such words but pretending they don't exist is flippin silly... PS Buggar & bloody aren't swear words in my books...

24 Feb 2012 09:48p.m.

Michael wrote:

As a teacher myself, I think Ms Shymkus is being rather too precious. The job of teachers is to educate, not to shield students from reality. If a dictionary includes the meanings of abbreviations, and if the meanings happen to include swear words, then I really don't see what the problem is. I think this is a case of a non-news story.

24 Feb 2012 08:12p.m.

Alex wrote:

Kids need to learn about this word so they know exactly what it means when they decide to use it and when it is inappropriate to use it.

24 Feb 2012 07:54p.m.

Erm... wrote:

Unfortunately that is what happens when standards and morals are allowed to erode. The police have made the word 'bloody' acceptable through their adverts. Toyota have made the word 'bugger' acceptable. The borders and boundaries will continue to be pushed while their are immoral advertisers and media dumb enough to let them get away with it.

24 Feb 2012 07:15p.m.

Rob wrote:

I take it FUBAR and SNAFU would really freak her out !!