3News » Home
Full Story

Tobacco company fronts at select committee

6 comments | Post Comment email Email printer friendly Print    Text Size:
aA
aA
aA
Smoking is a huge drain on the health system

Smoking is a huge drain on the health system

video
Thu, 11 Mar 2010 4:58p.m.

By Melissa Davies

A tobacco company manager has admitted nicotine is addictive and said no cigarette is safe.

British American Tobacco (BAT) faced a barrage of questions at the Maori Affairs select committee into smoking. They defended their own marketing strategies, but said black market traders and dodgy retailers were spoiling the industry.

Where there's smoke, there's fire, and it didn't take long for the panel to fire up at the company which produces 70 percent of this country's tobacco.

But BAT's Graeme Amey says the company does not support youth smoking.

"It is not our position to market to youth," he said. "It is not our position to supply to youth, and it is not our position that youth should smoke."

Mr Amey urged a crackdown on the illicit trading of grow-your-own tobacco, because it isn't regulated - a suggestion met with scepticism.

"To focus on the illicit trade seems, to me anyhow, to smack of commercialisation, of trying to pick your competition," says Labour MP Parekura Horomia.

BAT opposes shops hiding tobacco displays, because they say customers should be able to see the range in case they want to switch brands.

Mr Amey has switched himself - he used to smoke, but has given up. 

"I smoked for 10 years and I made a personal choice to give up smoking."

When asked if he quit for health reasons, Mr Amey dodged the question.

"It's just one of those things. I smoked for 10 years and I just wanted to give up."

BAT acknowledged that between 75 and 90 percent of smokers start before the age of 18. In fact, the average age New Zealanders say they began to smoke is just 14-and-a-half.

3 News

 

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Comments [6]

David
15 Mar 2010 9:20a.m.

Smoking tobacco contributes to poor health, to do so is comparable to a game of russian roulette, not the sort of odds anyone should play. Lightseed the problem is many are not aware of the risks when they start and are usually hooked to the habit by the time they do. However a ban has been used before, other problems and I am not convinced this is the magic cure wished for.

Jon
12 Mar 2010 9:45a.m.

yeah, ummm, Lightseed, so you are suggesting that tobacco is so addictive that everyday law-abiding people would be happy to deal with gangs to get hold of it? If tobacco has that much control over people then it definitely shouldn't be sold in supermarkets and dairies, and must surely cause a lot of today's under 18 smokers to commit crime to get their hands on it. Tell me how do the benefits of tobacco outweigh the damage it causes? Why should tobacco be legal?

Dave
11 Mar 2010 10:25p.m.

People shouldn't have to be told that cigarettes are addictive or hazardous...except for, perhaps, the ones who are incapable of thinking for themselves. Furthermore, why should the tobacco companies become scapegoats in a campaign which essentially argues that consumers are simply stupid, regardless of whether those who promote it intentionally do so with this very premise in mind?

Lightseed
11 Mar 2010 8:40p.m.

yeah, ummm, Ruz, you do realise that if tobacco was ever banned it would then be taken over by the gangs, and would be the next drug that gangs hold the country ransom to? People are adults, they know the dangers of smoking, if they decide to smoke then that is their decision.

MrMan
11 Mar 2010 8:20p.m.

I started smoking at aged 12 and smoked for 15 years i just recently gave up I used to patch's they really work! only thing is the first 2 months is very hard but once you get past those first months its so easy Ive been off smoking for just over 1 year now. And feeling better for it. Its never to late to quit

Ruz
11 Mar 2010 7:05p.m.

It's pleasing to see the Maori Affairs Select Committee get stuck into the tobacco companies. The sooner tobacco products are banned from sale the better off we will be.

Post a comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide here
Name:
Email: (Won't be published)
Comment:



3News Video 3News Audio

Post your opinion

3News - What changes would you make to MMP?
The Govt and lobby groups are urging people to have their say on
Comments (7)