Wellsford dog massacre trial begins

Print

Mon, 19 Sep 2011 6:25a.m.

It was a grisly scene at Rowan Hargreaves' northern Auckland farm in January last year

It was a grisly scene at Rowan Hargreaves' northern Auckland farm in January last year

By Kim Choe

A trial is scheduled to get underway today for the two men accused of shooting dead 33 dogs in Wellsford last year.

Russell Mendoza and Tony Campbell have pleaded not guilty to multiple charges including wilful ill-treatment of an animal and reckless use of a firearm.

It was a grisly scene at Rowan Hargreaves' northern Auckland farm in January last year, after two of his neighbours allegedly shot dead 33 of his dogs.

"I just can't comprehend," Mr Hargreaves told 3 News at the time. "It's not my life anymore. I'm looking through someone else's eyes."

The two accused said they were just doing what Mr Hargreaves agreed to after one of his dogs was seen attacking Mendoza's fox terrier.

"He signed the piece of paper under no duress," says Mendoza's friend, Maree. "He was also requested if there were any particular dogs that he wanted to keep, and he simply replied, "No. They've all got to go, shoot them all."

Mr Hargreaves admitted he'd asked for the dogs to be put down, but not in such a frenzied manner - and said he wanted to see the men jailed.

"It's their action, their choice," says Mr Hargreaves. "They picked up the gun, they pulled the trigger. They did these actions, end of story. Their choice. They live by their choices. I live by mine.

"I let my dogs die, but I expect it to be done humanely."

The massacre shocked the Wellsford community and the SPCA, who said the dogs were healthy and well-looked after.
"I'm sad for Mr Hargreaves, and angry that someone could do this to someone else's animals," says neighbour Moana Prictor.

"He shouted at the shooters, 'Do it properly! Do it properly! Let them out,'" says the SPCA's Vicki Border.

"The shooters ignored his plea. One of the injured dogs went to bite the nose of the rifle. The shooter blew its head off."

Campbell and Mendoza have chosen to be tried by a jury.

3 News

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Post a Comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide


(Won't be published)



Comments

23 Apr 2012 05:48p.m.

Michelle wrote:

RE: Tim Jones. The Inspector was from the Otaki area LLoyd Warren (a former baker/bread maker) who killed the cat. The vet who worked for that SPCA quit after this incident due to the horrific nature of the killing. A relation is a former SPCA inspector and said that this large gun pointed at the cat's head would have caused immense distress just before it was shot. Chances are that there were not other staff around and Warren said that he was due to go on holiday for 10 days. The vet who resigned was due to desex the cat the next day. It was in for desexing and the owner had already paid for desexing. The SPCA initially told her that Janie the had run away but then admitted what Warren had really done. The SPCA should have dismissed him but would not.

23 Apr 2012 07:34a.m.

easy goin' wrote:

Will be interesting to see the dog-lover language talk of 'murder' 'massacre' 'family' - it will be made to be worse than the Norway Island massacre. Get real. They were mongrel dogs, badly kept overcrowded, and un-registered. Their owner is the sort of person dog-owners were complaining about in the Auckland super-city dog reg-fee increase - keeping multiple uncontrolled dogs. Hope the case it dropped as a total time and tax-payer waste of time.

03 Oct 2011 09:29p.m.

tim jones wrote:

No option but to let them go. A gun kills. An inspector called Lloyd Warren from Auckland Office put a cat to sleep by using a captive bolt like they kill cows in freezing works. Now that is crueler than shooting them. How did that border lady know what he said if she was not there when they were shot....hearsay gossip.

24 Sep 2011 07:26a.m.

larry smith wrote:

ALL THREE OF THEM SHOULD BE JAILED FOR A LONG TIME ! THE OWNER IS JUST AS BAD AND COULD NEVER HAVE LOVED THEM BECAUSE IF HE DID HE WOULD HAVE NEVER AGREED TO THIS !!!

20 Sep 2011 11:36a.m.

West wrote:

Don't drop the soap.

19 Sep 2011 09:35a.m.

ursi wrote:

I hope they go to jail for a long time........Horrible thing they did ......I am happy they are not my neighbors....

19 Sep 2011 09:03a.m.

Nick wrote:

Send all three to jail.