3News » Home
Kim Dotcom
Full Story

TradeMe user accused of price fixing

6 comments | Post Comment email Email printer friendly Print    Text Size:
aA
aA
aA
TradeMe has chosen not to ban ‘pop 0071’

TradeMe has chosen not to ban ‘pop 0071’

video
Wed, 03 Feb 2010 6:10p.m.

By David Farrier

In the first case of its kind, the Commerce Commission has issued a formal warning to a TradeMe user over price fixing.

The Commission says Ernie Travers emailed a competing TradeMe seller, asking him to agree to sell his products for the same amount.

Mr Travers, who trades under the pseudonym ‘pop 0071’, specialises in LED lights, but his recent online activity has attracted some negative feedback from the Commerce Commission.

“This case is pretty unusual, it’s the first case we’re aware of and the first case the Commerce Commission has investigated to do with TradeMe,” says TradeMe spokesman Chris Budget.

The Commission has issued a formal warning to Mr Travers, saying he emailed another TradeMe user requesting they fix their prices on the LED lights they were both selling.

“Hey, how about instead of continually discounting these lights we agree to one price - $189 – and stick to it,” Mr Travers says in the email.

“I am sure we will both get a share of the market if we are both consistent on the price.”

Mr Travers told the Commission he never sent the email, but could not explain who had.

Consumers Institute CEO Suzanne Chetwin says it is a reminder that online selling is a serious business.

“I think it is a warning to those buying and selling, it is a sophisticated operation these days and it isn’t just people selling the stuff out of their garage or clearing out their houses,” she says.

TradeMe has chosen not to ban ‘pop 0071’.

“We feel the members had this warning, and a pretty strong one at that,” says Mr Budget.

“With publicity around it he has hopefully learnt his lesson. We are keeping an eye on his membership to make sure he doesn’t do anything naughty again. If he does, we will call him and talk to him about it.”

The Commerce Commission does not play to take any legal action, apparently wanting to make an example of this user and remind others that big brother is watching.

3 News

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Comments [6]

Jordan
03 Feb 2010 11:11p.m.

if you have a look at the CGA website it doesn't cover auctions... trademe is an auction site sadly any news site wont point this out as negitive news sells. yes it is price fixing and shouldn't be done but half the story is only 1 side shame nz news cant be positive once in a while

Alien
03 Feb 2010 9:45p.m.

ah, so people support people breaking the law as long as they are the "small people". So how can people complain when companies do it if you support these people doing it? The law is the law, and he broke it. Dayne, why does someone who is doing their job need to get a life or a new job. Perhaps you need to go learn what her job is and as for her life, are you stalking her?

Malcolm
03 Feb 2010 9:24p.m.

Bob is right on the mark
Why doesn't the Commerce Commission check out pre payed untraceable cell phones of middle management executives in the Oil Companies. They could find collusion going on every day. What about Telecom and Vodafone or the banks that charge $25.00 to send your money to Australia but only $10.00 to send it back to New Zealand. They are all sucking every Dollar out of the consumer they can- its called business

Sosoome
03 Feb 2010 8:44p.m.

Hi ALL, There is an easy way to deal with Mr Travers/pop0071, don't deal with him - I haven't yet and I won't in the future. Greg

dayne
03 Feb 2010 8:29p.m.

what alot of flippen crap!! Trademe members compete against one another to sell there products droping there prices lower and lower than another. I think Mr Travis did the right thing and tried to make an agreement to hold pricing. This is why all the registered business that pay over heads go bank rupt because of trademe members under cutting the market!!! Suzanne Chetwin needs to get abit more of a life. Or more a new job!!

Bob
03 Feb 2010 8:11p.m.

Its not like petrol companies don't do it..

Post a comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide here
Name:
Email: (Won't be published)
Comment:



3News Video 3News Audio