3News » Home
Full Story

Psychologist condemns execution of 'mentally ill' British man

10 comments | Post Comment email Email printer friendly Print    Text Size:
aA
aA
aA
Dr Peter Schaapveld

Dr Peter Schaapveld

video
Wed, 30 Dec 2009 5:40p.m.

By Jane Luscombe

An Auckland psychologist has denounced the Chinese authorities for executing a British man, believed to be mentally ill.

UK foreign officials rushed Dr Peter Schaapveld to China to try to assess Akmal Ahaikh, but he was twice prevented from meeting the condemned man.

Akmal Shaikh was being held in a detention centre in North West China for smuggling heroin.

The Aucklander never got to carry out a face-to-face assessment of the Briton before he was executed, but he is convinced he was suffering a severe mental disorder.

Peter Schaapveld told ITV that Mr Shaik was probably going through a manic phase in which his ability to think rationally, control his impulses, and think through the consequences of his actions was severely compromised.

Mr Schaapveld trained in psychology at Auckland University, but now lives in the UK.

He was asked in March by the legal charity Reprieve to assess Mr Shaikh's mental state from written reports.

Then the British Foreign Office flew Mr Schaapveld to the jail in Urumqi to meet the prisoner.

Speaking to 3 News by phone, Mr Schaapveld said he tried to visit the 53-year-old twice. Each time he was turned away at the last minute.

He said, “In what appeared to be the reasons almost made up on the spot, which was curious given the fact that I was given the green light all the way from London to Urumqi."

China has signed up to United Nations protocols that call for clemency for anyone with a mental illness who is facing the death penalty.

But it refused to carry out an assessment of his mental state and chose to ignore pleas from the British Prime Minister Gordon Brown.

Instead, the Chinese were furious at interference from the west.

The Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman, Jiang Yu, said no one has the right to interfere with the judicial sovereignty of China. Combating drug dealing is the common will of all people.

Mr Schaapveld spoke to Mr Shaikh's family after he was given a lethal injection yesterday.

He said, “It is, in their view, and I would share this, an absolutely appalling situation.”

Akmal Shaik was the first European to be executed by the Chinese in nearly 60 years.

3 News

Become a fan of 3 News on Facebook and on Twitter.

Comments [10]

hanyulr
01 Jan 2010 8:28p.m.

i dont know he is real mental illness or ...
but one thing is for sure ,the drug dealer is mental ill as he pass 10 million dollars heroin to a mental ill guy....what happen if he eat it

hanyulr
31 Dec 2009 9:38p.m.

4kg Purity is 80%.drug in the market Purity normally is 40%.so,this 4kg Purity80% can make up to 8kg heroin.worth 10 million us dollars.ask 1.3 billions chinese he should be ex or not.i think the answer will be yes.

hanyulr
31 Dec 2009 5:09p.m.

same case happen in singapore and indonesian,two australian, one excutive,one go to jail for 15 year.they both claim they dont know why the drug in their bag.what a old style excuse

Jill
31 Dec 2009 2:20p.m.

We should believe the british didn't sexy up the medical report? Yea right! Only a mental will believe the words of a shrink sent by the british.

Allan K
31 Dec 2009 12:40p.m.

The comments on here are a graphic, if sad, demonstration of the lack of understanding in society about mental illness.

No Drug Smuggling
31 Dec 2009 1:45a.m.

If Akmal was not executed, every drug smuggler can use so called "mental illness" as a defence for getting lighter punishment. "bipolar disorder"? What a joke! You carried 4.03kg heroin, how many people you want to kill? The answer is tens of thousands! Why should they forgive you?

UK JP
30 Dec 2009 10:48p.m.

UK Dave - get a grip!

Clark
30 Dec 2009 9:20p.m.

well, he should not be treated as anybody else who committed such a crime. he should be released because he is an European. am I right? -- A Chinese.

Richard
30 Dec 2009 7:47p.m.

The chinese dont fall for the western rubbish when they are faced with a criminal, we in the west are soft, china doesnt stand for the crap we do..yehaaa

UK Dave
30 Dec 2009 7:42p.m.

I seem to remember not so long ago an advert here in NZ featuring "Aubry" a bloke who suffered the mental illness of Bipolar disorder, if i remember correctly the advert was saying that bipolar sufferers were just normal folks with a few problems and they needed to be treated "just like the rest of us" ......ah that is until they get caught with 4kg of white stuff - in China - Nuff said ?

Post a comment

Before commenting, please take the time to read our moderation guide here
Name:
Email: (Won't be published)
Comment:



3News Video 3News Audio

Post your opinion