Ticketek slams Mallard's Homegrown scalping

Print

Thu, 16 Feb 2012 10:52a.m.

Labour MP Trevor Mallard says he originally intended to go to Homegrown (file)

Labour MP Trevor Mallard says he originally intended to go to Homegrown (file)

By Imogen Crispe

Labour MP Trevor Mallard denies he is a ticket scalper, despite revelations he sold four Homegrown tickets for a profit and that the on-sale was not his first.

The Hutt South MP sold four tickets to this weekend’s festival on auction site TradeMe for $656, or $164 each. The tickets have a face value of $95 each.

His TradeMe history shows he sold another four tickets to the same Wellington festival last year, and two in 2009. He also sold a Wellington Sevens ticket in 2009.

But Mr Mallard denies this was scalping.

“Scalping is buying tickets for the intention of selling them,” he says.

“I’ve bought them with the intention of going.”

Managing director of Ticketek Brendon Bainbridge says Ticketek was not happy about Mr Mallard selling the Homegrown tickets for a profit and in doing so Mr Mallard breached the website’s terms and conditions of sale.

The terms state that “tickets may not, without the prior written consent of Ticketek or the Seller, be resold at a premium” and if this happens the ticketholder could be refused entry to an event.

Mr Bainbridge says he does not have problems with people reselling tickets at face-value but advises people not to sell them for a profit.

“We think it’s terrible.”

Mr Mallard says he sometimes buys tickets, but then finds out he is not available.

“I quite often buy them when they first come online when I think I want to go to something, but I don’t always go.

“Sometimes I buy for a group of us and not everyone can come.”

Mr Mallard says he was intending to go to Homegrown this year, but a friend’s birthday celebration came up. In another case, he says it was a bike race that got in the way of him going.

Mr Mallard says he goes to concerts regularly.

“I do see a lot of New Zealand music.”

As Sports Minister in 2007, Mr Mallard initiated the Major Events Management Act which says scalpers can face a fine of $5000.

But Mr Mallard says this act only covers circumstances where international events have a “no scalping rule”.

The Act states “No person may, without the authorisation of the major event organiser, sell or trade a ticket to a major event activity for a value greater than the original sale price of that ticket”.

It also says the “substantial purpose” of the transaction should be to sell the ticket for more than the original ticket price.

Mr Bainbridge says Ticketek works with TradeMe to try and prevent it happening, and if they see a photo of the ticket they are able to void it.

He says Ticketek can ban people in breach from buying tickets on the site, but this rarely happens as it is too difficult to trace.

3 News

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

20 Feb 2012 07:35a.m.

Rod wrote:

Mallard or anyone else can try to justify his actions, make phoney cover-up excuses, or attempt to deny his scalping crimes but no matter what anyone says,Mallard broke the very law he created and his black and white paper trail with Ticketek and Trade Me records prove it. Quite simply, he got caught scalping. He broke the law. He should be prosecuted and fined $5,000.00 While true, it's difficult for Ticketek to trace other scalpers, they clearly caught Mallard scalping and he (bub242) should be banned for breach of Ticketeks policy. Corrupt officials have no place representing ANY New Zealanders!

17 Feb 2012 08:31a.m.

cherie wrote:

PhilB You are just muck raking. This isnt even news. Those young people are just trying to get their turn in the spotlight. Yes maybe he should of done buy now. But he was not scalping that is the issue here Scalping or not and in this case it is clear it is not, embarassing but NOT

16 Feb 2012 10:48p.m.

PhilB wrote:

Cherie - having sold several lots of tickets on TradeMe due to a change in circumstances I always do the right thing and put a buy now at my cost. Richard - Mallard's TradeMe name is bub242.

16 Feb 2012 07:46p.m.

Richard wrote:

Canb someone please tell me what Trevor Mallards TradeMe Profile Name is? As I'd like to look at what an MP has bought & sold.

16 Feb 2012 06:15p.m.

jack wrote:

What do you think the chances are of him having declared this 'cash' income in his income tax?

16 Feb 2012 06:00p.m.

Glrnn wrote:

What a rubbish story. He's one of husbands who have the right to sell tickets and use it who cares!

16 Feb 2012 03:06p.m.

Denny Crane wrote:

I think Trevor Mallard should be congratulated for maintaining the standards we the public have come to expect of our politicians. I wouldn't be surprised if the tickets were paid for using his taxpayer-funded allowance/credit card.

16 Feb 2012 02:06p.m.

Chris wrote:

'Sam / Cherie' the hypocrisy lies in the fact that in 2007 Mallard passed anti scalping policies. Whilst other 'normal' people can do it - it's not a good look for a law maker and minister who passed legislation against the very thing he is doing.

16 Feb 2012 01:24p.m.

Ruz wrote:

If Mallard was not interested in making a profit then he could have easily put a "buy now" price on TradeMe for the face value of the tickets. They would have sold instantly to the first person to take up the offer.

16 Feb 2012 01:00p.m.

penny wrote:

Um, Nick - Mallard isn't on the same side as Key ... he's a Labour MP.