3News » Home
3 News Video On Demand
Rate:
5 ratings
Views: 6030

Tobacco industry whistleblower talks to Campbell Live - Video

Mon, 21 Jun 2010 19:00
Dr Jeffrey Wigand is in New Zealand this week to address the Maori select committee as it makes an inquiry into the tobacco industry. - read full story »
Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Comments [3]

Licere
28 Jun 2010 8:34p.m.

Nowhere in this segment does he state that prohibition is the option he endorses - that is what a reporter has interpreted from his words. The final comment is "until they are extinguished by regulating them out of business" accounts for the fact that smokers should not be held primarily accountable for the harm done (since they do not manufacture and distribute tobacco).

However, there is a problem to be addressed - the preventable illness and death that results from smoking, and it's not acceptable to maintain the status quo. The 'physiological response' indicates that smoking imposes a prohibition on the vital function of breathing.

Go back and take in the interview again, and focus especially on the part after Hitler's name is mentioned, listening for the various examples of sinister conduct outlined.

David
27 Jun 2010 2:51p.m.

Still, anybody who believes prohibition is the next logical step in the war on tobacco needs their head read. So many calls for tobacco to be banned, yet so many more ill-informed opinions that instigated them. Prohibition was and is a complete failure from it's conception, as the war on drugs and the prohibition era of the United States will testify to.

Licere
21 Jun 2010 9:39p.m.

Good work John - I notice that for the 5.5 mins of the item, you really only had to ask a couple of questions, make a couple of comments, and your guest responded in a clear, decisive & engaging manner.
Viewers can contrast Dr Wigand's authoritative comments with the deception expressed in TVNZ's 'AD show' by one of their guests this past week about BAT as a 'great' company who governments had to work with to reduce tobacco harm (..Bullsh**).

Post a comment

Name:
Email: (Won't be published)
Comment:
Change Category 
Change Category 

Most Popular

3News - Wayne Tempero walks John Campbell through the events on January 20

Campbell Live enters Kim Dotcom's Coatesville mansion video

currently playing Kim Dotcom's head of security, Wayne Tempero, walks John Campbell through t...
3News - Assistant Police Commissioner Malcolm Burgess

Police defend actions during Dotcom raid video

currently playing Campbell Live talks to Assistant Police Commissioner Malcolm Burgess, who s...
3News - Will the food bill affect you?

New law worries small-time food outlets video

currently playing Anyone who sells, barters, or even gives away food will soon have to get th...
3News - Piri Weepu with daughter Taylor

Piri Weepu bottle-feeding daughter blasted as 'inappropriate' video

currently playing Earlier this year All Black Piri Weepu gave up his time to take part in a S...