Wairarapa neighbours at war over stink

Print

Sun, 29 May 2011 6:31p.m.

Disputed complaints about smell are just the beginning

Disputed complaints about smell are just the beginning

By Dan Parker

There's a growing stink in the country's daffodil capital and it isn't the sweet smell of flowers. It's silage, fermented, high-moisture fodder, the focus of a draft by-law which if passed could force the Carterton region's farmers to rearrange their properties.

“It's fair to say that there is one person that's involved more than anyone else,” says mayor Ron Mark.

That person is Phillip Engel. His silage is the source of the problem, it's piled up in close proximity to a number of his neighbours' homes. The bylaw would force Engel to move it 150 metres away.

“The further it has to be hauled, the more costly it is, access is paramount,” says Mr Engel.

Disputed complaints about smell are just the beginning. No neighbours would appear on camera but one gave 3 News video of what he calls a noisy and inconsiderate around the clock operation.

Federated Farmers’ Carterton president Paul McGill says this is an important lesson about getting on, because the draft bylaw could be negated with written consent from the neighbours.

“It seems to be a case of trying to solve a neighbourhood dispute rather than the actual silage bylaw itself,” he says.

McGill believe the bylaw is unnecessary bureaucracy that punishes all farmers because of the actions of one.

3 News

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

31 May 2011 07:29p.m.

Graeme wrote:

Why don't they pull their heads in.Go move into town!

30 May 2011 08:24p.m.

Tom wrote:

I have been farming in this community for many years. I am disappointed to see that once again the Engel family are causing havoc! The owners Chris and Jude Engel are unable to control their manager Philip Engel who is responsible for purposely trying to upset neighbors by putting silage stacks hard up against their boundaries. It must be awful living next door to these people when they are feeding out at 2am in the morning! These people are mis-representing the farming community. Their farming practice is not normal!

30 May 2011 08:13p.m.

Joe wrote:

These people are nothing but trouble. Not sure why Hania Engel would be making comments as she tried to charge the Engel family with assault last month It was written in the times-age paper!

30 May 2011 12:55p.m.

Hania Engel wrote:

I think that you guys did a terribly job with this report, It has nothing to do with a neighbour dispute. it is againist the law to create a bylaw when it contradicts the human rights, One family is obviously targeted, and the Carterton council will be going against the bill of rights, and it is unreasonable, 2 things of which can stop a bylaw from taking affect. That is what the stroy is about. Dan Parker do your job better its called research!