3News » Home

Woman puts cat in bin - why?

Lola the cat Lola the cat
Thu, 26 Aug 2010 9:40a.m.

By Kim Chisnall

Ever had the urge to throw a cat into a wheelie bin?

No, me neither. But Coventry spinster Mary Bale was caught doing just that on a CCTV camera.

In the video Ms Bale stops to pat the cat and then glancing behind her she spots the bin. She looks up and down the street, clearly making sure she's not being watched, before lifting the lid and dumping tabby cat Lola inside. Closing the lid, Ms Bale walks quickly away.

It was 15 hours before Lola was discovered by her owners Darryl and Stephanie Andrews-Mann. The couple installed a CCTV camera two years ago after their car was repeatedly knocked by careless drivers. When they checked the tape they discovered just how Lola got into the bin.

They posted the video on facebook and soon Ms Bale was identified. She's been questioned by the RSPCA and will possibly face animal cruelty charges.

In animal loving groups, Bale is now a figure of hate. She's received death threats and a "Death to Mary Bale" Facebook page has been removed. She is currently under police protection.

What possessed the 45-year-old bank worker to do this? In a statement Ms Bale says she can't explain it, that it was completely out of character and amounted to a split second of misjudgement.

She told The Sun newspaper that it was a joke. Really Ms Bale? You were walking down the street by yourself, nobody saw you do it, you weren't egged on by your mates. Somehow I just can't see her walking away chuckling to herself.

In the six years I've been working as a journalist it's the cases of animal cruelty that I remember the most. Fresh out of journalism school, I was working at the Marlborough Express when I got a call from the SPCA. They'd discovered a puppy that had been beaten to death and left on the roadside. I took a photographer with me, but there was no way we could put the picture of that poor animal in the paper. Nevertheless, the officer insisted that I took a good long look. I can still see the tiny scrap of a dog, covered in blood on the concrete floor of the pound.

Then there was the Huntly cat killings. Two teenagers who poured highly flammable glue on to three feral cats and then flicked a lighter. The cats were caught in a council trap so there was no escape. Like Ms Bale their act was caught on CCTV and the two teenagers were sentenced to nine months in prison for aggravated cruelty to animals.

I was in court the day they pleaded guilty. Remorse was in short supply; they swaggered in and began gesturing and posturing for the camera. They were smiling and laughing to each other like it was all one big joke.

Maybe that's why I got so annoyed when I heard Ms Bale justify her behaviour as a "joke". A three-year-old child might think it's funny to pull the wings off a butterfly, but then they don't know any better. At 45, Mary Bale is a bit old for that excuse.

Melissa Davies is based in London as TV3's Europe Correspondent. When she's not travelling all over the continent, she is slowly adjusting to life in the northern hemisphere.

 

Here she documents her life reporting abroad.

 

 

Comments [7]

John Davis
24 Oct 2010 04:15p.m.

I hate it when cats crap in my garden(and dogs on my lawn when people take their dog for a sh** i mean a walk) but ffs cats are free roaming animals thats what they do, if you dont want them to do it its up to you to prevent them from doing it in your garden, short of locking a cat indoors for its entire life, given its nature its very hard to prevent ones cat from crapping in other peoples gardens.

One has issues of self entitlement and lack of empathy if one thinks cat cruelty is ok, they are cats they dont know any better, we have been domesticated for far longer than they have been, give them a break ffs.

Irresponsible yeah right.. the responsible thing to do would be to accept reality for what it is and plan to prevent it from happening to your garden.

for the record i think pets are a waste of time.





Tony
21 Oct 2010 05:40p.m.

I'm not a cat lover but considering they are living beings and most probibly have feelings aswell, I really think she deserves everything she gets.

And for the people saying they are annoyed at cats crapping in there gardens.....Honestly are you that single minded? its a garden with dirt and bugs and outside. The human race dumps millions of tons of human waste into water ways and oceans everyday, what about the living species that have to put up with turds floating past them on a regular bases.

You people go to the toilet do your business and flush the chain...easy right? well unfortunitly cats and other animals don't have the choice or luxury

Jess Monk
20 Oct 2010 07:31p.m.

What's with this "perspective" business? Note how perspective is really YOUR perspective. Imagine, just for the sheer fact you are a human and CAN imagine, you are born into some other species. And then maybe try to imagine that you take a shit in the loo - perfectly normal right, and all the while, some other more powerful species, wants to abuse you for it, hurt you even. Perspective could involve not being quite so precious about catshit. If only we could get some humanoid insight into how most marine life feels about our sewage being pumped into the ocean - oh the hypocracy! Ok, so you are all-powerful human, lucky you. There's nothing worse than the powerful NOT deigning to show some kindness/understanding and or sheer compassion to others less fortunate. I hope there are karmic rewards - only for you.

scott t
28 Aug 2010 10:43p.m.

How can people get so concerned about cats crapping in their garden? do you realise how many animals or entire species were displaced so that your house could be their, more than a little inconvenient I think.

Nick
27 Aug 2010 10:49p.m.

I think we live in a cat worshiping nation for starters. Where the life of a cat is worth more than the life of a human. She just put it in a bin, not set fire to it, and people want to kill her over that! We have somewhere around 5 cats, well they belong to our neighbors actually, our place is their toilet. Many a time I think about doing ALOT worse things to their cats than putting them in a bin, sometimes to their careless self-centered arrogant owners too!

argie
27 Aug 2010 04:54p.m.

well no,but i do get really annoyed when cats decide to do their business in my garden [i'm not a cat lover],instead of their owners garden [and of course the cats owners dont give a toss].it always amazes me how people get so wound up with stories like this,yet will be so blazey about the poor old couple who got run down and killed by some wanker disqualified driver.people today need to get some perspective back in their lives

Mackles
26 Aug 2010 12:26p.m.

Ever had the urge to throw a cat into a wheelie bin? Yes. Many times. Along with their irresponsible owners.

Post a comment

Name:
Email: (Won't be published)
Comment:


3News Video 3News Audio

Blogs