3News » Home
Full Story

Twilight Saga: New Moon review

12 comments | Post Comment email Email printer friendly Print    Text Size:
aA
aA
aA
Twilight's Kristen Stewart and Robert Pattinson

Twilight's Kristen Stewart and Robert Pattinson

video
Sat, 21 Nov 2009 1:20p.m.

Reviewed by Kate Rodger

I said this about Twilight and I will say it again about New Moon; this really is one of those movies where there is almost no point reviewing it. Nothing that I nor anyone else says will stop the fans turning this into an enormous hit!

The passion of these fans cannot be underestimated, this is a beloved story and beware any filmmaker who chooses to mess with that story.

New Moon is of course the second of the Twilight Saga books, and its cinematic adaptation comes with the same core cast, this time under the guidance of a different director, Chris Weitz (The Golden Compass). As you might expect, that change is key.

Weitz is a big picture man, and his CGI experience certainly comes in handy -we're dealing in werewolves after all.

There is a good deal of plot to get through here, and his attention to detail will undoubtedly please fans, along with some bare-chested action from both Team Jacob and Team Edward.

Robert Pattinson's Edward Cullen takes more a backseat in this story, but the filmmakers are careful to ensure the Box Office pulling power of pin-up Pattinson is still maximized. And then there is the fleshing out, so to speak, of Taylor Lautner's role of Jacob Black.

The central character of Bella Swan (Kristen Stewart) has much more on her plate this time around, what with vampires and werewolves to contend with along with all the usual challenges of being a teenager. Stewart is a star performer, and I look forward to seeing what she has in store for us when she grows up.

Really showing the younglings how it's done is classy Welsh actor Michael Sheen (Frost/Nixon). His outing as head nasty on Team Vampire doesn't get nearly enough screen time for my liking, his "Aro" is the only one really worth having nightmares over.

Sheen aside, the second Twilight movie just lacked the impact of its predecessor, and while the two hour ten minute duration may please fans, it was too long for me.

The CGI translated well, and there were a couple of pleasing werewolf smack-downs, but the overall tone of the film was far less intense, moody and menacing than the story required.

Two and a half stars.

    The Twilight Saga: New Moon
:: Director: Chris Weitz
:: Starring: Kristen Stewart, Robert Pattinson, Taylor Lautner, Michael Sheen, Dakota Fanning
:: Running Time: 132 mins
:: Rating: M - Supernatural Themes & Violence
:: Release Date: November 19, 2009
:: Trailer: Click here

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Comments [12]

Ella
29 Nov 2009 6:00p.m.

i havent gone yet bcause of all the teenager girlz dat r ther and scream during da frigen movie so im not goin till it dies down and those sh*t teen ggurls bac off

Lucy
28 Nov 2009 8:05p.m.

I dont care what the reviewers say. New Moon was awesome :) and it doesnt matter how old or young you are there are so many fans out there that love this movie. Next time they should send someone who likes to watch movies like this to review the movie!! Then it would be a fair review. 5 Stars

cheryl brown
27 Nov 2009 9:56a.m.

I love the movie, and i am a twifan and love the books, i am seeing the movie again today for the 3rd time, never have i every done that with a movie, it was very close to the book and in some cases better then the book

riley
26 Nov 2009 6:46p.m.

Most people seeing new moon have their background info down from either reading the books or seeing twilight. I loved New Moon. Also, keep in mind the book new moon is very long and complex I think the movie summed everything up very well not to mention the cherry on top being the werewolves. This is definately a movie for the fans but also something others can enjoy as well. New Moon has a great cast and they portayed their characters on screen very well. I'm so excited for Eclipse and Breaking Dawn.

jane
26 Nov 2009 3:04p.m.

me and my friend dani are very dissapointed at the reviews that have been published. it is obvious that you should have sent a teenage reveiwer to a teenager film as you obviously missed the whole plot and we think you should grow down (because your too old) and go get a life

TEAM JACOB 4 LYF!

hannah
26 Nov 2009 8:47a.m.

I loved the movie!!!!!!!!!

Karen
24 Nov 2009 5:35p.m.

2.5 stars is not too bad - she's saying it is half as good as it could have possibly been (like 50%). Which I think is kind. I liked the first film quite a bit, but this one was just so boring. Bella is such a boring character and I hate her anti-feminist tendencies which were so strong in this film. Still, the guys were hot and it was a bit of trashy fun. I would give it 2 stars.

Claire
24 Nov 2009 1:39p.m.

I think this is a fair review. I absolutely LOVE the books, but the movie failed to hit the spot for me. I don't see how anyone who hadn't read the books would get into it. In saying this, I felt the same way after watching Twilight the first time. Maybe it might get better after another watch. In any event the film will always have trouble matching up to the books, they're just so well written and will always draw the crowds, whether or not the movie is crap or not. Looking forward to Eclipse and Breaking Dawn, massive action and fights in that one!

Leonee
23 Nov 2009 10:25a.m.

I loved the movie especially with all the hot werewolfs she can find a new job

Nicole
22 Nov 2009 6:14p.m.

I tend to always disagree with Kate's reviews.
She did mention that it does not matter what anyone says about New moon, it will be a hit regardless. I felt that the film offers a great visual representation of the book, and to fans, this is all that matters.
5 stars.

Post a comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide here
Name:
Email: (Won't be published)
Comment:



3News Video 3News Audio